Cancel

    Open app

    Search

    Treasure Hill Farm

    5.0 (1 review)
    Open • Open 24 hours

    Treasure Hill Farm Photos

    You might also consider

    Recommended Reviews - Treasure Hill Farm

    Your trust is our priority, so businesses can't pay to alter or remove their reviews. Learn more about reviews.
    Yelp app icon
    Browse more easily on the app
    Review Feed Illustration

    7 years ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    Verify this business for free

    People searched for Horseback Riding 169 times last month within 15 miles of this business.

    Verify this business

    Rita's Stable

    Rita's Stable

    3.9(28 reviews)
    36.7 mi

    This doesn't look open but it is. We dropped by late in the afternoon as Rita was cleaning out the…read morebarn but she was happy to answer my kids' questions and let us wander around patting the animals (we did not ask about a pony ride.) All the animals are very friendly, including Henrietta the chicken who gently pecks at you to demand a pat (who knew chickens were so snuggly?!) My kids really enjoyed the relaxed no hype time and want to go back right away. Be careful driving in and backing out. The animals are free range and Henrietta often leads them out to greet arriving cars.

    My wife and I drove past Rita's while exploring Montauk on a rainy day. We called back the…read morefollowing morning to ask about trail rides. Easy enough process and we were booked for the afternoon. Things were running a little late but no big deal by us - we passed the time in the area and headed back. We killed another 10 minutes petting the very friendly goats wandering about before getting saddled up for a ride. Our guide was a very young but very knowledgeable girl our from NYC for the summer. She was so sweet and my wife chatted with her about horses the entire time we walked the trails. Wise beyond her years is an understatement. She was a joy and we're both terribly sorry we didn't seem to catch her name. The trail was easy and quiet. We trotted a few times and our guide checked on us every 5-7 minutes to make sure we were comfortable and feeling good. She noticed my saddle slipped right away and guided me through fixing it. Total pro! We did an hour - it was a bit much for me after around 40 minutes but I'm not an experienced rider so maybe that's why. The trail is a loop so don't expect a full hour of unique sights. However, we really found it peaceful and enjoyable. It was $75/each which we felt was fair. Two tips: 1. Cash only, so bring enough! 2. Tip your guide!

    Photos
    Rita's Stable
    Rita's Stable
    Rita's Stable - The stable

    See all

    The stable

    Deep Hollow Ranch Beach & Trail Rides

    Deep Hollow Ranch Beach & Trail Rides

    3.5(59 reviews)
    37.0 mi

    I booked the 1.5hr ride to the beach and back for my boyfriend and I. I'm an experienced rider and…read morehe hasn't ridden a horse since he was a child, so we were hoping for a little more instruction for him other than "pull back to stop and kick to go". We were already on the horses for 5min before the guide stopped, introduced himself and asked if it was anyone's first time on a horse before (little late to be asking that!). Due to his thick accent, it was also extremely difficult to understand him when he was shouting instructions from the back of a horse. The trail itself was extremely rocky and the horses were frequently smashing their hooves/slipping on the rocky terrain. Our guide was always 2 horse lengths ahead of the group with another rider, so if something had happened while riding and we needed immediate assistance, we would have had to yell for him to stop. We were with an inexperienced group of riders, so we trotted one time and then never tried again. The oddest thing was after the ride. The guide took a couple quick pictures of each group while on the beach and told us to leave our number so he could send us the pictures afterwards. We did, bought a hat from them and left. Then my boyfriend received a message via Venmo from the business "reminding that we haven't received a tip from you for your ride and we accept tips via Venmo". Two days went by and still no pictures. I messaged them on Instagram and got no reply. The following day I called and asked if the pictures could be sent to me and was told she would let our guide (Carvel) know to send them. I then received texts from someone who was obviously Carvel himself telling me again he still hadn't received a tip from us. I asked if it was required to leave a tip in order to receive the pictures and he said "did not say that- but Carvel took the photos on his personal phone which he did not have to do so we believe he deserves a tip." Carvel never asked for my phone to take the pictures which I would have happily provided if asked. We finally got the pictures after I sent a string of angry messages. After paying over $400 for the ride and the hat, I never expected to have to harass the business multiple times for three pictures that were taken in a rush. I do not recommend this experience.

    After 3 hour drive, checked the website where no where did it state we needed a reservation to…read moreride... came to the ranch and was denied at 1:50 pm. Website states closes at 4 pm. We wanted a half hour ride but because no one booked, they start de-Satteling early?? Then a family of 5 came after us, all denied. That's 7 customers. It's a shame. Should really change website. Wasted my gas, and time. At 150pm, for 30 mins, there should be no issue on giving us a ride especially when there's no bookings.

    Photos
    Deep Hollow Ranch Beach & Trail Rides
    Deep Hollow Ranch Beach & Trail Rides
    Deep Hollow Ranch Beach & Trail Rides

    See all

    Treasure Hill Farm - horsebackriding - Updated October 2026

    Loading...
    Loading...
    Loading...