This is the best pizza I've ever had in my life. No joke. I think about this place frequently. I've…read morebeen here twice and both times the food and service were outstanding!!! The ambiance is so cozy and cute too. I adore this place and miss it dearly. If I ever go back to Orillia in my life, trust I will be here.

We went inside asked if had a reservation Said no…read moreWe can sit at the bar Guy gave us a hard time Said only three seats Told him only two of us Pizza was good

This place is incredible I came in just as they were getting…read moreready to close placing my order was not a problem at all I ordered the large meatatararin pizza I thought it was a little pricey But OMG it as amazing normally my wife and I can finish off a large pizza no problem But this was so filling we finished just half of it It has got to be one of best pizza I've ever had I will definitely stop in there again when I'm up here Even if I'm close in the area I'll stop in and get one to go

It's good. I have tried it twice and did not get that wow…read morethis is fantastic idea . It's pretty bland and does not scream italian . Maybe some new ideas in the kitchen would kick it up a bit

The crust is perfect. Generous ingredients. Superb service for the type of restaurant. Busy on…read morefridays dead rest of the week. Will go again when in the area. Takeout only.

Pizza was super doughy, complained and then they burnt it. There was 0 other orders being made…read more Will never be coming back.

I'd post a -1 if I could. First order burnt, finally two weeks later get a replacement and it has…read moresauce on it, I asked for NO sauce as I cannot eat it. Terrible place- no Canadians taking orders or cooking!

It was the worst pizza I have ever had, hardly no toppings on one canadian and all topping on half…read moreside of other pizza and asked for extra sauce got no sauce on either. Never again from this location.

Best butter pecan tarts that I've ever had. Half a dozen for $7.75. They are buttery, rich, sweet…read morebut not too sweet and a delightful treat. The Chelsea buns are also delicious. To be honest I haven't tried much of anything else because I always want the same two items! Service is quick and friendly. There are a few high top seats to enjoy your purchases.

Excellent pecan tart Good, fair prices…read more They had other stuff But I only had the pecan tart Did I mention it was excellent......

Fantastic pizza and Wings!!! Was in Orillia for New Year's celebrations 31/12/23, Service was…read moreawesome, we did a pick up order as we were just out of range for delivery to our hotel. We thought we couldn't get any more delicious pizza unless we traveled to Pickering Papa Johns, but to our delight Orillias Papa John's is even superior to the one in Pickering and a little closer to where we now live!! Hats off to the staff who were working New Year's Day, you all deserve a Big Pat on the back for an off the charts fantastic Pizza and BBQ wings!! What a GREAT START to the new year!

Definitely awesome pizza and great customer service as well. Love those free extras in the box…read morelike the hot peppers and garlic dip. My favorite! I even got a few extra peppers to make my taste buds tingle! Thanks Papa Johns!

**A True Hidden Gem in Orillia **…read more As we were passing through Orillia, we decided to stop into **Theo's Restaurant** for a bite to eat--and I'm so glad we did. From the moment we walked in, we were warmly greeted and brought to our table with such genuine hospitality. The space is spotless, intimate, and beautifully styled, creating the perfect atmosphere for a cozy meal. The menu is filled with wonderful Greek and Italian options, and everything we ordered was absolutely delicious. The bruschetta was outstanding, and the veal parm was perfection. The food alone is worth the visit, but the service truly elevated the experience. The staff were incredibly friendly and attentive, giving us that small-town connection where we didn't feel like "just customers." We also noticed the same level of care at the tables around us--clearly, this is how they treat everyone who walks in. Theo's is definitely a place I'd stop at again on my next trip back. And for anyone who lives in Orillia, it's a wonderful spot for a family celebration, a special date night, a relaxed dinner out, or even a business meeting. **Five stars all the way. The Theo family has done an incredible job.** Anja Lavigne ( Toronto/Kwarthas )

What a great experience. Fast and friendly service. A…read morerefill brought without even asking! The pepper was full not that we used it and they give enough tzatziki sauce to swim in (not that I'd recommend trying that) We aren't positive but think it's POSSIBLE Justin Beiber was at another table here. You be the judge. Deffo would recommend.

I expected a lot more from them. The pizza was alright quality and toppings are what you expect for…read morewhat you are paying for. My issue was they are SO close together and have employees in the costumer area without masks. It is plastered all over to wear a mask and not a single person was wearing one. I get it that it's hot, but if you go into the customer area with 4 customers inside, when it's that enclosed, you need to wear your mask. I simply waited to order til everyone was outside. They should know better.

Well the food is very good and top quility I will not be returning to this establishment. I find…read morethe owner and his wife very rude to their customers. If you want good food and don't care about the customer service then this is the place for you but if you want a place with both this is not your place.

Skimps out on toppings completely. I ordered a pepperoni pizza and got 2 pepperonis per slice. Also…read morewas cut super uneven where 1 slice was a sliver. The slices on display looked like roadkill that have been sitting there since yesterday. It looks like it has seen better days in the decor as well. I felt super dirty going in there. Now onto the bathroom.. I found a needle beside the toilet. I just am super upset with Pizza Pizza in Orillia. I will go back with a video at a later date with a new experience and hope they can change this review.

Wow what can I say about this pizza pizza...well all good things. I came in expecting nothing more…read moreor less than your run of the mill pizza pizza....but I was pleasantly surprised. Jay our server welcomed us warmly into the establishment. His smile alone made the experience fantastic but then he continued to deliver a positive and surprising experience. Jay notified us of the deep fried avocados which was my first time hearing about this wonderful treat at a pizza pizza. Kudos Jay! We didn't try the avocado deep fried, a bit exotic for our taste buds but it was delightful to learn That they are an option. Speaking of learning Jay taught us about all the soda options available. Did you know they have Barq's cream soda?! This is the first time I had even heard that this was a thing. All in all the experience was 11 out of 10. Jay provides great service and I can't wait to come back. Well done gentlemen keep up the great work.