Cancel

Open app

Search

Tahquamenon Pizza

3.0 (1 review)
Open • 11:00 am - 9:00 pm

Tahquamenon Pizza Photos

Recommended Reviews - Tahquamenon Pizza

Your trust is our priority, so businesses can't pay to alter or remove their reviews. Learn more about reviews.
Yelp app icon
Browse more easily on the app
Review Feed Illustration

10 months ago

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

Verify this business for free

Get access to customer & competitor insights.

Verify this business

Island Slice Pizzeria

Island Slice Pizzeria

3.7(156 reviews)
59.3 mi
•$

We decided to visit this pizzeria during that sweet spot between lunch and dinner to avoid the…read morerushes. When you walk in, you head straight to the counter where there's a large menu board to order from. My wife ordered a slice of cheese pizza and a salad, and I ordered the jerk chicken pizza. It took a little while for the food to come out, but that's to be expected when it's made fresh sono complaints there. A woman called our number, I let her know it was ours, and not long after, our food was brought to the table. The pizza looked and smelled wonderful. The only downside was that it wasn't cut very well, I had to use the edge of the pizza spatula to make better slices, which was a little annoying. But the flavor made up for it. The jerk chicken pizza was very flavorful, and since I got the thin crust, it didn't leave me feeling overly stuffed. Timing was everything, we beat the rush. By the time we were leaving, nearly every table was taken and a line had formed at the counter. The decor was simple and nothing flashy, but it didn't take away from the experience. Overall, glad we stopped in when we did.

Pizza is terrible. Barely lukewarm, old (sitting in the warmer for hours), hardly any cheese. Crust…read moreis like cardboard. So called deep dish is like a loaf of bread with a thin layer of sauce and cheese. Possibly the worst pizza I've ever had. Quite the ripoff. This is not a pizzeria.

Photos
Island Slice Pizzeria
Island Slice Pizzeria - Hair in pizza

Hair in pizza

Island Slice Pizzeria

See all

Mackinac Island Pizza

Mackinac Island Pizza

3.9(27 reviews)
59.3 mi

Pizza was great, service and price not so much. When we got in line to order the food, my husband…read morewas 3rd in line. It took him about 10-15 minutes to get to the front of the line. For some reason the staff taking the order took forever with each of the customers. She seemed friendly but not very efficient. She wasn't taking into account the customers waiting to place their orders. When finally placing our order, we asked if they could substitute the lemon Zest in the 2 pizzas we ordered (mushroom and Greek) with truffle honey and she proceeded to charge us $5 for a drizzle of this honey on each of our pizzas so a total of $10 for 2 pizzas for honey! And when we got our order for the Caesar salad it was a prepackaged small bowl with a side of packaged croutons and packet of dressing for $12! The orders when we finally got it were missing the ricotta on the mushroom pizza and missing the dressing for the Caesar. Fortunately for this place, the pizzas were actually tasty especially with the truffle honey drizzle. It was the only thing that elevated this restaurant and this rating.

We initially asked to do half mushroom and half pepperoni but they said they couldn't do it. Seeing…read morefrom previous posts they clearly do but refused when we asked. The pizza tasted pretty good but the prices were pretty high. Wish there was a lunch for two option for dinner too but only for 4 ppl instead. The pizza was lacking a bit more of the white sauce which would make it better; the crushed pepper was good and the atmosphere.

Photos
Mackinac Island Pizza
Mackinac Island Pizza - Tomato Basil Detroit-style Pizza with Kalamata Olives

Tomato Basil Detroit-style Pizza with Kalamata Olives

Mackinac Island Pizza

See all

Tahquamenon Pizza - pizza - Updated May 2026

Loading...
Loading...
Loading...