Wow...while downtown today we walked past the beautiful storefront of The Cake Lady so we stepped inside. The owner is very nice and very helpful. There is a case with fresh items including cake slices, cannoli, and cupcakes. The cake displays were so beautiful, with options for any occasion. We can't wait to see the Christmas options. The star of the day were the chocolate/chocolate and white/white cupcakes. They were so moist and smooth, so incredibly rich in flavor and perfectly frosted. We got 2 and we could have eaten 4! Try it out for yourself. read more

The Cake Lady Custom Cakes - Look at the detail in the Harry Potter cake! - Desserts Near Me - Fort Pierce, Florida

Absolutely delicious!!!! Saw a post on facebook about this incredible looking Dubai cake. Decided to call them up and make sure they had a slice before I drove from south Stuart. They were very kind and said I should be fine to get a slice. I arrived and both ladies greeted me with huge smiles and remembered that I drove all that way for this cake. They had so many other amazing treats so I also grabbed a key lime cupcake to balance out the chocolate cake. Let's be clear, I am not a chocolate fan. I hate super sweet desserts.... Neither of these desserts were overly sweet or too indulgent. The Dubai cake was moist, flavorful and the crunch from the pistachio middle layer was perfect. The cupcake was also super flavorful without being too tart, very moist cake and the frosting was delicious. I will definitely use this bakery for any big cakes in the future or whenever I need an amazing treat. read more

The Cake Lady Custom Cakes - Dubai chocolate cake and key lime cupcake - Desserts Near Me - Fort Pierce, Florida

The owner went absolutely above and beyond when it came to my daughter's birthday cake. It was well worth the money!!!!!

She makes amazing cakes. I highly recommend her. I have followed her online for many years. They also have great cupcakes!! Many flavors!

Let me start by saying the FIRST cake she made was amazing. It was my daughters wedding cake. From there it's gone downhill. SECOND cake, I ordered on Feb 23, 2023. The cake was to match my daughter's wedding cake topper as they didn't get to keep the original. Stacy said she knew what I was talking about as the wedding was just 13 days earlier. I asked for the cake to be ready Feb 9, 2024 for my son-in-law to pick up the day before their anniversary. I was charged $75. All good.....until S-I-L couldn't pick up the cake on the 9th because it wasn't ready (he called). They weren't able to pick it up until the 10th, NOT as ordered and then they couldn't have it until they paid $65! The only thing that looked like their original cake was that it was round. When I called Stacy she replied that she was out of town. The cake that got picked up was white with red flowers and a red stick pin that said Happy Anniversary. NO resemblance to the original (see pictures) other than the cake topper that my S-I-L brought with. She finally said she would refund my S-I-L for the $65 but that their "website says $75 minimum". Wait a minute, your employee charged them $65......for a cake that was already paid for and wasn't ready when it was supposed to be done. THIRD cake we ordered was for my grandSON's 1st birthday. It was to be a full round cake (see pictures) decorated to look like a highland cow, for a BOY, could not contain dairy or wheat as he is allergic. The cupcakes were to look like cow pies with brown frosting. The cake came as a 1/2 cake (not round), the highland hair with PINK bows. This cake was to be for a boy! The cupcakes that were to look like brown cow pies were done in white frosting. The cake could not be finished for a boy as they did not have the required frosting and we had to wait for the white frosting to be scraped off the cupcakes and be re-applied in the brown coloring. When I called to complain Stacy said she was out of town when it was made and couldn't control what the on-hand decorator ended up doing. After my panic and complaining The cake lady Stacy finally ended up giving us a $40 gift certificate but only to her store. Should have been a refund to the credit card! The comment was their web site says "NO REFUNDS", issue was this was THEIR mistake in decorating, not our ordering, not to mention we had to wait for them to correct the mistake. Here are some quotes from the website "Promise to EXCEED your expectations" "HIGEST STANDARDS in quality, taste and DESIGN" "All our products are tailored to our client's WISHES and STYLE" The Cake Lady was a recommendation, but we will NOT order from there again! read more

See all

My son calls this cake land, which is appropriate. They rock out with their decorative cakes, but also make a mean cupcake (the biscoff and mint chocolate chip are exceptional). This has an old school bakery vibe with crazy flavor and consistent service. read more

The Cake Lady Custom Cakes - a cupcake - Desserts Near Me - Fort Pierce, Florida

Not much was there when I went but a few cupcakes. The didn't taste fresh either and not worth the price being charged. Sorry but I was expecting a bakery which is probably my bad but from the reviews I thought it would be better. read more

The Cake Lady Custom Cakes - Outside cute Decor - Desserts Near Me - Fort Pierce, Florida

Wow! My husband surprised me with this Gucci cake! What an artist you are! These high heels are icing and look at the icing purse. Yes I think I'll have my cake and eat it too! Thank you! read more

The Cake Lady Custom Cakes - Gucci cake - Desserts Near Me - Fort Pierce, Florida

We absolutely LOVED our cake from The Cake Lady. We went in and tried multiple flavors and decided to keep it simple with vanilla, chocolate, and red velvet. We ended up getting a 3 tiered cake that was very simple and elegant, as well as two half sheets of cake. None of it went to waste it was that good! The whole process was easy and stress free. Thank you so much for being apart of our special day! We look forward to eating the top of the cake in 7 months to celebrate, and will definitely be stopping in the store for some sweets! read more

See all

Our wedding cake and cupcakes turned out PERFECT! Everyone loved the look, and flavor!!! I HIGHLY recommend checking this place out for any event, or even if you're just in the mood for something sweet! read more

See all

Very helpful and creative in designing cake. Cake was delicious. The cake lady really set the bar high for a turn unique cake.

While in Fort Pierce/ Vero Beach FL I will not order a cake or cupcakes from anyone but Staci at "The Cake Lady Custom Cakes" !!! Many amazing and successful people have said..."If you love what you do you will never work a day in your life." This is true when it comes to Staci, you can see and taste this love in every bite. Staci is and amazing artist, all of her sugar flowers are so life like, I smell them just to make sure they are not real. My Grandmother turned 80 this June and I wanted to make sure she had the best. When she saw this beautiful and amazing cake she teared up. When my family tasted the cake they were amazed by how moist and delicious it was. My first bite melted in my mouth and all I could think was, Staci nailed it... this is perfect! Thank you Staci for helping me make my Grandmother's 80th birthday a day she will always remember. read more

See all

Stacey created our wedding cake that was similar to the picture provided. Which we were very happy with...However, my husband and I ordered an extra cake for our wedding to feed all of our guests and this extra cake was forgotten on our wedding day. When it was brought to Stacey's attention she provided us with a refund for our missing cake, and gave us a $25 gift card, she also informed us that she fired the individual who made this mistake. At the end of the day and about a year later we are looking forward to eating our top layer of our wedding cake but feel there should there have been more of a compensation than a $25 gift card for the inconvenience. read more

The Cake Lady Custom Cakes - Wedding cake - Desserts Near Me - Fort Pierce, Florida

Staci and her team of artist always go above and beyond and blow my expectations out of the water. Not only do her cakes looks magazine worthy, but they taste even better. She is always up for a challenge and I'm sure to throw them at her every year for my kids birthday parties. The Greatest Show on Earth was outdone this year for sure thanks to Staci! read more

The Cake Lady Custom Cakes - Birthday cake - Desserts Near Me - Fort Pierce, Florida

The wife and I grabbed a half dozen cupcakes to try this bakery out, and they were very tasty. This was the taste test, and we are going to be looking to order a cake soon. The cupcakes were very fresh and had great flavor. They have so many flavors to choose from! I recommend you try them. read more

I found The Cake Lady on Facebook and took chance and boy did she knock it out of the park! I needed a custom cake for a bake sale and not only did it turn out great but I had it delivered to the venue for 7:30 am it arrived on time and was more than I expected. In the live auction this cake went for $1100.00. Thank you again and I will definitely be visiting The Cake Lady again! read more

The Cake Lady Custom Cakes - Desserts Near Me - Fort Pierce, Florida

Stacey is awesome! Not only are her cakes absolutely beautiful but they also taste amazing. We use The Cake Lady every year for our kid's birthdays. read more

The Cake Lady Custom Cakes is a teeny tiny storefront tucked into a street in downtown Fort Pierce. Once inside, you are greeted with a number of gorgeous cake creations - it's obvious that the main business here is custom cakes and based on design alone, it does not disappoint. However, I got acquainted with it when I bought a Groupon for 6 cupcakes. I stopped in mid-afternoon one day to use it, only to find that they had only two flavors left. Because I didn't want 5 maple bacon cupcakes, I bought a lemon huckleberry and decided to use my Groupon another day. The lemon cake had a nice flavor, and the huckleberry filling was good, but I didn't like the frosting. It was very firm and very sugary, and didn't really have much flavor. Fast forward a few weeks, and I got smart and ordered my 6 cupcakes to be set aside and picked up the next day. My assortment consisted of: orange dreamsicle, raspberries and cream, vanilla rum, white chocolate macadamia nut, dark chocolate cherry, and pina colada. These cupcakes were GORGEOUS! They were so beautiful that I can't believe I forgot to take a photo. The winners were the pina colada and the dark chocolate cherry - the chocolate cake was really good with a gooey cherry filling, and the pina colada had a soft tropical filling. The others were ok - the orange one had a weird chemical flavor, and the texture of the macadamia nuts was off-putting. However, I have to say that the frosting for all of them leaves much to be desired. It's very thick and hard, and lacks flavor - most just tasted of sugar. And I like sugar! It reminds of commercial frosting, not the excellent frosting you usually find on a homemade cupcake. read more

I ordered almond cake with raspberry and I got chocolate on chocolate. Then the top of my cake had 2 holes with flattened balls of fondant filling it in...and her only solution was to put FLOWERS on it???? I had a nautical cake...how would flowers look right on that???? I did put the ball in her court saying, you know best put something there on top, but then to just leave it??? Also asked for "pearls" (actual hand made balls, even showed a pic) going around the seams but instead I got lame tiny stamped out fondant!!! I was quite disappointed....she said I could come in for cupcakes but that doesn't solve my disappointment and embarrassment at my party. read more

See all

10 out of 10! She made our wedding cake and cupcakes and I had nothing but compliments. Beautiful work and worth every penny!

The cake was amazing yes it was expensive but if you want a specialty item you have to pay for it. Will definitely have them make another special occasion cake for us. read more

Butterscotch cupcake was very good. Cake was moist and frosting not too sweet. Helpful staff. I would recommend them to others. read more

The Cake Lady Custom Cakes - Desserts Near Me - Fort Pierce, Florida

Ordered a wedding cake through this bakery and was rather disappointed. The cake was hot what I had expected at all. I gave them a few pictures of what I wanted as well as a swatch or the color I wanted it to be. I asked for it to be mint green and it was royal blue, it was not ruffled nor ombré like I had ordered. This was the only vendor who did not check in with me the week of the wedding and I could not get ahold of them on the day of either. The flavor was AMAZING but I would not order a cake this important through this bakery again. read more

We had a last-minute birthday cake idea, got a hold of the cake lady and she made it happen in just two days the cake was beautiful and it tasted great read more

We met the cake lady at a bridal show and quickly made the decision to order our wedding cake. A few weeks later we met with the Cale Lady (Staci) for a cake tasting. Staci was both supportive and offered suggestions which we gladly accepted. Our wedding guests were compliments our wedding cake throughout the reception. Thank you Cake Lady for making our day so special. read more

I used The Cake Lady for cupcakes at my wedding, and the ones I did get to try had A-Mazing flavor and stayed very fresh. They arrived on time to Jupiter! I would totally use her again for a function and will stop by next time in Port St Lucie. The only critique would be that they seemed a little small, so much so, that they fell through the hole of their slots in the boxes, so the toppings got flattened. Custom boxes or bigger cupcakes would easily solve this:) read more

Stacey is a true Artist! Every cake is like a masterpiece. Apart from being esthetically beautiful, their also delicious. If you have a wedding, birthday, special event or just because celebration. I would only go to here. read more

So far it has been an absolute pleasure working with Stacy, her customer service is AMAZING, she's attentive, quick to respond, had valuable input and when she found out I was military, gave me a discount on my order. After finding her on Yelp and Google, looking over her reviews and cake pictures I'm so excited to see the final design of this baby shower cake, I know I picked the right bakery!!! read more

This place is insane with the cake designs! It was worth the stop in just to browse the displays! We ordered chocolate cannolis and they were delicious! They have also been on Food Network, I can see why! Atop in for a look and if you are in the area and need a specialty cake, check them out! read more

We used Staci, the Cake Lady custom cakes for my daughters wedding. The cake was beautiful, fabulous flavors, moist and so delicious. Delivery was on time. Set up was perfect. Her professionalism over her cake art is not to be beat. I highly recommend Staci for all of your cake needs. read more

My future, now daughter-in-law in NJ, asked me to visit The Cake Lady Custom Cake Shop in Fort Pierce for a cake tasting in anticipation of her upcoming wedding to my son. We scheduled an appointment for the tasting and arrived on time. The shop's decor is delightful and appealing. Stacey, the proprietor, was welcoming and accommodating as we devoured the moist and delicious flavorful cupcakes. The assortment of cakes presented would delight every conceivable palette, from red velvet, carrot cake with cream cheese frosting, pumpkin, Irish cream, as well as any other conceivable flavor. My daughter-in-law sent Stacey a picture of a wedding cake with gold fondant frosting. It was beautiful. Stacey captured and surpassed the photo's image. The wedding cake was outstanding. Instead of the traditional, often thrown away, wedding favors, we ordered individual holiday inspired red velvet cupcakes for each guest. They were absolutely delicious. The Cake Lady helped make the wedding an epic success! read more

Fun cupcakes! Recommend the Starwberry Shortcake Cupcake. Very Tasty! So many good other choices too!

Beautiful, tasty creation of a cake for our daughter and son-in-law's wedding. I was never so excited about cake before. Three unique flavors, all delicious. And they will make anything you dream of. Very affordable and easy to work with as well. read more

A million thank yous to Staci and her staff at The Cake Lady!! You guys did an incredible job on the Wonder Woman cake and Superhero Girls Cupcakes for my daughter's 9th birthday. I mean the attention to detail is incomparable. I sent them a picture of what I wanted and they recreated the image perfectly. Visit The Cake Lady in Fort Pierce and you won't be disappointed. read more

The Cake Lady Custom Cakes - Desserts Near Me - Fort Pierce, Florida

They did an amazing job on my wedding cake. Everything was as delicious as it was beautiful. Thank you !!

I would love to give you pictures of my inspiration cake (which she made) and the cake she gave me. Absolutely nothing like what I asked for. I asked for gold, champagne and ivory with pearls. I got a white cake with green and pink with silver pearls. "creative freedom" is what she said she took. She matched the bouquet of my cake topper. My colors were champagne, gold and pops of cobalt blue... see the problem? When I tried to get he to fix it, she removed the pink flower, gave me a white one and said I was lucky to get a custom cake for under $200!!!! read more

Excellent service and beautiful delivery not one thing bad I can say about this lovely bakery all I can say is good things recommend more friends and family to check it out read more

Extremely disappointed in our wedding cake from this lady. First off we ordered and paid for our cake back late last year for our wedding that was to be the day after Christmas, so there was a extra $50 delivery charge for holiday, ok,no problem, we had to move the Wedding to the end of June, so I asked her about the extra charge she said we would figure it out, so 2 weeks before the wedding we go to drop off cake topper and to just talk about the cake again and we asked not to do sand dollars and sea shells and not to do burlap on the cake but to put burlap flowers in stead, which she was going to charge for so I asked about the extra $50 and she said oh yes ok, so less work but still got paid for same cake. We get to reception I notice my cake is leaning, that my flowers from my centerpieces are stuck in my cake. She only put one trim of color around the top and put my cake topper on and used my flowers because the cake was sinking due to the heat I suppose. Now we had a air conditioned facility. Now the next day I hear from my guests about the cake and what was the flavor because it was not good at all, well was supposed to be key lime. That the icing had a bad taste to it . So I message the lady and I get the response of its summer and she doesn't advise her brides to do buttercream ( for one she never advised, for 2 it's her business and her responsibility to deliver a cake ) the decoration part she said I told her no flowers, in correct, my fiancé and kids were there they heard the entire conversation. We had tasted the key lime cake at the shows and it was good, not sure why ours tasted like crap, how embarrassing. Even more I bragged for months about this cake and how great it was going to be. We won't even have our first anniversary cake because the entire cake was pitched that's how bad it was. It's very unfortunate , she does great work. Just not on mine. Just beware!! read more