I hate to give bad reviews on a business, but since this this was my wedding I can't hold back. I went to their place an order a cupcake just to try it and I it was good, so I decided to order my wedding cake from them. I shouldn't know from the moment I place the order the lack of knowledge and unprofessionalism this place has. Planning a wedding is stressful enough and doing everything with 2 weeks left was even worst. I ask a family member to pick up the cake and when she went to pick up the cake she realise the cake was a mess, with no frosting in some areas and she had to wait over 30 minutes for them to fix the cake. Once at the reception when it came the time to cut the cake it was hard and impossible to cut, it almost felt like the cake was in a freezer from the day before. The cake was vanilla with strawberry filling and it tasted like a poorly done box cake with the edge almost burnt and barely any filling. I asked for a foundant cake and they told me they do not work with foundant, only regular frosting but hey will assure me it will look great. The cake looked like like someone made a cake for the first time, it was hard dense and hard to even swallow. It was a total disappointment and I would never order from them again. Too bad I looked up the reviews of this place after my wedding. Stay away from this place if you want a nice wedding cake. read more

I was invited to a beautiful wedding Sept 15th 2018 @ Rainbow Mt. Everything was perfect except No Cake! The grooms finally called wondering where there wedding cake was! Ur company said they were in some sort of an accident! Really? Why in the world wouldn't someone , anyone from PattyCakes call them 1st! What a horrible thing to do to people on there most special day! Why haven't u refunded thier money? Why haven't u had the decency to give them an apology?!?! Its been 2 weeks now. What kind of business runs like that?? I've lived in this area my whole life & know a lot of people & best believe word of mouth can make or ruin a business. read more

Absolutely the worst experience I've ever had in my life. I recently attended a wedding where they were supposed to have brought a cake needless to say no cake arrived they said that they had an accidental going to repair part of the cake and at no time to the cake or the cupcakes arrived for the party the groom's had to purchase a cake from a grocery store. you would think that this would have mortified any other establishment and they would have made recompense or figured out some way to make this right no they completely ignore the couple and refuse to return the money or do anything in return for this horrendous treatment. read more

This bakery was contracted to provide a wedding cake and cupcakes to my congregants wedding that took place on Sept 15th at Rainbow Mountain in East Stroudsburg. The first story we heard was that they were running late after yet 2 more calls, remarkably the delivery person was in a car accident. I sure hope this wasn't used as an excuse. My grooms were terribly hurt and part of their day was ruined. Then I was told by my congregants Patty Cake Bakery never offered an apology nor did they refund their money. This in my opinion is a terrible way to do business and I would reccomend this bakery to anyone using them for a special day other than maybe dinner at Auntie's house. SHAME ON YOU AND YOUR BUSINESS PRACTICES. Make this right by refunding the money to the grooms from September 15, 2018 at Rainbow Mountain Resort. I also sure hope this wasn't done because they were 2 men. Shameful. read more

Do not use them. They never delivered my cousins Cake to his wedding and haven't refunded him or even apologize. They told him the cake was in a car accident and lied about it. I see they told another person the same thing in June. They are terrible. I would of gave them a no star review. I can't believe the dishonesty of these people they took all his money upfront and no cake. They need to be shut down!!!!!!! read more

Do not book with this baker! I ordered my wedding cake with them and it WAS NEVER DELIVERED ON MY WEDDING DAY! Worst experience. I should have known by how inexperienced they seemed in the back and forth: only asked for checks, receipts for purchase were just an email with details, they asked multiple times to send over the same details. Beware...you will not receive what you paid for if you order from this service. I am still waiting for a refund from Anthony (Natalie) Pollara & Corinn Pollara (Corinn Finley) and will continue to share this information across the internet until i do. Corinn: In response to your reply, I said it was great to work with you before getting scammed out of my money because you were so easy going likely cause you knew you were never actually going to make anything for me. Unfortunately, your former employer let you both go because he said you both were nothing but difficult and drama since the first day you started with his bakery. I reached out to your former employer because you both left me no choice with constant lies, absurd excuses, and periods of ignoring me entirely to inform him of what his employees Natalie (Tony) and Corinn had done - seems like he should know if he has people that could effect his own business reputation working for him. This was not a threat but merely informing him as a business owner of who he had working for him which seemed to the "final straw" after an already terrible track record you both seemed to have already created for yourselves at his bakery. Seems like you had it coming for a while. While speaking with him he also told me very specific information about the day of my wedding when i was SUPPOSED to have a cake. He recalled that you and Natalie asked to borrow equipment from his bakery at 3pm that day for a cake that needed to go out by 4pm which he knew was NEVER going to happen which we know is true (it didn't) because i never received a cake. If he were to see your page today and all of the horrific reviews corroborating all negative claims against this scam business, I bet he'd feel relieved not having to be associated with you both any more. Also, great to know you both have new and better paying jobs! This will be helpful with recouping my funds and funds for all of the other customers you've scammed...very helpful information, indeed! To all other reviewers who had a horrible experience: I hope we are able to all take this to court together and get reimbursed for the hundreds (if not thousands) of dollars in funds owed to hard working people. Natalie and Corinn:should be ashamed to scam people out of paid for goods on their special occasions. For anyone wondering: Here is a photo of my wedding planner verifying that the cake was never delivered. And the bakeries response to my review is confirmation they never reimbursed me. I'm owed hundreds of dollars for a cake that was never made by Corinn Finley and Natalie/Anthony Pollara. read more

Patty Cake Bakery - Custom Cakes Near Me

This bakery is not is Stroudsburg, it's a unlicensed home run business in Slatington, Pa. Do not use them. They want half the money up front and then have a excuse when your cake is NOT delivered. Would not recommend this at home bakery. They also go by many different alias names, Natalie Finley, Natalie Pollara, Natalie Pallara, Natalie Range, Anthony Pollara, Corrin Finley & Corrin Pollara. I would highly suggest you Google these names before you get scammed!!! read more

I attended a wedding and couldn't wait to try this cake that was to be as beautiful as the day was , I was just wondering if that cake ever was delivered or if anyone had the decency to apologize or offer a full refund to the grooms? Planning a wedding is stressful enough but not having a cake or cupcakes to celebrate and serve to your friends and family is to say the least very unprofessional! read more

If I could I would give them no stars. I was at a wedding in September and they were supposed to deliver a cake and cupcakes. They claimed they had a fender bender and the cake needed minor repairs. The wedding was hours later, but they never delivered the cake or the cupcakes that we're not damaged. They never called, never apologized never gave back the money. Terrible! Do not order from them. read more

I highly recommend this bakery! The cake was amazing and delicious. Very accommodating and go above and beyond for their customers. I was so happy with my son's first birthday cake and our guests loved it! read more

Patty Cake Bakery - Loved this! - Custom Cakes Near Me

Don't let the compact size of the shop dissuade, great things come in small packages. I stopped here on the way back to NYC amazed to find a friendly baking team with delicious authentic baked goods (AND COFFEE!!!) for me to salivate over. Their prices are perfect and the food is all made from scratch. Skip the chain wanna be, pre-made garbage elsewhere and see Patty for the good stuff. It was great to learn that this young couple is so passionate about their craft and the tradition of authentic bakeries are safe for yet another day. MMMMMM! read more

This place is a sham. DO NOT BUY from this "business" unless you're okay with made up excuses and not ever receiving your product. One of my close friends told me alll about the cupcakes and cake design he was supposed to receive on his wedding day and I'm not even a huge fan of cake, but I was excited. Wedding day comes and they "got into a car accident". Sound familiar? You'll hear it on a lot of there reviews. Wether these accidents are real or fabricated, these scam artists refuse to refund the money to their customers despite the fact that the product NEVER SHOWED UP. I can't say it enough, DO NOT GIVE THESE PEOPLE YOUR HARD EARNED MONEY!!! read more

If I could give this establishment a half of a star I would! They are complete fraud. some very close friends of mine had a wedding up in the Poconos a few weeks ago. They ordered a cake and cupcakes from this place they have a tasting everything was going well the payment options were a little odd but they proceeded. Day of the wedding everything's going great the wedding was beautiful the cake hadn't arrived before the wedding which was sort of a red flag but the groom's were not going to let that deter them from their special day. A few hours into the wedding there's still no cake. They got a text message saying that they were in an accident and they were going back to the bakery to fix what was wrong and they would be up shortly. They never showed up! They proceeded to basically fight with the groom's about getting their money back. They refused to give the money back is what happening now. They said they made the product so they didn't think they should give the money back. But when a product never shows up made or not we have no proof that it was actually made. So this establishment is obviously fake in every way shape or form. Do not do business with these people. There will be some sort of excuse to not get your product. The main excuses what I'm seeing from other reviews is car accidents. Now I know you're up in the mountains! But car accidents don't happen to the same people that often unless you're just the most horrendous driver ever! And all I'm saying is that you're the worst business person ever! read more

See all

Love this bakery and their work! Ordered a cake for a birthday and they made sure to make it within two days and gave me an amazing price, they delivered the cake on time and corrinn was so professional and friendly. The cake looked soooo good and everyone loved it! I would definitely recommend this to anyone who wants a cake for special occasion :) read more

Patty Cake Bakery - Custom Cakes Near Me

Yes, we left a voicemail stating we were happy w the cupcakes, regardless of the fact that they were NOT what was ordered and that they were 5 hours late. We are not cruel and aren't hard to please. We were just happy SOMETHING arrived to put a candle in so we could sing happy birthday. We are NOT the type to complain for no reason. Not one of us are the type to order something and make up lies to get free product. We are hard working adults that can afford the $130 charge. However, when we took a closer look it was clear they were store bought, the frosting was not the buttercream we ordered, there's was barely any gold dust glitter requested, they had sprinkles (not asked for), there was a plastic piece left in one of them, something you'd find in store bought cupcakes. So now let's add this up 1. 5 hour late delivery 2. Not the design we ordered (vanilla buttercream frosting dusted w gold glitter, w black cupcake paper wraps) 3. Not the flavor we ordered (whipped frosting, not butter cream) 4. Not the size we ordered 5. They were unpacked out of a plastic container you'd find when buying from a local grocery store. Vanilla buttercream was ordered for all 4 dozen, but 4 cupcakes had chocolate frosting. Why? Because wherever she bought them from probably didn't have enough vanilla so she had no choice but to buy a pack of chocolate to make up the last 4 to get us the 4 dozen ordered. Why else would you throw in 4 chocolate? But WE are wrong? Our only wrong was choosing your poor excuse for a "bakery". She continues to say we are wrong and her other customers will back her up. I find that hard to believe bc her pics barely have any "likes" and/or comments. If you go to her Facebook page you will see you can't comment on her posts. And, until we went to social media to address it the texts to rectify this were ignored. Bad business all around. Please, do yourself a favor and ORDER ELSEWHERE! You only get 1 star because I have to give 1 to post a review. read more

I ordered a cake from them and even gave them a picture of what cake I wanted for my baby shower...what a mistake! The theme was a nautical cake and when the cake came "Corinn" told me that she had some trouble with the buoy that was on the front and tried to fix it but failed. That was only the beginning....it was a 2 tier cake that was completely sinking in the back, the fondant lines where all crooked and inconsistent (some lines started skinny then became fat then skinny again, etc. ). There were flags on the cake that were not aligned, they were crooked and all over the place and the cake itself just crumbled when we cut into it. Some of our guests didn't even get a full piece of cake! They got a plate full of crumbs and icing. Not to mention it was obviously box cake!! You can tell it wasn't homemade! And the cake board was just a flimsy piece of cardboard. Not at all what I asked for which you can see in the pictures. All in all the cake was very amateur. It looked like whoever did it had no skill at all. It was just very sloppy and a complete eyesore at our baby shower! I also make cakes but because I am pregnant I couldn't do it myself (which I usually would) and I felt the need to get up in front of my guests and let them know that I DID NOT make the cake. I didn't want anyone thinking I would make anything so hideous especially for my own shower! On top of it all they charged me $350 for this terrible cake!! In the end, I tried to contact them to let them know I was disappointed in the cake and nobody has contacted me back to this day! Maybe if they did, I wouldn't have felt the need to post a bad review but no reputable business would just ignore a customers complaint! I will NEVER use these people again ...and I don't even know what your orientation is so I don't even know where that came from and YES I tried to contact you SEVERAL times and no response to any of my messages. But anyway yeah, I have found another baker that is way more professional and does a fantastic job! Thank you! read more

Unfortunate that my son and his husband never received their wedding cake or cupcakes to celebrate with the guests. This, on THE most important day of their lives filled with family and friends. Your bakery created an unnecessary, stress filled afternoon leading up to and including the wedding ceremony. No apology, no refund, just excuse after excuse. WE CAN'T redo that day, but YOU CAN do whatever you have to to make it right. read more

Unprofessional "bakery". And I use the term bakery loosely. Never delivered the wedding cake & cupcakes that were ordered for a wedding. This "business" is just a scam and stay away! Don't fall victim to their games and lies. These people are only in it to ruin lives. read more

Amazing quality for all their pastries! Their cheese Danishes hands down are some of the best around. I highly recommend this place! The prices are very fair, and the owners really enjoy making these fantastic baked good. read more

We contacted Patty Cake Bakery to make a special cake for our sons first birthday party. Corinn did a phenomenal job on the cake inside and out....so much so that people thought it was part of the party decorations!! The cake was perfectly light and fluffy and the filling/frosting was not too sweet. We selected a three tier cake, with each tier being a different flavor (spice cake with sweet cream cheese filling, chocolate cake with cannoli filling and vanilla cake with cookies and cream buttercream filling). While cannoli filling is my favorite, so I am biased with that cake being my favorite, they were all so good! I can't wait t have another party so I can order another cake!!! Thank you Corinn for making the day even more special for us. read more

Patty Cake Bakery - Thank you Corinn for our very special cake! - Custom Cakes Near Me

We hired this bakery to create my grandmothers 100th birthday cake--it was the BEST decision. The cakes were delicious, moist and decorated EXACTLY as we asked. We had the number 1 (chocolate frosting on yellow cake) then 2 other "zero" cakes--one was vanilla on white with ganash filling--the other we said "surprise us"--it wound up being chocolate cake with mint filling YUM!!! They did these AWSOME cakes with only 2 weeks notice---if you need something tasting great--looking spectacular--and created perfectly--call this place!! It is not out of business (this cake was delivered on 7-7-2012) read more

I went to a 30th birthday party this weekend where the young lady asked for cup cakes made into a large 30, what she got, 5 hours after the delivery that was scheduled for 4pm and she showed up at 9pm! They had to be store bought cupcakes as they were nothing that she requested and she has the text messages to prove it. She asked for gold dusting, which Corinn said they could do and got rainbow sprinkles, asked for buttercream icing and some had chocolate icing, which also was not asked for, should have been 40 cupcakes, there were maybe 25 - 30 small cupcakes and she had the audacity to charge $130 for such terrible service. After reading some of the other reviews, all I can say is the good reviews were between 4 - 8 years ago so her service has drastically declined. A text message was sent saying how disappointed she was, and to tell Corinn she still had not received her receipt for the $130 to which neither text did Corinn respond to but she sure cashed her check! read more

TERRIBLE! They ruined my wife's birthday! Called me a day before her party that they didn't think they would be able to make it because the girl that took my order didn't tell the bakers. They said they would try to make it though. The day of the party, they didn't even have the decency to call to tell me that the cake will not me delivered. I had to call and they told me that the lady's kitchen caught on fire and ruined the cake....right. Oh but to make things right, they gave me 15% off my next purchase. HA! I Will NEVER go back there again. DONT GO THERE IF YOU WANT YOUR SPECIAL DAY RUINED!!! NOT A RELIABLE BAKERY! read more

They are in business and do custom orders, but no longer have a store front in Stroudsburg.

Cake that I ordered was not made. TERRIBLE! They ruined my wife's birthday! Called me a day before her party that they didn't think they would be able to make it because the girl that took my order didn't tell the bakers. They said they would try to make it though. The day of the party, they didn't even have the decency to call to tell me that the cake will not be delivered. I had to call and they told me that they lady brought my cake home to her apartment before the delivery and her apartment cause on fire....right. Oh but to make things right, they gave me 15% off my NEXT purchase. HA! I will NEVER even look at that website again. DON'T USE THIS FAKE SERVICE IF YOU DON'T WANT YOUR SPECIAL DAY TO BE RUINED! Fake service, scammers, and all the reviews that are positive on Yelp are their Facebook friends which I'm pretty sure is against Yelp policy. Hope they get kicked off soon and stop scamming people ASAP. read more

I scheduled a cake for my son's birthday with this bakery, even though they have no store front and just a web site. The owner asked me to make a deposit by putting money into her bank account, which made me a little leary. Luckily I had the same bank so I used a service through the bank, because we ended up canceling and I got my money back from the bank with no hassle and no need to deal with her. She was saying that the payment would need to be made in full a week before the party date. Mind you, I have never paid for any other cake, any other service, until the actual date of the service, or the service was made, and that's when I have actually met the person and been to their place of business, which she does not have for me to go to. She was incredibly rude and disrespectful to me, and took a long time to respond to emails, even when we were planning originally. I just find her business practices shady and odd, and her customer service horrible. read more