Pizza Pit

Okay. I hate that I have to leave this review... Timber Creek has always been a stand up place. But…read moremy recent experiences here have been awful. They just keep getting worse too! The girl I've encountered in this place has the worst attitude. She's stared at me (like stared me dead in the eyes for multiple minutes straight while I was ordering) and made me feel super uncomfortable. She's never acknowledged customers when I've been in there and saw her. Then she made me a sub today that I can only describe as scary. The lettuce was brown and the meat was slimy. I didn't even eat it. $15 out the window. The poor guy who was working with her was incredibly nice however was clearly not trained in the slightest. He didn't even know if they had mint ice cream. Let alone what was in it. He also didn't know how to use the cash register. And let's face it he was alone with Miss Personality and I would be scared to ask her a question too if I were in his shoes. Also the interior is beginning to look more and more like someone's garage sale. There's crap everywhere. The counter shouldn't be so cluttered with ratty dirty signs that you can't even pay your bill without have to step around the corner and almost put it in the register yourself. There was junk mail wedged in some of the signs too. Random pieces of paper advertising specials but could just be scraps of paper. I love the cabin decor but the grinch costume clearly being stored in the corner of the front window needs to go. As well as the two elf on the shelf toys that make reading the already cluttered menu difficult. The arcade games are a nice touch but shouldn't be right next to the register. There's so much going on in that corner and it makes it hard to order. I don't know what happened to this place. This was one of our favorite places especially in the summer. And was one of the reasons we moved here.

Pizza was mid at best. Freezer quality pizza. It took 45 minutes for this pizza. They also gave it…read moreoff to the wrong table twice. Staff were snotty and rude. Tables were dirty. Soda was flat, water came out pink. We regret not going to McDonalds

The turkey sub I ordered. Very little lettuce and brown at that.

See all

Nachos and a taco

Samijos Pizzeria

4.9(12 reviews)

7.9 mi

Wow! What a great pizza! Our 1st time here. The pizza has a fantastic thin crisp crust. We…read moreordered a chicken, breakfast bacon pizza with 1/2 red sauce and 1/2 white garlic sauce. Both were equally delicious. We will be regulars from now on. 5 stars!

Best pizza in Jefferson bar none the calzones are great too…read more Ordered one line went great ready in about 20 minutes

Chicken, bacon, half red sauce, half white sauce.

Chicken Bacon Ranch pizza

See all

Chicken Bacon Ranch

Gordy's Pizza & Italian Food

4.5(23 reviews)

8.0 mi

Excellent Lasagna and pizza. I will definitely be back to try more. It's take out only. You can…read morestop in and pick up Lasagna and bake it whenever you're ready. Yummy stuff!!

Great thin crust pizza and friendly service. My family stopped in here months ago while visiting…read morerelatives and we still talk about it. Every time we get a pizza back home now we lament, "Well, it's not Gordy's." This will be our first stop when back in town again.

Only toppings on half?! What gives?

Supreme pizza with extra pepperoni

See all

Milwaukee style thin crust

Pyramid Event Venue

4.1(23 reviews)

0.7 mi

This is a really lovely establishment! The apps are good (our personal favorite at the moment is…read moretheir spinach & artichoke dip) and the service is kind and friendly. They host a variety of events like bingo and trivia, and they've been fun to attend!

$10 cover for a dead night. Not a great way to run the business, especially when they chase our…read moreparty of 6 down the street saying they can do $5 if we come back. It ain't Chicago pal.

Gearing up for tonight's comedy club.

Food

See all

Entrance

Lewis Station Winery

4.3(51 reviews)

0.6 mi

Delicious soft pretzel a good selection of wine varieties and it was a wide open space with great…read morehost. Wish it was a little warmer because I can see this place getting very busy. Just a great selection overall atmosphere with great people

Sampled wines while on vacation. Loved the experience and the service. Charming little place.read more

Olive Flatbread. Mmmmm

See all

Rose Dry Wine

Mink Farm Tavern

4.4(15 reviews)

7.9 mi

We stopped on our way to the Jefferson Speedway The Mink Farm didn't disappoint…read moreIt was busy but we managed to move a few chairs and found a spot The staff was so friendly. And the fish, (fried cod and the lemon pepper cod) were so good!!! We will stop again if we find ourselves in the area again

It's a small cute bar that happens to have a small bar menu which is perfect. We split the prime…read morerib sandwich which was 14 bucks which is a good price. It was tasty but nothing incredible but good solid bar food It looks like an up north bar with the wood trim and games of chance. It's a well stocked bar but they did run out of Diet Coke when we were there but it was okay. If you're in the neighborhood it's worth a stop.

Bar

Lemon pepper cod

See all

Brickhouse Pizza Pub

3.9(55 reviews)

12.9 mi

It doesn't look like much from the outside, but inside was nicely decorated with Italian pizza…read moredecor with Italian crooner music for ambience. Friendly server took our orders and the drinks and food came out timely. Our loaded nachos were good, though the nacho cheese was a bit runny and pooled in the bottom. My grandsons loved their pepperoni calzone and Mac and cheese. My personal pan Meathead pizza was very good; tasty with a nice crisp crust. My wife enjoyed her chicken Tuscany pizza. Both personal pizzas were bigger than expected and very filling. Would definitely stop in again if in the area.

Had lunch today i had supreme personal pizza and wife had cream of mushroom soup. Both were very…read moregood and reasonably priced. Waitress did a nice job for our table of 6.

Loaded nachos

See all

James Street Pizza Co.

4.2(26 reviews)

17.9 mi

Great place to eat glad for trying this place and having a new york style pizza! Thank you!read more

I called after ordering a pizza that the crust was so soggy you couldn't physically pick up the…read morepizza and was told by the front end "the guys in the back remember making your pizzas and they said the crust was borderline burnt, not raw. I'm sorry you didn't enjoy it but that's just how we make our pizzas. This AFTER I told them I didn't want it comped. Didn't want it remade. I just wanted them to know because I still think they're the better pizza place in town. Flavor- 10/10. Crust...usually 5/10. Today 1/10. Customer service, being told "ACTUALLY they said it was 'almost burnt' not raw". Ok then why send it if you thought it was "almost burned?" And why not just accept the feedback with a thank you for taking the time to provide your feedback on our product" instead of being rude and saying "sorry that's just the way our pizza is". Customer service 0/10. Many notes. Do better. And by the way: a pizza that wasn't loaded down with dozens of toppings SHOULD be not so flimsy that it literally falls apart when you pick it up. C'mon now.

Margarita pizza

See all

Menu

La Piazza Pizzeria

4.5(21 reviews)

19.8 mi

I've been so curious about this place and finally got there! The two slice special saves you a few…read morepennies. Slices are heated up perfectly. It was 6 PM and the place was empty, but there was plenty of pizza to go around. It was fresh crust, light and tasty, and the toppings were delicious.

I graduated in 2022 and have not been back to this place since '23 but I still think about this…read morepizza so often. The pizza is perfect, garlic knots, are perfect, and if you have a chance to see the owner, he's amazing! Could not recommend this place more. (Also check out his Italian restaurant next door)

See all

Why does Yelp recommend reviews?

Hundreds of millions of reviews are posted on Yelp, and our automated recommendation software works in the background to showcase the reviews that it …

1 review that is not currently recommended

The reviews below are not factored into the business's overall star rating.

Rob B.

0

11

3

6 years ago

Been a fan for a while now. Always great food, not just their pizza. My wife and I love the gyros and their hot subs even more. Keep it up read more

Pizza Pit - pizza - Updated October 2026

Browse Nearby

BEST of Lake Mills, Wisconsin Restaurants near Pizza Pit

BEST of Lake Mills, Wisconsin Desserts near Pizza Pit

BEST of Lake Mills, Wisconsin Shopping near Pizza Pit

BEST of Lake Mills, Wisconsin Things to Do near Pizza Pit

BEST of Lake Mills, Wisconsin Parking near Pizza Pit

BEST of Lake Mills, Wisconsin Coffee near Pizza Pit

BEST of Lake Mills, Wisconsin Thrift Stores near Pizza Pit

BEST of Lake Mills, Wisconsin Dinner near Pizza Pit

BEST of Lake Mills, Wisconsin Breakfast near Pizza Pit

BEST of Lake Mills, Wisconsin Burgers near Pizza Pit

Best of Lake Mills

Things to do in Lake Mills

Browse Brands

Brands by name

Browse Articles

Articles by date

People who viewed Pizza Pit also viewed

Gordy's Pizza & Italian Food

4.5

(23 reviews)

Excellent Lasagna and pizza. I will definitely be back to try more. It's take out only. You can…read morestop in and pick up Lasagna and bake it whenever you're ready. Yummy stuff!!

Great thin crust pizza and friendly service. My family stopped in here months ago while visiting…read morerelatives and we still talk about it. Every time we get a pizza back home now we lament, "Well, it's not Gordy's." This will be our first stop when back in town again.

PJ's Pizza

3.3

(17 reviews)

Amazing Buffalo chicken subzeeny. The spice on it has a perfect dose of spice…read more SUBZEENY - juicy, tasty sub -

They leave you on hold for 10+ minutes and ignore your call while they help customers in person…read more They won't give an estimated hold time just expect you to sit on the phone until whenever they feel like taking your order or not. I asked if they could call me back, no. Asked if they could give me an estimated wait time, no. They could have taken the order and just put it in when they were ready, no. Wasn't even in a hurry, just don't want to sit with a phone to my ear for thirty minutes while I hear them all chat in the background. She literally said "you can go back on hold or you can hang up" -Mrs Rude Honestly unbelievable. Do better.

Timber Creek Pizza

3.2

(40 reviews)

Okay. I hate that I have to leave this review... Timber Creek has always been a stand up place. But…read moremy recent experiences here have been awful. They just keep getting worse too! The girl I've encountered in this place has the worst attitude. She's stared at me (like stared me dead in the eyes for multiple minutes straight while I was ordering) and made me feel super uncomfortable. She's never acknowledged customers when I've been in there and saw her. Then she made me a sub today that I can only describe as scary. The lettuce was brown and the meat was slimy. I didn't even eat it. $15 out the window. The poor guy who was working with her was incredibly nice however was clearly not trained in the slightest. He didn't even know if they had mint ice cream. Let alone what was in it. He also didn't know how to use the cash register. And let's face it he was alone with Miss Personality and I would be scared to ask her a question too if I were in his shoes. Also the interior is beginning to look more and more like someone's garage sale. There's crap everywhere. The counter shouldn't be so cluttered with ratty dirty signs that you can't even pay your bill without have to step around the corner and almost put it in the register yourself. There was junk mail wedged in some of the signs too. Random pieces of paper advertising specials but could just be scraps of paper. I love the cabin decor but the grinch costume clearly being stored in the corner of the front window needs to go. As well as the two elf on the shelf toys that make reading the already cluttered menu difficult. The arcade games are a nice touch but shouldn't be right next to the register. There's so much going on in that corner and it makes it hard to order. I don't know what happened to this place. This was one of our favorite places especially in the summer. And was one of the reasons we moved here.

Pizza was mid at best. Freezer quality pizza. It took 45 minutes for this pizza. They also gave it…read moreoff to the wrong table twice. Staff were snotty and rude. Tables were dirty. Soda was flat, water came out pink. We regret not going to McDonalds

Samijos Pizzeria

4.9

(12 reviews)

Wow! What a great pizza! Our 1st time here. The pizza has a fantastic thin crisp crust. We…read moreordered a chicken, breakfast bacon pizza with 1/2 red sauce and 1/2 white garlic sauce. Both were equally delicious. We will be regulars from now on. 5 stars!

Best pizza in Jefferson bar none the calzones are great too…read more Ordered one line went great ready in about 20 minutes

Marty's Pizza - Delafield

3.6

(99 reviews)

Good pizza, sometimes inconsistently made. Good service, always busy during prime times so there is…read moreAt times a wait. Inside is cute like an old school pizzeria.

Pros: -Good pizza…read more-Nice staff -Easy parking Cons: -Underwhelming steak sandwich -Some items over-seasoned We recently tried out Marty's Pizza on Mother's Day because it was my MIL's choice. She has great memories from going to a different Marty's location for work lunches years ago. Apps: -We started our order with some of the mozzarella sticks, which my wife and MIL liked (I'm not huge on breaded mozzarella sticks, so I didn't try them out). Mains: -Pepperoni pizza (Wife)-- really good thin crust pizza -Spinach lasagna (MIL)-- over seasoned to me, but my MIL seemed to enjoy it -Steak Sandwich (Me)-- not great, one little slice of overcooked, thin steak with some cheese. It also came with a cold side of fries. Overall, I would stop back in for pizza but probably would probably skip for anything else.

Brickhouse Pizza Pub

3.9

(55 reviews)

It doesn't look like much from the outside, but inside was nicely decorated with Italian pizza…read moredecor with Italian crooner music for ambience. Friendly server took our orders and the drinks and food came out timely. Our loaded nachos were good, though the nacho cheese was a bit runny and pooled in the bottom. My grandsons loved their pepperoni calzone and Mac and cheese. My personal pan Meathead pizza was very good; tasty with a nice crisp crust. My wife enjoyed her chicken Tuscany pizza. Both personal pizzas were bigger than expected and very filling. Would definitely stop in again if in the area.

Had lunch today i had supreme personal pizza and wife had cream of mushroom soup. Both were very…read moregood and reasonably priced. Waitress did a nice job for our table of 6.

Pizza Villa

3.2

(19 reviews)

Pizza tastes like it did 30 years ago, amazing flavors and quality. And the owner Kim, is fantastic…read moretoo. Love this gem

The food was amazing after a long day of playing at a waterpark. The single server that worked his…read morebutt off did great. Are food came out delicious and fresh. I would recommend rigatoni Bolognese, and the gluten free pizza

Rolling Stone

4.1

(16 reviews)

Food was fantastic, many things made from scratch. Soup, sandwiches, sides, sauces and prime rib…read morewere all done very well with great flavors. The chef, Russ, came out and introduced himself, he was very pleasant and clearly passionate about what he does. Cocktails were tasty and service was great. Will definitely be back.

Food was not great. Brussels were burned. Chicken was over done. For the amount I paid I was…read moreextremely disappointed. No one in my house enjoyed it. unfortunately. Really was looking forward to good food in Juneau.

Biggs Bar & Grill

4.2

(44 reviews)

We went for the fish fry. 4 piece deep fried cod, coleslaw, potato salad, tart-a sauce and bread…read more Plenty of great tasting food. Just finished it. Great beer selections both on tap etc. Off the beaten path but don't tell everyone. Great wait staff, good service and a very nice crowd.

Hard to beat Biggs if you're in the mood for a fresh burger or want to share an excellent pizza…read more Portions are generous and food is always fresh and hot. The people are friendly and welcoming in this tradition corner bar/ sports bar setting. When the time is right, the Bloody Marys hit the spot, and with a few apps on the side, you're good to go. Delicious!

North Lake Inn

3.0

(57 reviews)