Large farm well kept and landscaped and the first on our day of doing the Cheese Trail. Needless to say this was the best one to start with as the flavors were the freshest, most natural, and best tasting. In particular the chocolate milk non homogenized and no pasteurization was smooth, creamy, naturally sweet, and the cocoa flavor was just enough. We love horseradish and were disappointed to not find any in the cooler although the sign indicated it is made there. A very nice gentleman overheard us and came out with an armful of the horseradish curds and a few other items that were in little or no supply in the cooler. Clean and fresh everything dairy fills the cases and shelves. They also make a homemade beef stick in a multitude of flavors. I chose the pickle and the sweet chili which i later tried at home and found them to be less salty than the typical beef stick with good flavor. Now back to that horseradish curd. Suffice to say our mouths exploded with fresh horseradish flavor and warmth leaving a slight heat on the tongue without overpowering the cheese flavor. We both agreed this was the absolute best we have eaten over the years and vowed to buy no other. More flavors to try we will skip the stores where it can be found and return to the farm for the best of the best. read more

Stoltzfus Dairy - Cheese cooler - Cheese Shops Near Me - Vernon Center, New York

Absolutely THE best fresh curds packaged today! Son of the family was friendly and talked for a brief time about the cheese making, curd making process, and uncle whose cheese is also featured here. read more

See all

Fantastic , non-homogenized milk that has a cream layer on top. The human body can digest the non homogenized milk better. The yogurt is amazing! Took Grams there for a tour. They were very excepting of us. Best milk Ever!! Thanks for keepin' it real! read more

If you are looking for the best yogurt in all the land, you are in luck, as Stoltzfus Dairy yogurt is simply the best of the best. I have enjoyed every flavor they have on the market. It is absolutely delicious! I live 2 1/2 hours from the area and always make sure I pick up some yogurt while visiting friends in Westmoreland along with packing some in my cooler to bring home. It is soooo goood! read more

Visited the farm a couple of times. Very interesting. Their cheeses are wonderful. Their yogurts are great. My husband really likes their milk. We have found a place close to home that we can buy their products but you made my husband very happy. read more

As a dietitian/nutritionist, I highly praise the products made at the Stoltzus Family Dairy. Their yogurt is magnificent. Barbara Beigel - Clinton, N.Y. read more

stopped by to buy cheese curds they where still making them the lady behind the counter invited us in to see how they were made they were so nice they invited me to come back the next day to see them make yogurt what a nice family i loved my visit there my inlaws live near there will go everytime i visit read more