Pulled into town late and stopped. The best decision I made all day…read more We picked up our pizza at this Walkerton gem in great time. They gave us plates etc and the staff were helpful. The pizza was generous in size, toppings and was perfectly cooked. It tasted fresh! My definite go-to when I return.

Honestly this is some of the best pizza iv ever had in my life perfect amount of cheese and other…read moretoppings. The staff are always great there's a manager there his name is Matt he's the nicest guy around and always makes you feel very welcome I'm happy to support a business with such great staff. Iv eaten inside the place as well great assortment of music great theme all in all I highly recommend the place.

We were starving on our trip to Wiarton to go camping for the weekend. Maybe it was me thinking…read moreI'd have to cook on an open flame all weekend so I better get some substantial calories before I burnt everything that made me so hungry:p I told my fiancee to pull into any restaurant that didn't look deserted. We drove by A LOT and I finally yelled just go anywhere and Good Fellas popped up. Hesitant at first, I'm use to seeing tons of cars parked outside a restaurant or a lot of people inside (hey i'm from the city and this was my first camping trip) but the second I walked inside I knew that I may have spoke too soon. The size of the pizza reminds me of Big Slice down in toronto... still not sure which is bigger, but the girl at the counter was super friendly warmed up our pizzas for us and grab us a drink. I couldn't finish this SLICE pizza that is how big it was and I was STARVING. Listen I make all-you-can eat buffets regret their business motto so i'm telling you this slice was HUGE and delicious! I was really happy with the food. The place could use a bit of sprucing up, no one wants to see the foam under the cover of their chairs but hey the food still great! Great price I think two slices came up to $13 with a root beer, it was under $20 I just cant remember how much it was. Great work! Oh and for the people who live up in that area, they deliver!

On our drive home to Toronto and we were starving and didn't feel like the usual Tim Horton's or…read moreburgers/fries. Chose this place because of the decent reviews. Uhhhh.....this pizza gave us instant heartburn and was way too overcooked or overheated up. Sorry, not so much Goodfellas.

Great pizza created by people who are passionate about doing it right. Consistent every time, with…read morea crust which is thin but firm, and high quality toppings distributed evenly across the pie.

Awesome pizza pie and it was cooked until nice and done. We've had some under done pizza lately…read more Good choices and we had the deluxe and added tomatoes. Only take out but right next door is a nice park with a couple tables, perfect for our pizza lunch. We have found no good pizza in Kincardine so have had to stretch out a ways. Tiverton isn't too far and Locknow also has s good one.

Exceptional food...everything we ordered exceeded expectations. service was top notch. Atmosphere…read morewarm and welcoming.

Came here at 855pm based on their posted closing time of 10pm and was told that the kitchen are…read morealready closed. Ironically we were asked if we had a reservation when we walked in. There was only one table being occupied at that moment so it was not as it they were busy... Very disappointing.

Prices are too steep, food just isnt good enough to justify them. Not bad, just not good enough for…read morethe money. Service is good, menu is quite large and varied. Just way too much money for food that average.

Good location, lots of parking, homemade food! Was driving by, am glad we decided to stop in!read more

Had anchovies for the first time in a long time. Excellent! Very tasty, great sauce. Sufficient…read moretoppings for a satisfying slice of pie.

Nice little corner restaurant... fresh locally baked bread, in-house roasted meats, crisp vegetable…read moretoppings. Build your own sandwich or choose a signature one. Daytuna, Canadian Club and Chicken Parmigiana got a thumbs up from my family. Fresh cut fries and friendly service rounded out a great experience. Pass up the restaurant chains. It's worth a stop!

This is a new place in town but it was the first time I managed to get out to it. Great sandwiches…read moreand delicious poutine. Will definitely try the soup next time.

Was lucky enough to stop in at bonfire for a quick lunch with my wife and the quality and service…read morehas not changed, excellent service and absolutely delicious food, we started with the roasted broccoli with the garlic truffle sauce and my wife went with the duck confit Pappardelle And I have wanted to try the calzone for quite some time so that was my selection... My wife said it was the best pasta dish she's had a restaurant ever! The calzone was absolutely delicious with salty salami, stringy mozzarella and a delicious sauce and the dough for the pizza, light and airy and crispy... If you have not been to this restaurant yet it is a must as they will be closing in the future! Thanks again! Zeke

I love this restaurant! Small carefully selected Italian menu, which is made from scratch. The…read moremeatball app is so fresh and lively flavoured and about the best pizza I've ever had.(and I've been to Italy). It may look a bit pricey but the food is so filling with real high end ingredients it is well worth it. Service is excellent. Patio is little a little fairy garden nestled in mature trees. Look for the tree with the braided trunk. Just Go!