Awesome food... was broke down in my truck down the road and was hungry gave these bros a call..:…read morewhat can i say this food is great it's a buttery crisp pan pizza crust it's very good... reminds me of a place that used to be up in Andover Ohio... this place is awesome also the pretzel sticks were freaking delish!! Saw some reviews that the place takes a while to deliver but hey if it's good food oh well places do get busy anyways def try them

It was amazing and they treated me just like family.Thank you the food was absolutely amazing…read more Ambiance 100

I grew up on Wally's pizza in Cambridge and my eldest son's first solid food was their pizza crust…read more I am a die hard fan. I recently moved and have been trying to find a place that resembles what I grew up with. With that said, this is NOT it. I don't even think they try to serve good pizza. I've given them about 4 tries and only because I wanted it to be good. I needed it to be good. This location has served me reheated hard, dried out "pizza". Pizza that I've had leftovers for breakfast and lunch at the Cambridge location and it never tasted as bad as what I have received from this location, supposedly fresh. You really need to do better. The price you charge for pizza and you're reheating it trying to save money and that just cost you a would be loyal customer. I tried to chalk it up to being 4 pieces and not a 1/2 tray, but you guys don't even try to make a good half tray. The dough can't be fresh. If it was it definitely wouldn't be this terrible. I know Wally's pizza. I've been eating it since 1978. I'm so disappointed, but I think I've given enough chances. I won't be recommending this to anyone I know. We wasted an entire 1/2 tray tonight minus the piece we each tried to eat.

I stopped here for a quick lunch on a Sunday road trip because it was next to the gas station…read morewhere I filled up and I like supporting local restaurants instead of fast food chains when possible. Although it's attached to a gas station, it's not connected inside. It's a separate business. There isn't much to the place. But the menu board was cute and the service was fast and friendly. That, plus the fact that the other reviews make it clear the locals like it, warranted the 2nd star. How was the pizza? What are the words I'm looking for ... um ... not good. I've heard about Ohio Valley-style pizza and I think that's what this is. The crust had a nice crispness to it and the sauce wasn't too sweet (which is a common feature of pizza in other parts of Ohio). But the cheese was provolone, not mozzarella. And after they cooked it, they put more raw shredded provolone on top! That seems to be their thing - fresh cheese and toppings on top of the cooked pizza. And the pizza was terribly salty. I've had better frozen pizza from the supermarket, and if the cheese doesn't melt, I cook it longer. I should have known not to expect better pizza after living in Ohio for a couple decades. This is so close to the state line that I guess I forgot I was still in Ohio! The sign on the door says they're closed Sundays. I wish that had been true today!

Great job on the pizza and sub. Delivery was quick. Thanks…read more So much. I'm trying to add a few more remarks according to the information I'm getting but , haha haha I hope this is enough . Thanks again and appreciate it and thanks again .

Love it. A great local hometown favorite. No extra cheese needed this is cheesy enough.read more

Visiting from out of town and found this little gem! Beautiful view of the Ohio, we ate outside…read more The Asian chicken bowl was amazing. Pizza was made exactly as ordered. We were here on wing night special and they were so yummy! Cold beers, and friendly staff. Alyssa was amazing and so friendly!

This business has changed hands several times. We ordered food recently and we will not order again.read more

Called in my order of Chicago style deep dish. Picked it up 45 minutes later. The staff was very…read moreinviting and helpful. The restaurant was very clean and the kitchen was wide open to see the whole pizza process. I got the pizza home about ten minutes later and the pizza maintained temperature very nicely. I and my family absolutely loved it. My very picky son said "can we only get this pizza from now on". I assured him we would. My family highly recommends.

This was my first time trying this restaurant.. I got the…read morebreadsticks,pepperoni and 2 garlic butters.. I want to start off by saying my food was amazing.. but im glad I ordered the garlic butter because the breadsticks or pepperoni roll do not come with dipping sauce.. I wanted to give 5 stars but this the 1st time I have ordered those items from a restaurant and did not get sauce included.. That will not stop from ordering again because I really enjoyed the food..

I really liked it, and I see why there has been reviews all. over the internet about this unusual…read morestyle of pizza. I do wish that they had a soda fountain, instead of having to buy it by the bottle.

No mozzarella cheese in the building, only provolone for everything…read more I will not return. I hope this helps someone make their decision. Thanks for listening.

Three slices for under $5 is one of the best lunches around. The picture of daily specials is from…read moreJune of 2026.

Crust was hard and sauce was not good. Asked for extra cheese and what a joke, very little cheese…read more Pizza here used to be the best, now... not so much

This place was amazing when it opened. Something has went very wrong. They are always "so busy" and…read morethe food is always delivered super late.Pick up orders are ready 40 minutes after the time it was supposed to be ready. It's ridiculous.

I moved to Saint Clairsville eight months ago. During the busy time of moving and setting up a new…read morehome, we had tons of take out food. We tried all of the pizza shops in town numerous times. Papa D's Pizza consistently beats the competition. I believe they have six employees in total. Every staff member is friendly, courteous and professional. The store is neat and clean. There are several tables for dining in. My wife and I ate there twice. She enjoyed watching HGTV while eating at the pizza shop. I have probably had over twenty take out orders and never encountered a mistake or problem. On one occasion, I ordered a tray five minutes before closing. It was perfect pizza, not old, re-heated pieces. This pizza beats every competitor from here to Wheeling and beyond. The pepperoni rolls are nothing short of awesome. When my son visits from out of state, we order a tray for him to take home. He can't get enough of Papa D's Pizza either.