EDIT: Scott responded to my review below. I'm not sure what that means as I showed Scott the upmost respect throughout this eight month ordeal. I have the text messages and emails to prove it. I do find it odd though, he didn't dispute that this refinance took 8 months, or that the cash close changed four times.. or we missed multiple closings. You'd think someone in Scott's position would at least try to disprove it. He didn't. Instead he tells you to go read reviews on a site where you must pay at minimum $30 to review people.
P.S if you search Big Valley Mortgage, on Google/Yelp and look at the bad reviews you specifically see other people calling out Scott for his issues and lack of communication. So was it just me?
I cannot in good faith recommend the use of Big Valley Mortgage, specifically Scott Cooper (NMLS #220458). I started an FHA streamline with Scott Cooper over 8 months ago! Yes, it took this man the better part of a year to close a streamline refinance.
I was lured in on one of those zero cash to close refinance ads Scott had mailed out to houses in the area. Sadly, Scott failed to complete my loan under the conditions he promised and my deal ended up changing MULTIPLE times. My cash to close went from $0, to $400~, to $700 to over $2000. I was informed on THREE separate occasions we were closing; those closing dates came and went, and not even a single peep from Scott. At one point Scott had failed to keep my loan active, so the lender cancelled and deleted my file entirely, yes, at month six we had to begin this process ALL OVER.
During this entire process I maybe spoke to Scott on the phone a handful of times (he heavily preferred email/text) and he'd only ever call me to give me bad news. Right around month six, I received a call from him letting me know that the lender cancelled the file due to inactivity and we had to begin this WHOLE process over. I think, as most people would be I was furious, though, I stayed calm with Scott, but I demanded answers. Well Scott did not have any answers, and in-fact he yelled at me over the phone and tried to shift blame onto me. Scott was completely unremorseful of the situation. He simply did not care.
In the midst of all this, we were able to track down the VPs phone number, so we gave him a call. While Buzz is clearly, a well-educated and professional person he remained distant from the actual issue. The position he took was more of a coworker who had no power to discipline Scott. However, we were told Scott was 'yelled' at... I will say, Buzz explained more about my refinance, and lending in general in two limited phone calls than Scott did in 8 months. I appreciated that.
Finally, it is time to close. Documents have published and all I need to do is sign and wait the three days. But wait, my closing cost is showing as $2000~. Well that is not right. Last I spoke to Scott I was told $700~. I then received a phone call.. (if you guessed it was Scott, you win a gold star). Scott did indeed confirm the bad news, but said, "I was going to make it right, you have my word". He instructed me to sign the documents so the clock could start and we could close. In my gut, I knew better, but at this point 8 months later, I just wanted this over. I signed the documents, and soon found out that BVM was going to cut me a whopping $500 check. Well thanks, after eight months of hell, multiple cash to close changes, failed closing this what their way of "making it right". So I did what I thought was best, and I called a lawyer.
I proceeded to pick up the phone and call Buzz. As mentioned earlier, Buzz is clearly well educated and knows how to talk to people. While the phone call was uneventful, I did ask them to up the amount. Buzz was a master at dancing his away around that, but ultimately he revealed two things. "Scott does a lot of business for us" and "We have no fiduciary duty to you". So that explains why Scott gets away with what he does, he makes them money so why possible harm that.
My call with a lawyer were equally uneventful. Indicated that litigating this would take many years, and no one would likely come out on top. I should accept whatever offer and put this behind me. Big Valley Mortgage upped their offer to $750. I accepted.
At the end of the day, I do have a lowered interest rate and a more manageable payment, even if it took eight months. I still sit here wondering if it was worth it, and if I should have pulled out of the refinance earlier. I am still not sure, and even if I did pull out I would have been in a worse situation. See CalHFA stopped doing refinances on FHA loans in the middle of mine, so if I left I would have been unable to achieve a refinance anytime soon. What am I sure of though? Scott Cooper lied to me, and took clear advantage of a new homeowner. I guess some lessons are learned the hard way. I will not be making this mistake again, and I hope you do not make the same mistake as me. read more