Such a cute book store! I came across this shop after visiting the planting fields, and they have a nice selection of books and merchandise. The bookstore is small, but it doesn't feel messy or unorganized. Each section was labeled and the books were displayed in a way that made you want to pick up each book. The cashier/employee was also very nice. If you're interested in books like Common Sense or the Constitution, there is a small section towards the front of the store where they sell books related to Washington, Ben Franklin, etc. I purchased a mug and bookmark, the mug was around $14 and the bookmark was around $7. Cash and card accepted! read more

While strolling through Oyster Bay on a summer afternoon, I made my way over to this adorable bookstore. My New Year's resolution this year was to "shop local" and I am so glad I have been. Theodore's Books is situated conveniently in the midst of many dining establishments and plenty of on-street and municipal (free!) parking. I was immediately greeted when I walked in, but I was left alone (thankfully!) to peruse at my leisure. After selecting a book, I recalled wanting another book that I'd heard about recently. I asked the young person behind the counter and she knew the exact title, author, and where in the store I could find it. Easy and low-pressure purchase, great prices, and personalized service. This venue is charming, has all current bestsellers available, and the staff knows how to help find books to fit your needs. I also learned they run a monthly book club and have special events/speakers. How wonderful! For my bookish followers, RUN to this store and enjoy a slice of small-town America right here on Long Island. read more

Theodore’s Books - Bookstores Near Me - Oyster Bay, New York

See all

The absolute cutest books shop can be found in Oyster Bay. You don't see shops like this anymore. I was invited to see an author reading here. The space clears out to fit about 50 chairs. And the place was packed! It really made me happy, to see both artist and the community coming to discuss and sign a physical book. Books completely line the walls of all different genres. The children's' books were behind the author signing his work so I guess I'll just have to come back. Which will definitely happen because we make a point to come to Oyster Bay at least twice a year to go to Sagamore Hill, summer home of President Theodore Roosevelt. Hmmmm... wonder where the name of the bookshop came from read more

Bought a signed copy of a recently published book Nicely curated selection of books.Helpful staff. Found a parking spot a mile or so away. Not the fault of the bookstore.A charming neighborhood Raynam Hall from the American Revolution . Stopped in yesterday Thursday with my son Eric.I highly recommend this bookstore. Also as a long islander I try to shop locally read more

A really great bookstore in a quaint cute town. It's harder and harder to find any small independent bookstore, let alone one that's welcoming and friendly. This shop is all of that and more. It's sparkling clean and updated, with a huge selection tailored to a variety of wants. I love a bit of an edge and sense of humor, and this place has it. There's a banned books section on the left when you walk in, and incredibly catchy recommendation cards by the staff on shelves throughout the shop. I'm not a big history reader, but Claire's rec of "Swashbuckling Sugar Daddies" for the book "Pirate Enlightenment, or the Real Libertalia" by David Graeber, hooked me and I had to buy it. When I got up to the counter to pay, the staff was incredibly friendly and we got into a conversation about books and video games and everything in between. I signed up for their free rewards program too, and I can't wait to come back, find some new good reads, dive into some more great talks, and rack up some loyalty points. Thanks for a good time, and I'll definitely be back. read more

Theodore’s Books - Bookstores Near Me - Oyster Bay, New York

See all

Stopped by Theodore's books while strolling through town and I was impressed with the suggestions from the staff. Picked up the silent patient by Alex Michaelides and only put it down to write this review. The store is quaint but well stocked with a wide selection of material. Please support local businesses and stop by! read more

Theodore’s Books - Enthralling book! Couldn't put it down! - Bookstores Near Me - Oyster Bay, New York

What a cute hidden gem! Had a wide selection of both fiction and non fiction. I love the little placards added by the staff suggesting what books to read & why. Ambiance was amazing & really peaceful, prices were as marked. Playlist was 10/10. They even gave a bookmark with your purchase & the staff was so sweet. Two things I didn't really like: I overhead that they don't carry any books by independent authors / self published, only books with a publishing company. Not sure if that's true but if it is, that was sad to hear. Another thing; this store is very political. Political books are thrown front & center. I'm a big reader of fiction / thrillers, and I know that not everyone is. But if you're going to put a book representing one political party in positive light, then you should put another with the other party there as well. Not all books bashing one party. Or better yet, just keep it to literary classics and leave the political books in the political section. Other than that, I really did think this store was so cute & would return. read more

Theodore’s Books - Bookstores Near Me - Oyster Bay, New York

See all

Great bookstore for new hardcovers, kids books, fiction picked by cool staff. Lovely vibes. Dog-friendly! read more

See all

Bathroom needs cleaning. Smells horrible Nice selection of books. Overpriced though. I try to buy as much as I can from independent book stores, but the markup here is insane. The young lady was nice. But the older fellow was surly. read more

We were in a jam because son needed Macbeth for school the next day. The store closed in 3 minutes and we were 10 minutes away. The young woman in the store said to come down, she would wait. Very grateful to have such a family oriented store in town. You just don't see this type of service any more. read more

Excellent local bookstore with amazing Customer Service. Nice to support a local business and will continue to recommend to family and friends. read more

Fantastic bookshop with dedicated and helpful proprietors! Highly recommended! Great selection. We asked for suggestions and were very pleased by their thoughtful ideas. read more