Not that we're fed up with our local wine and liquor because we actually love them- but when we…read moretravel north (ok...Peekskill is only about a 20 minute drive from us...but it's still north!), we like to discover new Wine Shops. Right in between West & Hudson Aves., Dylan's Wine Cellar was a great match. It certainly looks the part with its relaxed vibe and nifty local wine selections at cool retail prices. Plus the two main aisles are spaced nicely and not too cramped. Adjacent room on the right has a few other items and held for Tastings also- not sure how often they host them. Hubs and I like our wines- but since I'm pausing for a while, he enjoys them for me. We're not wine connoisseurs- but he picked out a couple of interesting Reds to fill up the rack. Dylan's actually a cool spot with a seriously good selection and something for every taste and every budget. And regardless of whether you're looking for a flawless, hard-to-find label, or an every-day, budget-priced wine, swing by Dylan's laid back space- besides...my husband was pleased with his selections.

Cute shop with a good selection. I've been in probably ten times and nobody has ever asked me if I…read moreneed help, recommended a wine, commented about the wines I chose at checkout... It would be nice if staff at a little local shop like this would be more engaging and give that personal touch you don't get at Total Wine or BevMo. Maybe next time!

Great selection even found a spirit that was hard to get my hands on. Would definitely recommendread more

Correct Address is: 374 Windsor Hwy, New Windsor, NY 12553 (this is helpful if you use a GPS)…read more Located in the K-Mart shopping plaza this liquor store is fairly large. Selections are clearly marked by type (i.e. vodka, gin, etc.) and bottles are neatly kept. Compared to other large similar sized stores in the immediate area the prices are very comparable with variations being only a dollar or two. Check out can be a little chaotic during busy times but nothing too crazy. Note: Duplicate listing on Yelp

Stopped in here for lotto. The girl was very nice and helpful. Looks like a nice variety of wine…read moreand other liquor.

The service is amazing and I love all the girls that work there especially Valerie. And they are…read moreall very knowledgeable and it's a lot of fun just to walk in there and pick something out for a party. Love this place.

This is such a gem. The woman are so knowledgeable, and Fun!…read moreThe selections are wonderful. Filled with surprising different choices. We have been here so many times I think we know the store by heart. I always get expert wine advice from m the owners. My husband is a chef so he is the true connoisseur. So when he sends me to pick wine I get a little nervous. Sandy and Bonnie always guide me in the right direction. I can not give them enough praise or stars. What a true local find. Thank you for all you do !!

We recently stopped into the shop for the first and service was great, got some great wine…read more On our second visit we brought a friend of ours to introduce him to a new great wine shop. Before even entering the store there was a new person there (assuming the co owner) working. She condescendingly asked if we were 21 and carded us, well that wasn't really a big deal for Us, but once we started browsing and looking at different wines she tells us, "please don't pick up any bottles in that section if you don't plan to buy, it would be very expensive to replace..." THE BOTTLE WE PICKED UP WAS $36!!! (we were taught to always look at labels, producers and importers when buying wine) We are just heartbroken because we thought we had a new locally owned wine shop to support one of our favorite pastimes. Which we tend to spend a lot of time and money on... We totally planned on buying a few bottles from the shop today. Now we are wineless and they lost the sale...

The best overall selection and prices for spirits I've seen in northern Westchester. I've never…read morenot found anything I'm looking for. If you live in Westchester, it's worth driving a few extra miles to go here. If you live in Mohegan Lake and you drink -- and if you live in Mohegan Lake, I highly recommend drinking heavily -- then this should be a no-brainer.

Good selection and helpful staff . Always upgrading stock and a few hidden gems. Recently upgraded…read morethe interior

Wednesday, 8/16 at 6:00pm. Whoever you have working at this place didn't even have a hello, and…read morethank you or a good bye. Not a single word or sound spoken. No appreciation for someone choosing the place to make a purchase. Drives me crazy at any place I go regardless of how much I like it. Won't be back for some time because simple customer courtesy counts. UPDATE: Just after posting this review, Ryan, the store owner, contacted me directly. He was apologetic and provided the explanation of their policy to greet all customers. Something I've actually grown accustomed to when visiting the store, which made the lack of interaction that much more obvious my past visit. I appreciate the immediate response and the care Ryan took to assure me that I am appreciated as his customer. Thank you Ryan! That meant a lot and I look forward to visiting your business real soon.

A fantastic local spot with an impressive selection of wines, spirits, and unique finds you won't…read moresee anywhere else. The staff is very friendly, knowledgeable, and always ready to help with great recommendations. Store is just off 84 and easy access. Highly recommend!

would give this place a zero if I could. I came in twice and spent 100s of dollars. On the second…read moreoccasion I bought two very nice bottles of whiskey. When I arrived home, I noticed that in the fancy box it comes in one of the bottles had a half broken seal and was leaking. Those were the only two bottles in stock and they refuse to initially exchange. They later agreed to exchange, however only with a same item that would not arrive in time for a Christmas gift. I tried to exchange for another item of equal or more value, expecting to pay the difference but they would not work with me. I had to go to another liquor store in order to buy the same bottle to give as a gift and out money now. They are really making me go out of my way to dispute the charge on my credit card at this point. Awful way of doing business, especially during the stressful holiday season. There are better locations you can shop at. ****After initiating a credit card dispute and placing this negative review, the business issued a prompt refund which was applied towards another bottle in stock.

This is an addendum.....how many times have you gone to a store looking for something and not…read morefinding it. Then you ask the manager or owner and just to placate you they tell you we can order for you. Then the Pinocchio syndrome hits and in your mind your saying it's not going to happen and disappointment sets in. Well not at Ultimate. I have been on the hunt for specific spirits, Brittany would take the info and see about avaliabity. One of the spirits I've been hunting for has been on the shelves. Today I walk in and another hard to find spirit is there calling my name! This is how a business keeps their customer base happy. The store is well stocked and the staff are there ready to help and offer advice. Major thumbs up to Ultimate Wine and Spirits!

Staff is friendly and knowledgeable. Huge selection, lots of options in the refrigerator as well…read more If you are a wine lover looking for a local spot where you can actually get a good recommendation, rather than your run of the mill liqour store, this is a great option.

I love this store the people are always friendly and helpful. I stopped going anywhere else. Great…read moreselection and roomy to help find everything you want and need. I've been going there for years now. Give this place a visit and you also might stop going anywhere else