4.5 stars rounded up! We visited the day after Christmas and had a wonderful meal! Pros- beautiful interior, great service, very good dirty martini, fun menu, AMAZING short rib poutine. Cons- the gravy in the seafood grits had large chunks of ham which was interesting but the mela was still good, Caesar salad could be better. read more

The Pier - Dining area - Seafood Near Me - Harbor Springs, Michigan

See all

We've been dining at the pier for forty years. To say we are disappointed with the staff, service and quality is an understatement. We spend half the year in HS and do not choose the pier as a place to dine any longer. Such a shame. O read more

As I previously reviewed we were visiting Harbor Springs downtown and the beach in the morning. This was our first time here with my family of seven including three adults and three young children for our 12 noon lunch reservation. The restaurant opened a few minutes after 12 noon. Other customers ahead of us were also waiting to be seated. The hostess was not very friendly. The older female hostess seemed to be annoyed, when we checked in. We were seated at a round table near the deck. We had a partial view of the bay. I enjoyed my two Michigan Manhattans with Iron Fish bourbon whiskey, sweet vermouth, Iron Fish cherry maple smoked bitters and a cherry up for $19 each. I also enjoyed my reuben for $21. The reuben is made with Sy Ginsberg corned beef, house sauerkraut, swiss, house thousand island dressing, toasted rye and beef tallow fries. This restaurant is expensive. Our food service was slow even though the restaurant was not crowded. We had to wait almost an hour for our food to be served to us. Being with young children was not good for our young children to wait so long. Keni served us very well. I don't think Keni was the cause of our slow food service. Our total bill was $242 excluding gratuity. read more

See all

Lovely view and great service. We prefer eating in the cozier bar but they also have these cool booths in the main dining room with a nautical theme. Consistently decent fish & seafood with wonderful water views on the deck. read more

I usually stay quiet on these reviews but, the Pier's fish tacos were terrible. they should be embarrassed. it came on a rectangular board. 4 corn tortillas laid on there like flat circles, covered in purple cabbage slaw. two big brown fried pieces of formerly frozen fish dropped on top like Dr Scholls foot inserts...gross. fries on the side but so what. overpriced and awful. read more

Went for dinner last night. Beautiful restaurant. Everything else was troubling. Upon arrival, we waited for 10 minutes for the hostess to appear. After 8 minutes there were two other couples in the queue. The place was pretty empty and it felt like the other couples were an inconvenience since they didn't have a reservation (I made one the day before). I really felt badly for the other folks. The staff should be gracious regardless of who called ahead and those who made a spontaneous decision to dine there. So, I've learned my lesson with ordering cocktails in places like this. A decision was made to order a few glasses of wine. Half the price of a cocktail and the typically inept bartender can't screw it up... It took a while for the drinks to get to us, but they finally did. 2 minutes before the entrées. So much for a relaxing libation before dinner. We ordered whitefish with rather high expectations. It appears disappointment is bountiful this time of year. The fish was waaaaaayyyyyy over salted and the unpealed mashed potatoes were gluey. It was also overcooked. The potatoes sucked... OK, I hate "smashed" potatoes. To me they're just an extremely lazy excuse for "half assing" the ​carbs. Please, just peel the damn things.​ And don't make the entire night's needs at 2:00 in the afternoon as they'll just turn into paste. Yuck! The broccoli Rabe was good... So, another $90 bucks for a pretty terrible meal. Our waitress, Jordan was a sweet girl, hence the 2 stars. read more

My brother and his wife got food poisoning here. I believe they notified the health department. It hasn't been the same and I miss the old Pier which was distinctive and well known for its quality fare and style. read more

This place exceeded our expectations after seeing a 3-star rating. Our boys loved the kids noodles with a shared petite filet, my wife's clam chowder and salad were great (I ate all the dried cherries), and my smash burger was really tasty. The only issue I had with the burger (and this is a burger pet peeve of mine), is that the bottom bun was too soggy from all the juices. Otherwise it was a pretty good experience, including the dock seating and views of the water. read more

Great little cocktail place before dinner with snacks. The inside is cute and it has a nice view of the boat harbor. read more

The Pier - Burrata - Seafood Near Me - Harbor Springs, Michigan

See all

My wife and I had dinner last night at this restaurant and she had the escargot risotto and clam chowder soup. About 4 hours later she was vomiting and had diarrhea... this was the only thing she ate all day. My best guess... food poisoning as she usually has guts of steel. Of course, we won't be returning. I should mention the dining room floor is carpeting (not clean), there were gnats and a fly buzzing around and a hair was found on my wife's plate. Not worth $155.00... read more

We came here as we had a Stafford's gift card to utilize. I Will note we came on a Saturday night about an hour before close in early May, so this likely contributed to having no wait time. But we were greeted promptly and staff seemed to make an effort to seat us at maybe the table with the best view in the place, in the corner wall of windows. Service was pretty prompt and polite. I got the ribeye which I believe was a special, served with scallops, mashed potatoes, and asparagus. It was cooked very well and delicious. My husband got the whitefish sandwich with sweet potato fries and he didn't leave much on the plate! The clientele seemed to skew older, not a complaint, just an observation. Probably a great place to take parents and family to impress them. We enjoyed a walk on the pier after as well. read more

The Pier - Seafood Near Me - Harbor Springs, Michigan

We arrived around 4pm on a Saturday night. The restaurant was fairly empty. The food was overcooked and under seasoned. We sent back the filet and the salmon was fishy and overcooked as well. The short ribs resembled pot roast with undercooked carrots. The clam chowder is fantastic and mainly the reason for the second star. read more

We came to the pier today after the 4th of July parade hoping to grab some food before heading back home. Unfortunately our experience hit all the wrong notes. While we understand it was a holiday, the restaurant was barely half full and it took us over an hour to receive our food. During that time our waiter visited our table maybe once after taking our order to bring us drinks. We had to request refills from the host area. Once we received our food, our fish and chips was undercooked and the salad we'd ordered had no dressing. Oh and it was also the wrong salad... The burgers we ordered must have been cooked and prepped ahead of time because the buns were so soggy. We love to spend our time and money supporting local spots in harbor springs but it will be a long time before we return to the Pier... if ever read more

I read a lot about the food "not being what it used to be". Well, I had never been there, so had no preconceived notions. Went for lunch. Got a table facing the water. Had a lovely 9 oz pour of French white. The seafood chowder is fab. If you're getting the seafood chowder, get the bread service. The homemade focaccia is great. The crab cakes are the best I've ever had. They are delish on their own, but served on greens/corn with a delicious drizzle = mwah. read more

The seafood "tower". When asked if there are usually crackers for the dip, our waitress said "I've never actually seen this ordered before". read more

The Pier - Seafood Near Me - Harbor Springs, Michigan

The Ambience at The Pier is incredible. combine the harbor views with an inventive designer and the interior of The Pier is worth seeing. the service was a little slow for an off time lunch with no crowd but our server was nice. Clam Chowder-Excellent. 8/10 French Fries-Very good LOBSTER ROLL ($36)-POOR/INEDIBLE the bun looked classic but the lobster looked strange. the mayonnaise or whatever prep they used was no longer white as if heated. The lobster may have been de thawed 2 times? Its texture was gooey and spreadable. It wasn't fishy. But usually lobster prepared for a lobster roll is white and firm yet rich. This lobster meat was a translucent blu. Every restaurant has its screw ups and off shifts so I might go back but am staying away from the Jelly Roll. Great soup. Worth a visit just for the interior and view. read more

I think there were probably a lot of great things about this restaurant. The rest of my party really enjoyed their meals. I guess I ordered the wrong thing. Anyway, where to begin... We had reservations 3-4 weeks out for a party of 7. Upon arrival, they half-hazardly threw us all around a round table that was *maybe* for 4-5 people max. Not preset, kind of in a dirty, forgotten corner on the patio. Meanwhile, other reserved tables were preset with waters, menus, etc. Not sure what that was about, but we made it work. The whitefish trio appetizer was insanely good. The smoked whitefish pate was CRAZY GOOD. Everyone else in our party enjoyed their meals, and service was generally good. Unfortunately, my meal was the most flavorless, bland thing I have ever eaten. It was the whitefish with couscous and veggies. I couldn't even get the attention of our waiter to ask for salt and pepper shakers, unfortunately. Got the vibe that it was one of those places you don't ask for salt. Bummer. I would try this place again with a smaller party and different order. The patio view of the bay was beautiful. When we walked out of the restaurant, the local band was playing on the lawn. Cute. read more

A classic northern Michigan restaurant that has gone through recent changes to ownership and staff. The menu still offers some of the old standby entrees but many are no longer available. I tried the scallops that were served on a bed of risotto with a tasty zesty sauce. Very good. The Caesar salad was just ok. Not special. Our server Maverick did a decent job with a group of eight although I was hoping he could give us individual bills. This restaurant doesn't have the "old-world" charm that it had 20-30 years ago but it's still one of the better options if you're looking for a solid dining experience in Harbor Springs. read more

The Pier - Interior lighting - Seafood Near Me - Harbor Springs, Michigan

See all

I've always loved The Pier but today was an exceptional experience due to the service we received. Maverick was our server and we were a party of 15. He had such a lovely demeanor and made sure that everyone was taken care of. It takes a special person to balance a table of 15 while serving other tables as well. Thank you Maverick! read more

The Pier - Seafood Near Me - Harbor Springs, Michigan

See all

I arrived looking to sit outside to have a cocktail and take in the scenery of the harbour.. the hostess informed me that there was no tables available outside i inquired about inside on the harbour side nope no tables available.. I was given the option to sit in the bar area in which I referred to as the blue collar bar.. I ordered a drink then took a stroll to the upper part of the restaurant it was empty and the outside had 6 tables open.. not sure why I was lied to about but I was dressed in nice clothes and didn't give the appearance of a person who didn't belong.. I chose a 2 star because the bartender was nice instead of a 1star for the way I was treated.. don't waste your money on this restaurant.. between this town and Petoskey way to crowded and snooty.. much better places that will appreciate you.. read more

Tried to order take out and you can't. I always could under the previous owners. This place used to be so awesome the new owners have altered the menu and taken away the super customers service. Disappointed that my favorites are gone. read more

Excellent! Our server was wonderful and all 7 of us were thoroughly impressed with our food. My salmon was among the best I've ever had. Ambience was warm and lovely. Will definitely be back ASAP! read more

Go here! Everything was incredible! The food is amazing. We got the crab cakes, fish and chips, and reuben! Afterwards you can take a walk to the docks and see the views! read more

The Pier - Fish and chips - Seafood Near Me - Harbor Springs, Michigan

See all

Excellent food and service. The location and view of the harbor are fantastic. Great ambiance

Our second terrible experience this summer at what used to be one of our 'go to' places. We had out of town business associates here for lunch. I told the hostess upon entering they had a plane to catch in an hour and a 15 minutes. It took nearly 15 minutes to get water poured. We all ordered salads. Both my friend (who was buying) and myself got up to ask the staff to bring our food (after nearly an hour). The only reason we even came back was the location: so out of town guests could see the bay. Read the recent reviews from this summer. Most people we know here in Harbor Springs have signed the place off. read more

Wow! What has happened here? So bizarre to see how this place has changed. Food, service, drinks, etc. are not what they used to be. Very disappointed. Don't even know to bring your saland BEFORE your dinner. So sad!! read more

When you charge a high dollar you better come with some game. My family of four (me, brother, mother and father) went here and two got the white fish and two got the herb chicken. My mother complained of the white fish lacking salt and was bland. The table had zero salt or pepper to add. My brother and I had the herb chicken. It was okay but really seemed to lack in the herbal category but it was still a big chunk of chicken that was moist (maybe too wet) and buttery with the sauce they did have on it. My biggest complaint was the drinks. I remember coming here earlier this year and thinking the drinks I got were lacking. One being an old fashioned. At this meal I got a margarita and it was one of the worst margaritas I have ever had. The old fashioned wasn't fantastic but it was still okay and enjoyable. I saw a young girl behind the bar. No idea if she's the one making the drinks but if it is young seasonal help that's making high end drinks then you have already set yourself up for failure as a bar/restaurant. My entire family had the same feelings leaving. Unimpressed. I would never eat here again. At the cost of poorly made drinks of which I had several over the course of two trips, I would pass on drinks here also. I know not everyone will have the same experiences but this was my family's experience. When I talked to the waiter he had a touch of shortness with me as I appeared to mention things to him he already knew. I was not sure of his experience which is why I was trying to understand what his knowledge was on what they served if the menu was not accurate. I was not saying this in an off tone either. They had lacking organization with the menu and had liquors there that were apparently not found in the computer system or not on some list they refer to. I would go to the New York restaurant in a second over this as my experience there was much better. And my suggestion to anyone in this area is that if you want a real unbelievable chicken dinner, head to the Dam Site Inn just outside of Petoskey. Even the New York has a better chicken dinner. I have gone to places around where I live in Grand Rapids for epic drinks. MDRD at the top of the Amway, the Drip Drop and Nightwatch cocktail lounges and so on. A good drink shouldn't take you more than a few seconds to realize. I fought to find any benefits here with mine. read more

The food was very good, but the service and staff were awesome! Laila, our server, was amazing- what a great personality and so fun! She is awesome! We were there twice in two days- once for lunch and once for dinner. If we ever come back, we will definitely be coming here again! Loved sitting outside on the water for lunch. Nice bar area also! read more

The service by Danielle was outstanding. She had a great personality and handled our group of 10 with humor and grace. The salmon was great. Everyone liked their meals. The ambiance was amazing with the open air and views. read more

We waited 10 minutes. Not one person acknowledged us! We left. I have left 2 restaurants in my life. This was one. Very rude! Do not recommend read more

The atmosphere is nice and was able to talk easily. The service was friendly and fast. The food was delicious with small changes that would make it wven better. The menu is seafood heave, as expected from the pier. The escargot was delicious, and the salad was very nice, the whole anchovies were a surprise, but not unwelcomed. Pasta was cooked nicely. The lobster roll is served cold and could use more dressing or butter. Overall a very nice experience. read more

The Pier - Escargot - Seafood Near Me - Harbor Springs, Michigan

I walk in there and get seated fairly quickly, but that's where it went downhill. I ordered a glass of wine and it was 19 minutes from the time I ordered it to the time that it got to me. The server that was serving me was on her second day and she was training another girl under her that was doing her first day, and there were no senior servers. It was almost comical, watching the roulette of dishes and glasses of drinks get to the wrong table consistently while I sat there therefore I decided not to order food.. I believe the staff manager came by and started asking everybody how their meal was and it was Discontent with everybody in the entire section that I was in. I was only going to give one star, but they had a great recovery. Not only did I get another glass of wine, but it was all on the house. If it weren't for the beautiful view And the incredibly nice with no excuse manager, it would've gotten a one star. Good recovery, but really bad service. read more

Used to be great, ruined by new ownership. New menu, horrible service, bring back the old Stafford's Pier experience. Will not be back.

We used to love The Pier. I've had the whitefish at least a dozen times. Our most recent visit was disappointing. The food came out 45 minutes after ordering. It wasn't cold but lukewarm. An app ordered to split came on one plate. The whitefish was questionable. I left most of it on the plate. New ownership has been a significant downgrade. Won't be dining there again. read more

Delicious, giant cut of white fish with nice seasoning. Had a great view of the harbor and quick service. A touch overpriced but much of the places downtown are, so a solid choice regardless read more

The Pier - Whitefish - Seafood Near Me - Harbor Springs, Michigan

Ambiance is amazing, food is way overpriced and absolutely horrible. Hostess is rude. Waitstaff added drinks to our bill that we did not have--glad we caught it. read more

We came here for my mom's 70th Birthday dinner on 07/08/24, and it did not disappoint! We had a thirty minute wait, so we went to the outside bar, and had a round of drinks poured by Grace, who was as friendly as she was beautiful! When our table became ready, we were seated and our (new to the restaurant) server was a young gentleman from Virginia, Andrew G., who is working in MI for the summer. Andrew was GREAT! Just who we needed for a celebration and genuine personality. Bravo, Andrew! There was a band playing out in the park lawn, and she ships/boats all coming in with a beautiful sunset, when we dined outside. The Crab Tostada, Mediterranean Linguine, Waygu Burger, and Seafood chowder were AMAZING. So so good! I pairs it with a little Honey Bubbles Moscato and enjoyed it immensely. The young ladies at the front door were also great to have an exchange with, and the young man who was hosting. Way to go, Pier Restaurant staff! read more

See all

Food was very good, staff was very friendly and attentive, but the best part was their beautiful new china. Pretty blue patterns that really made the table and dinner feel special. Seems like a small thing, but interesting to see what the new owners are up to and what we may look forward to for other changes. read more

Dinner tonight was very disappointing. Limited menu and not the same quality or variety as this restaurant was when it was Stafford's. Lobster roll had very little meat, mostly bread. Service was fine at our early dinner. Ambiance is same as when it was Stafford's. I will think twice before coming back for just that. read more

Really enjoyed our drinks and apps on their lovely patio. High points for the Michigan Manhattan--best cocktail all week on our vacation. Skip the crap cakes and get the crab tostadas...so good! The seafood chowder was also a highlight. read more