Honestly this is some of the best pizza iv ever had in my life perfect amount of cheese and other…read moretoppings. The staff are always great there's a manager there his name is Matt he's the nicest guy around and always makes you feel very welcome I'm happy to support a business with such great staff. Iv eaten inside the place as well great assortment of music great theme all in all I highly recommend the place.

Their claim is to be wood fired pizza restaurant, yet they're using gas ? don't get me wrong their…read morepizza is better than any of the so called pizza places and or chains, but they are doing a disservice to themselves, their customers and pizza by not relying on wood as its fuel source solely. The crust lacks the wood fired taste that only wood as the fuel source can achieve, you can't blend it and expect the same result, their dough did not have that malted taste you get from the traditional double 00 flour and 3 day formational process and leads me to believe it not proofed properly. If you claim to be something then be just that, don't misrepresent the process, thats just marketing not traditional pizza

Worst pizza I've ever received !!! Cheese was poorly placed and pizza was undercooked ! Service was…read morehorrible and they were the most unaccomidating business in town. I do not recommend this pizza place. Customer service is priority. Go to either of the two other pizza places.

I've had Domino's Pizza at multiple locations and usually I am happy... It seems like there may be…read morea quality control issue at this location... The crust was bland and chewy, The toppings were flavourless and the chicken chunks were dry... Hopefully this location will dig deeper with regards to quality control because Domino's Pizza usually is pretty good! Zeke

Ordered online and it's easy as usual. They have a screen that says when your pick up is ready…read morewhich is nice. The girls in the back seemed to be working hard and the young guy up front was polite and quick. Got the pizza home and it tastes pretty good. They did a good job especially when busy and that's tough for some places. Nicely surprised with a tasty pizza this time, maybe cause I got the garlic Parmesan base cause red sauce gives me heartburn ‍

Terrible attitude, their we site says closed at 11pm but they close at 10pm. they refuse to make my…read moreorder that i placed online based off the 11pm at 9:56pm. Won't recommend nor go to them evr again!

I ordered Pizza online When I finished putting all the info I needed and the payment info , I hit…read moreenter and the site said the store was closed and my order didn't go through It was 5:15 and I knew they were open I checked my bank account and the money had come out from Pizza Hut I called the store and they said there was no order under my name I told the Manager what happened and he said I'd get a refund within 7-10 business days and if I wanted to order again and pay again I could I said No I wanted the order I just paid for He said I'd get my money back within 7-19 days , he kept repeating it I was so upset I don't order out much It's probably been 6 months It's too expensive I was so disappointed and I really wanted that pizza I will never order from Pizza Hut again

The pizza buffet is not the greatest, but the pasta portion of the buffet tastes better. But take…read morepizza does taste a lot better then the buffet

had the new Harlem heat love it , love my pizza with bite , going to order it again deliver was on…read moretime and very good driver

We were starving on our trip to Wiarton to go camping for the weekend. Maybe it was me thinking…read moreI'd have to cook on an open flame all weekend so I better get some substantial calories before I burnt everything that made me so hungry:p I told my fiancee to pull into any restaurant that didn't look deserted. We drove by A LOT and I finally yelled just go anywhere and Good Fellas popped up. Hesitant at first, I'm use to seeing tons of cars parked outside a restaurant or a lot of people inside (hey i'm from the city and this was my first camping trip) but the second I walked inside I knew that I may have spoke too soon. The size of the pizza reminds me of Big Slice down in toronto... still not sure which is bigger, but the girl at the counter was super friendly warmed up our pizzas for us and grab us a drink. I couldn't finish this SLICE pizza that is how big it was and I was STARVING. Listen I make all-you-can eat buffets regret their business motto so i'm telling you this slice was HUGE and delicious! I was really happy with the food. The place could use a bit of sprucing up, no one wants to see the foam under the cover of their chairs but hey the food still great! Great price I think two slices came up to $13 with a root beer, it was under $20 I just cant remember how much it was. Great work! Oh and for the people who live up in that area, they deliver!

On our drive home to Toronto and we were starving and didn't feel like the usual Tim Horton's or…read moreburgers/fries. Chose this place because of the decent reviews. Uhhhh.....this pizza gave us instant heartburn and was way too overcooked or overheated up. Sorry, not so much Goodfellas.

SCAM ALERT I…read moreordered a 19" pizza online. I got a call from a 241 pizza call centre (apparently the same place?) to tell me the restaurant can't make this pizza. I asked for an equivalent amount of pizza in sizes the restaurant could make. 2x 14" pizzas is close. Should be a no brainer? Apparently not. NOP decided that I should pay $5 more for this inconvenience, and the call centre would need to check with the restaurant. Honestly, I didn't care at the time. I asked the person I was speaking with to make sure the pizza would start cooking either way. I went into the local supermarket for a moment and missed a call. Voicemail said: No, the restaurant won't make a comparable amount of pizza either. What is this place good for? Not pizza, they don't seem to like making pizza. So I had to call the restaurant and then call centre back to get a refund, which I'm told will be processed in a few days. Awful experience. Looking forward to supporting any other Wiarton business in the future. If this review deters you from ordering, give it a like so NOP knows they lost more than $5 (OK maybe this is not an actual scam but NOP Wiarton has customer service bad enough it may as well have been)

I know this is a chain but I dare say this is better than some pizza I have had at Italian…read morerestaurants in the GTA. They serve up some pretty delicious pizzas for a town as small as Wiarton. The town has very limited options which is not a surprise considering that it has only about ten restaurants. The pizzeria is a good place to stop over on your way to the Bruce peninsula. They have three tables of 4 if you want to eat in. The staff are also quite friendly. We ordered a garlic bread this time and it was so good that it was better than their pizza. It might also be because we had just hiked 8 kms and were starving. For the pizza toppings I like their salami and deluxe pizza. I stop by at this place every time I am up here. The quality and freshness have been pretty consistent. Can't go wrong with that.

Delicious woodfired pizza in Chesley... A friendly team cranking out absolutely delicious pizzas…read morewith a pillowy slightly charred crust and multiple options for toppings... This place is definitely a winner! Check them out! Thank you! Zeke

Great service....fast prep and seriously, The BEST PIZZA we have had in years!!! Soft and…read moredelicious, THIN crust with fresh and simple ingredients. Drive to get this PIZZA this summer. It's SO worth it!

It was very greasy. Can't say anything else…read more People were nice and they seemed to know everyone that walked. Maybe it's just not to my taste.

Ordered a panzerotti with pepperoni bacon and onions. It is baked in their pizza oven. It was a…read morelittle over done on top and somehow a little under done on the bottom. It was was still great and the left over the next day in the air fryer came out great. Very inexpensive and good quality.