We visited the waterfront hall location in Wheeling for lunch. Fast service and absolutely amazing…read morefood! Highly recommend the Bianco and flying pig pizzas! The building is absolutely adorable, full of history and beautifully decorated.

Went to the waterfront hall location with family for lunch. The workers were very nice and brought…read moreout our food fast which was great. The location is amazing like stepping back in time with the old brick building. I tried the cheese breadsticks which were some of the best I've ever had. My mom also really liked her Margherita pizza as well. It was really good food and we will definitely go again at some point.

First time trying this place. It was on a Saturday afternoon. I'm guessing it was considered busy…read more We ordered a small pizza for $17. My wife also ordered a chicken sandwich. We said water for our drink and they wanted to charge for water so we decided against that. We dined in. My wife's chicken sandwich came out pretty quickly. About 40 minutes later my pizza was delivered to our table. The noise of the place was terrible. The steel chairs on the hard floors echoed throughout the dining area. The pizza was delicious! Definitely one of the best pizza pies I've had. Little soggy in the center but overall it was great! My wife liked the chicken sandwich but the dressing was a little heavy, which made it a little too salty for her taste. We're excited to try different items next time! Pros: Food was great. Cons: WAIT TIME Noise Price

The Rustic Chicken Pizza was second to none! Absolutely delicious and highly recommended.read more

We were passing through and were staying at a hotel not too far away from Pizza Milano…read more Yelp searched for late dinner as it was after 9PM and Pizza Milano came up as "open". Ordered a large pizza with (1/2 cheese & 1/2 veggie) and it was absolutely delicious. They piled the veggies high on our pizza and the cheese side too was amazing. We sat and ate our pizza in their dining room and it hit the spot!!! I even asked for extra onions and they were even generous with them too. Keep up the service & quality and you will never run out of customers.

Always very good across the board…read more Well made, reasonably priced Pizza and subs Love the owner as well. Very good

This is not a DiCarlo's Pizza. It's called Papa D's now. They used the same font for their "D," but…read morethat's the only thing that's the same. The pizza might be acceptable if you're not in the mood for DiCarlo's, but I doubt it.

Have to give a one star simply for the fact that they are not open during posted hours, no info at…read morethe phone number, and the company website has no links for this location. Boo!!

I grew up on Wally's pizza in Cambridge and my eldest son's first solid food was their pizza crust…read more I am a die hard fan. I recently moved and have been trying to find a place that resembles what I grew up with. With that said, this is NOT it. I don't even think they try to serve good pizza. I've given them about 4 tries and only because I wanted it to be good. I needed it to be good. This location has served me reheated hard, dried out "pizza". Pizza that I've had leftovers for breakfast and lunch at the Cambridge location and it never tasted as bad as what I have received from this location, supposedly fresh. You really need to do better. The price you charge for pizza and you're reheating it trying to save money and that just cost you a would be loyal customer. I tried to chalk it up to being 4 pieces and not a 1/2 tray, but you guys don't even try to make a good half tray. The dough can't be fresh. If it was it definitely wouldn't be this terrible. I know Wally's pizza. I've been eating it since 1978. I'm so disappointed, but I think I've given enough chances. I won't be recommending this to anyone I know. We wasted an entire 1/2 tray tonight minus the piece we each tried to eat.

I stopped here for a quick lunch on a Sunday road trip because it was next to the gas station…read morewhere I filled up and I like supporting local restaurants instead of fast food chains when possible. Although it's attached to a gas station, it's not connected inside. It's a separate business. There isn't much to the place. But the menu board was cute and the service was fast and friendly. That, plus the fact that the other reviews make it clear the locals like it, warranted the 2nd star. How was the pizza? What are the words I'm looking for ... um ... not good. I've heard about Ohio Valley-style pizza and I think that's what this is. The crust had a nice crispness to it and the sauce wasn't too sweet (which is a common feature of pizza in other parts of Ohio). But the cheese was provolone, not mozzarella. And after they cooked it, they put more raw shredded provolone on top! That seems to be their thing - fresh cheese and toppings on top of the cooked pizza. And the pizza was terribly salty. I've had better frozen pizza from the supermarket, and if the cheese doesn't melt, I cook it longer. I should have known not to expect better pizza after living in Ohio for a couple decades. This is so close to the state line that I guess I forgot I was still in Ohio! The sign on the door says they're closed Sundays. I wish that had been true today!

Really good pie, very satisfied. Crust is bent up at the edges with good texture. Very generous…read moreamount of toppings. This isn't thin crust, but it isn't "original" crust either. Somewhere between is the best way I can describe it. The pepperoni had a bit of spice, sauce was a bit sweet, onions cooked just right. Was glad to find a great pizza place in the area and would definitely stop back.

There pizza terrible I moved from a large state never and live in a small town still and have eaten…read morelocal owner's pizza company never have I eaten some cheaply made pizza's we had to peel off the toppings and eat it and throw the rest away never again bad experience

We were visiting the area and were looking for a local place to grab a bite and this worked…read moresplendidly. The pizza was good and the wings were great. The pizza was perhaps the cheesiest I've ever had. That's a plus for us but maybe not for everyone. The service was timely, friendly and accommodating. The seating was outside via covered picnic tables which worked great since the weather was nice. The take out business was brisk while we were there during a work day evening which we took as a good sign. We wouldn't hesitate to go back if we were in the area again!!

Pizza was yummy!! Service was excellent! No indoor seating, but weather was perfect for the outdoor…read moreseating area!

Delivery pizza is almost always a quality compromise. It's either uninspiring or cold or both. From…read morelarge franchises to Mom-amd-Pop businesses...meh! It's an I-don't-feel-like-cooking choice. And the person answering the phone is the one who drew the short straw...and sounds like it. Carpenter's was none of that. And this is the first time I've ordered from them. The person who took our order was cheerful, quick, and laughed at my pathetic attempt at humor. Weird, thought I, but any pizza from a village as small and remote and with a logo that looks like a copyright lawsuit waiting to happen can't be that good. Plus, it's in the low 20s tonight, so let's fire up the oven so we can reheat it and we'll see. Turned out to be the best pizza we've had in the area and better than most we've had out previous homes in CBus & ATL. And still relatively hot. The toppings were a little sparse (got to say something so I don't sound like the mother of the owner). The sauce was good. The crust was the winner. Perfect. Keep it up Carpenter's. If you don't deliver to Bethesda we'll have to work out a meeting place in Belmont as a handoff.

Pizza was great & so were the cinnamon sticks ! Also delivered directly to our hotel roomread more

We stopped in after leaving the Pumpkin festival to get a pizza to take home with us. We ended up…read moregoing with just the basic xl pizza and a chefs salad. Price wise this place lines up with most other pizza shops. The inside of the shop is a classic small pizza shop. Old arcade games line one wall and the seating is limited but takes advantage of the available space. The pizza itself was very good. We baked it for 5 minutes after getting home, but that was due to the drive not the pizza. The salad was also very good. In an area with several options, this is definitely one I would recommend trying.

I love this place best pizza in this town and area great friendly staff closest thing to a real…read morepizza I have found makes living in this area great I have ate pizza all over the US & Canada and this is the closest to a real NY / Chicago style and flavor pizza I have found keep up the great work guys!!!!!!!!!

Driving from PIT after a day traveling, called ahead for some slices. They were ready when we…read morearrived, piping hot with crunchy doughy crust. It's Ohio Valley style- cheese & pepperoni added at the end. If you like that style come here - this is one of the best I've had. Bonus if you're on a road trip- there's a nice space for eating and clean restrooms.

They have the worst customer service. They are rude, obnoxious argumentative, and wouldn't know the…read moretruth if they fell in it. The woman behind the counter waiting on customers should spend more time cleaning the restaurant instead of arguing with customers and chatting on the phone! I'm really not sure how this place stays open. The pizza is poor at best. If you like overcooked cardboard and uncooked cheese and toppings! My late wife for some reason liked their pizza for some reason and the only reason I went was to try and bring her a little joy in her last days. This has been over a year now and she passed in June of last year. I doubt if this place has changed. It makes me very sad every time I think about it.