When Dog Fight started, we said no chains. But as time went by, we started seeing that Sonic commercial. You know, the one with the quarter-pound foot-long chili cheese coney in it. So we amended the "rules" (because we can) and decided to give Sonic a shot.
First we were off to Sonic Drive-In. And that meant our chain trek now included a 10 minute wait for the noon train to pass over Assembly Street. When we finally made it to Sonic, we navigated to a shady parking spot. All the while, people churned through that drive-thru at a hefty clip.
We believe, after great debate, that the foot-long quarter-pound coney and the extra long chili cheese coney are the same item although both are listed on the menu. If the foot-long's not your bag, try a lady-sized normal coney or a corndog. We have to give the Sonic staff some props here. The place was a mad house and our order was chaotic and changed three times before we paid and they got it right, 100%.
But that's it for the yapping part of the review, let's get down to the dogs.
How the Dog Fight went down.
Karen:
Sonic Dog 1: Foot-long chili-cheese coney
Jeff:
Sonic Dog 1: Foot-long chili-cheese coney
Melissa:
Sonic Dog 1: Foot-long chili-cheese coney
Russell:
Sonic Dog 1: Foot-long chili-cheese coney with mustard & onion
Julie
Sonic Dog 1: Foot-long chili-cheese coney
Dean
Sonic Dog 1: Foot-long chili-cheese coney with mustard, ketchup & onion
The Dogs
While jockeying lunch in their laps, most agreed the Sonic wiener itself was fine. Not great, but the sheer gratitude of finally having a foot-long in our hands made it taste better. Jeff felt it was probably the most visually appealing dog we've judged to date. Melissa felt it was what she expected: a basic convenience store chili cheese hot dog - just longer.
The Toppings
Sonic scored extra points in the topping category. Their chili was good, "zingy" Julie declared. The cheese was melty. The bun was light and sweet. All together the foot-long was a fine, fine specimen to ingest.
The Packaging
At previous Dog Fights, the topic of packaging has come up here and there. Sonic took the day with their clever foot-long foil bag and paper box that included instructions on the proper way to eat your coney. Melissa gave high marks to Sonic's clever packaging, too, but reminded us all that you can't eat it.
The Verdict
According to Jeff, Dog Fight Director of Math and Spreadsheet Maintenance, Sonic finished in a distant ninth place with a score of 21.08.
The bottom line? Sonic offers a great looking dog that will do in a pinch if you can't make it to a local purveyor of hot dog goodness.
If you want to see all reviews with pictures check out http://www.facebook.com/adamsgroup and click the Dog Fight Tab. read more