I went in to see what Halloween stuff they are putting out this year and was not disappointed…read more While they still have a lot more to come, according to a clerk, they had lots of great creepy stuff already. The store is clean and the employees were all very friendly. It seems to be a smaller location, so I'm curious how their selection is on every day party supplies.

Wow,, no employees Seriously on 3…read moreSuper slow check out over an hour, We won't come back Amazon is easier

Fantastic variety, well organized for finding items quickly. Reasonable prices. Most important of…read moreall, friendly, HELPFUL, courteous staff.

Cash & Carry Paper is one of Indy's true indie gems. Located by the railroad tracks right as you…read moreleave downtown Indy on East New York Street, Cash & Carry Paper has been around and within the Corsaro/Moss family since they first bought it in 1962. It has been in various locations including 32 years at 602 East Washington Street. Cash & Carry Paper has a 33,000-square foot warehouse and a 4,000-square foot showroom. They are local, do not ship, and do deliver within the Indy area. You can also browse online. I drive by Cash & Carry nearly every day since I take East New York Street on my way home. I was immediately intrigued because they have a huge and very nicely ramp done at their front door (I'd imagine it's as much about carrying supplies, but for a wheelchair user it's also pretty great). If it's paper, there's a pretty good chance that Cash & Carry Paper carries it and there's a pretty good chance their pricing is going to meet or beat mosf the places that you'll think of to get things like cutlery, napkins, plastic ware, decorations, bowls, office supplies, and a myriad of other things. Seasonal items are plentiful here and this place offers great prices for wedding needs (Okay, I've actually heard this. I'm old. I'm tired. I'm perpetually single.). Employees are always friendly here - in fact, it was because a friend was dating someone from here that I finally visited Cash & Carry and came to regard it as a "go to" option for paper goods. While the hours don't always work best for me (7am-5p, M-F), it's worth the extra effort because I'm truly supporting local while also getting great customer service and prices. While the neighborhood is a mixture of up-and-coming and economically challenged, I've never had any issues here and Cash & Carry is in a good location being next to the railroad tracks. If you're doing special events, have a wedding, have a gathering, or whatever, there's simply no place else I would check first. While they focus on paper, like nearly any other paper company they offer a wide range of similarly-themed products including janitorial supplies. Honestly, rather than trying to list all the supplies - go to their website and check it out for yourself. Truly, Cash & Carry is an Indy gem and one of the best options I've found for paper goods in this area. I'll easily check here first before ever heading over to one of the chain options.

My son and I love this place! I'm excited that the Halloween selection continues to expand every…read moreyear. I like to take my son in frequently for small fireworks, so that the fun lasts throughout the spring and summer. The owners are great with recommendations and often ask for feedback to make sure that we are enjoying what we pick up from the previous visits.

We had a great and fun time painting our pieces. I wish we arrived earlier to have more time to…read morereally finish what we wanted. Prices aren't all that bad, but being towards the end of the day, a lot of the handwriting paint bottles were empty which made us scramble and get creative with the brushes. Large selection and helpful staff.

This place was fantastic! I was in town visiting family for a few weeks and wanted to take my 3…read moreyear niece to a painting pottery class. We found this place on yelp and walked in on a Friday afternoon. It's so cute and quaint and reasonably priced!

We recently discovered this cute little gift shop and it's such a charming spot! They carry a…read morevariety of unique items that make for great gift ideas--it was honestly tempting not to walk out with the entire store. Everything is very well-organized and thoughtfully laid out, which makes shopping easy and enjoyable. On the flip side, the staff could be a bit more attentive. When we walked in, we weren't greeted, and the employees continued their conversation instead of checking if we needed assistance. Even as we browsed, no one offered help. That said, my son loved the selection and ended up picking out a wooden vehicle as a keepsake, which made the visit special. The prices are fair for a privately-owned shop, though you may find some of the same items online for less. Still for the experience and the unique finds it's definitely worth a visit.

I love coming in here. I always find something I "need" or a gift. They have a great selection…read moreof items. Staff has always been friendly when I go in.

This is a kid and/or adult's dream--regardless of what you're looking for. They have a bit of…read moreeverything for the kid who wants to play or find some unusual toys for their ever-expanding collection, or an adult who wants to revel in some nostalgia. In addition, the staff are kind, helpful, and knowledgeable about their various products. Finally, if you are looking to sell or trade some items, they are fair and considerate when reviewing your items. Every city needs a "Toy Pit."

As an Elder Millennial raising little 90's wannabees, this shop has quickly become a family…read morefavorite. Everyone working there is really friendly and helpful. There's always been at least one employee that will geek out with us about our favorite characters. I recently purchased a Coraline doll for my youngest from The Toy Pit, and she was so thrilled. She's carried her everywhere for the last week. Their Barbie collection is pretty impressive. You can also find Labubu and My Little Ponies from the 80's. There's always something new to check out.

If you haven't stepped into Gaskin's Fantastic Finds yet, you are missing out on one of the…read moreabsolute best shopping experiences in the Cumberland area. What is Gaskin's Fantastic Finds? This isn't your average retail shop; it is a meticulously curated boutique and treasure trove that makes Amazon wonder who their competition is and how they operate such a tiny location. The store features an incredible mix of: * Home Decor & Curiosities: Items that add real character and a story to any room. * Seasonal Specialties: They always seem to have the perfect, high-quality gift for any occasion. * Homegoods: Everything from diapers to paper plates to clothing and shoes to games. You name it, you can probably find it here! The layout is organized yet full of surprises, making it the kind of place where you go in looking for one thing and leave with three dozen items you didn't know you needed but now can't live without. The Heart of the Shop: The Owner - Danielle What truly elevates this store from "great" to "essential" is the owner. It's rare to find someone so genuinely passionate and knowledgeable about every single customer who enters her store. Danielle treats every customer like a guest in their own home. Whether you are a frazzled mom looking for that one size of diaper or a casual browser perusing the shelves, she takes the time to share the daily gossip with you and offer honest, thoughtful recommendations of what to purchase next. Her dedication to the community and her "eye" for quality is exactly why this shop stands out. Bottom line: Support this local gem. You'll come for the "finds," but you'll keep coming back because of the wonderful atmosphere Danielle has created. And don't forget the paper towels and toilet paper!

Mostly, I wanted to visit Gaskin Fantastic Finds because of the fantastic use of assonance and…read morealliteration in the business name (GAS-kin FAN-TA-stic Finds). The name has been ringing around in my head on repeat since I heard about this Cumberland shop a few weeks ago. I'm one of those people who cannot have decorative things in their home that have words on them, because I will repeat the words or phrases in my head over and over whenever I see them. So, no Live-Laugh-Love or Bless This Mess signs for me. However, if you're a word-sign person, you will definitely find things like that here. You will also find things like toys, rugs, stationery, fancy snacks, ottomans, laundry detergent, wallets, makeup, holiday decor and lots more. This place is like if Home Goods, Ollie's and Dollar Tree had a three-way tryst that produced a child. That child would be named Gaskin. This is the kind of store where you don't visit to find a specific thing, because they might have it, and they might not. No, you need to go in with a pure heart and an open mind. It's best to just browse and be surprised. Oh! I didn't know I needed this stackable pantry shelf. Oh! What a good price on L'Oreal Elvive Hydrating Shampoo. Oh! My kids would really appreciate these Squishmallows for Christmas. This is a good place to find little trinkets and random gifts if you're indecisive and OK with letting the universe guide you to a gift. The prices are just OK; definitely less than retail, though, so you are saving money here if you find just the thing you want.

There's a new place to game in town! Greenwood is building and growing and changing! One of the…read morethe changes is this great little Toy and Gaming store - Faraday Toys! Faraday has only been open a couple of months but I think it's gonna fill a little niche. The owners are friendly, helpful, and knowledgeable. The store has a Huge selection of toys and action figures from every imaginable show. From Star Wars to Star Trek from He-Man to ohhhhhsooomanyothers.... They have a wide selection of new boxed action figures to collectibles. Divided into a front store and a back gaming room it's very spacious. They are also offering a movie night. Pretty cool space - check it out!

I can't recommend this place enough! The owner is super friendly and helpful, and he's got an…read moreintricate knowledge of both his products and customer interests. I was looking for a specific figure that I couldn't find on the shelves and, when I asked if they had anything similar, Matthew found the EXACT figure I was looking for in the merchandise he hadn't put out on the shelves yet. Above and beyond customer service, and I absolutely love the concept of the store overall. For lack of better words, just being in there made me feel like a kid in a toy store!