Pros: Dirty, potholed, no railings, full of tourists and minorities. If you are looking for a posh destination, this is not it. Please stay away. Please do not convert my favorite spot into a spot like every other sanitized spot in America.
First, the lack of railings enables you to feel the wind in your face, to feel the closeness of the ocean, and generally to get a little of that feeling you get standing on a rock over the ocean. If you dont like that, try Pier 39. It has railings and is very safe.
The tourists are happy people. They are on holidays. They remind you just how blessed you are to be crabbing on this pier. They spend thousands of dollars to spend just 20 minutes at a place where you are crabbing for hours. The families with kids bring adorable boys who peer into your bucket and recoil with an "Ew!!!!" or a "Eek!", depending on whether your catch is slimy or waving a sharp claw. The look on their face, and on their parents seeing their kids reactions, is priceless. You want a "fishing vibe"? Go to Pacifica. I love the tourists. I love talking to people from all over the world.
The potholes, the oil stains, the seaweed - this is a pier. These things are what make piers, well, piers. If you were to rip it up, you would be ripping up the tramlines where the torpedoes were brought out of the sheds to load onto the submarines in WWII. Please do not do that.
The sealions are a menace, and one or two of the Pelicans can be downright scary. The seagulls defecate over everything. Yes, thats why I'm here and not in a strip mall. I like seeing nature face to face on its own terms.
The minorities remind me that some people get their pleasures cheap, and perhaps dinner. It reminds me that this is how all our ancestors used to live. And when you sit and watch them, and their families, and talk to them, you realize that we are all the same.
So whether you come here to meet the locals, the local wildlife or the tourists, remember that you are in one of the few places where you can interface with these all in one place, each on their own terms, and all in one of the best natural settings that the earth has to offer.
If you like your pleasures sanitized, please stay at Pier 39 or other sanitized location. Somewhere where a sealion is something to take pictures of, not something you try and wrestle your trap up in time so he doesnt steal your dinner.
Oh - and you cant catch the Dungeness crab here, because apparently the size limits are not enough to protect the baby crabs (2-3 inches) as they move to the sea. Personally, I think the size limits DO protect the breeding space, but it forces people onto tourist boats if they want to catch them - or to buy them from corporate fishing boats that clean out entire areas in days. Far better to allow Dungeness to be caught (under the usual size guidelines) and to cut the commercial season or quota (do they even have a quota?) by a few percent to compensate. They could even rent out crab traps to the tourists to give them happy memories. Too much common sense?
One thing that infuriates me. The barrier between the golden gate road and the car park. If I come down and find the few spaces near the huts taken, I have to drive 2 miles to the Marina and back, polluting and spitting out CO2 as I go, and clogging the roads. Seriously? Why that barrier? Its not like it prevents me from parking there - it just forces me to drive around the long way. Another bright idea by some useless civil servant. So lets just give it 4.99 stars. read more