A charmingly old shop in charmingly old downtown Columbiana, Ryan's offers lots of magazines,…read morethough I haven't perused them. Also available are many snacks, plus (good!) hot coffee at a very low price. There are lots of mass-market tobacco products--cigarettes, snuff, Swisher Sweets, etc., but since I go there for the cigars, that is what I'll be talking about.
(I don't know if you can smoke in the store or not, but there's not really a place to do so anyway.)
The cigars are located in a glass case under the counter. I wouldn't say they have a large selection of premium stogies, especially toward the lower end of the dollar scale, but what is there is well-tended (I thought they'd be dry, given their seeming lack of star status in the shop, but they were perfectly humidified). Because the cigar stock is limited to what will fit under the counter, the size diversity is somewhat arbitrary--most brands only have one vitola available, and it can be anything from a lengthy Churchill or Lonsdale to a squat little Robusto. Still, in the two times I've been there, I bought an old standby once and a random bargain brand I was certain would be terrible the other time, but I haven't been disappointed yet.
The staff are very pleasant, always happy to chat with customers but never pushy if you need to take your time--I suppose, given that a large portion of their customer population seems to be in the 70+ age group, they have trained themselves well.
Coming from Route 11, take the OH-344 exit toward Columbiana/Leetonia and go east, then take a right turn off the quaint little traffic circle. Ryan's will be on your left. It's a bit like being in an early-19th-century Ohio village, which is more or less what Columbiana is anyway. Street parking is free and plentiful, and you can stroll along the sidewalks of the town square sipping your coffee and looking in the various storefront windows. (I'd recommend puffing your cigar, too, but I hear people tend to frown on that these days. Ah, well.)