Very helpful and excellent customer service! Everyone should come here!…read more Helped me pick a good Pinot Noir! Everyone should visit Atlantic Wine and liquor!

Terrible experience. The store owner tried to charge me $19.99 for a bottle that was clearly marked…read more$12.99. When I told him how it was marked, he replied in a nasty tone of voice: "Nice try! It's not going for that." He then tried to show me an identical bottle marked $19.99, but I had already taken a photo before he scraped the prices off. He then tried to accuse me of somehow magically putting on a fake price tag before yelling at me that he didn't like that I took a picture. He then took the bottles away and said: "Take a hike. Get out of my store!" And, then started shouting like a lunatic yelling at me as I exited. So, basically they decided to lose a sale of two bottles of wine totaling almost $30 because they wanted an additional $7 which they lost solely due to their own error for which they refuse to take responsibility. Not to mention, I've been a loyal customer buying there every summer, and now I will never go back and I will tell everyone I know what happened. Oh and by the way, the owner was not even wearing a mask.

Neighborhood liquor store with a solid selection. They have enough variety in a range of prices to…read moremake it a worthwhile stop. The service is stiff, though, and that drops it a star (and I tend to be generous).

This is not a huge liquor store but it is off the main road and you can pop in and get what you…read moreneed relatively quickly. The selection is pretty decent for a store of its size and they manage to make good use of the space with calculated stacking and display techniques while allowing the appearance of the shelves to be clutter free. There is a small fridge in the back with a few selections that are pre-chilled for convenience. The pricing overall is about 2-3$ above average than where I typically shop back home but likely on par with other liquor stores in this area overall. After all, they do cater to the Hamptonite crowd and can get away with it. They stock wine from both of the local vineyards as well; Wolffer and Channing Daughters. In fact there's more wine than anything else. The liquors are limited but some good choices were available. They had the organic chardonnay I was looking for which was a plus and I also tried a brand of prosecco there that was new to me and it was rather tasty. The chardonnay typically runs about 11-12$ but it was on sale here for $15.99 The lady behind the counter who I can only assume is the owner doesn't exactly have a sunny disposition or perhaps she was just having a bad day. She did however offer assistance in finding what we were looking for and even made a few suggestions. There was no one else in the store so we got quite a bit of personal attention. Overall it's difficult to judge with nothing to compare to so as of right now I'm rating it four stars but I may adjust once I've checked out some other liquor stores in the area.

The best selection, great prices and very knowledgeable owner and staff. An absolute wonderful…read moreLiquor Store !!! The best liquor store I have ever been to in my life 5

The owner and staff are so warm and welcoming and they always have what I need. Shout out to the…read morewoman there, wished I had gotten her name, that when she saw that I lost my wallet was going to give me money! How nice is that?! Thank you so much. Very kind of you!

Small beer store in East Hampton but has alot of different brands to choose from. Worker here is…read morenice. They also sell mixers, sodas and other stuff besides just beer.

From east hampton to montauk I've found no better place for a great variety of craft beers, ciders…read moreand other beverages than Sam's. It's close to the east hampton train station, has ample nearby parking and is right next to grindstone coffee and donuts.

By far the best curated liquor store outside of Manhattan!! The owners are a husband and wife and…read moretheir selection is amazing! The store is gorgeous too! This is what you'd expect in The Hamptons!

Wonderful selection, well-organized shop. Owner and staff always willing to help and share their…read moreknowledge.

These people work hard. Currently they have an efficient Covid-19 protocol in place. Still, whether…read moreI've called ahead (to make sure they had what I needed) or just stopped by; service has been fast AND pleasant, always. Pull up to the door, call the number on the door and they take it from there. For Browsers, that'll have to wait until we have a vaccine, BUT still a friendly, local neighborhood spot. Thanks

Used to be fantastic with a beer cave and lots of variety. Not so much now. Its not horrible just…read morenothing special

This place is awesome. Extremely well stocked. Jesse's the man-- always knows his stuff. It's the…read moreonly spot I'll go for beer in the area. 5/5 would recommend

For a small little island liquor store this place delivers. Nice variety of wines. Liquor and mixed…read moredrink cocktails. Found all that we wanted,

On April 18, 2013, I tried making a Fresh Direct order and received the message: WE DO NOT…read moreCURRENTLY DELIVER TO SHELTER ISLAND. Confused, I googled wine and Liquors on Shelter Island and was directed to Dandy Liquors. What a pleasure when I called and the woman on the other end of the offered to grab a few bottles and suggest from her offerings. Amazing and they deliver!