Cancel

    Open app

    Search

    Orcas Island Catering

    3.0 (4 reviews)
    Open 6:00 am - 10:00 pm

    Get pricing & availability

    You can now request a quote from this business directly from Yelp

    Services - Orcas Island Catering

    Orcas Island Catering Photos

    You might also consider

    Recommended Reviews - Orcas Island Catering

    Your trust is our priority, so businesses can't pay to alter or remove their reviews. Learn more about reviews.
    Yelp app icon
    Browse more easily on the app
    Review Feed Illustration

    2 years ago

    Helpful 1
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 1

    1 year ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0
    Photo of J. R.
    102
    64
    1

    3 years ago

    Helpful 1
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    3 years ago

    Orcas Island Catering did the food for a friend's wedding. Everything was tasty and the bartenders were sweet. Highly recommended!

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    Ask the Community - Orcas Island Catering

    Verify this business for free

    Get access to customer & competitor insights.

    Verify this business

    Asher & Olive

    Asher & Olive

    (18 reviews)

    Gavin and team were wonderful. We had a small ~30 person wedding and wanted a low-key dinner. Gavin…read moreand team showed up the day before, set everything up and were good to go at the time of the event. Appetizers came out right on time throughout the day and Gavin really kept his promise that "it would be like we were never there". Food came, the self-serve buffet we ordered came and then it was cleaned up and they were gone at the perfect time. We actually didn't notice! The next day they picked everything up they had brought and left zero mess. They were also super friendly the entire time. We had beef, salmon, salad, bread etc. and it was cooked super well and was delicious! Especially the beef. We appreciate how in touch they were with our timing. I was a bit nervous when they said they would stick to our timeline but keep an eye on the vibes of when food should be ready and they really delivered. Gavin was also incredibly available leading up to our event and just nice to chat to overall.

    Destination weddings are always difficult to plan and my daughter did most of the planning without…read moremy input. Had I been involved, I would have looked at the reviews and moved on. We can only parrot all the negative reviews on here. Gavin promised so much that never came to fruition, including a Mezcal wall that could only be described as serving bitter liquid that most people took one sip and put down. The food was ordinary and there was NO water. We had discussed the water situation prior to the event because Gavin deemed the water "undrinkable". After discussing the water purity with the owner of the venue, I was told the water is perfectly fine. I sent a message to Gavin explaining we would use the water on site. The problem arose that the catering staff only filled the water glasses 1/2 full and only brought ONE PITCHER to the event. EIGHTY people and only ONE PITCHER! People were asking for water all night and one person (not even the staff cause they all went home) was running into the venue (it was outdoors) filling ONE pitcher at a time of water and trying to accommodate 80 thirsty people. Additionally Gavin told me to purchase double the wine and beer needed for a party of 80 and NO ONE brought up the fact that not only was there no water, but no non-alcohol beverages. I would have gladly purchased the additional beverages had someone noted that there would be no other beverages such as lemonade or iced tea provided within the hefty $100/person price. I would note that as a caterer that should have been in the beverage discussion. Seeing as my daughter had not thrown any events to this magnitude, she was unaware to ask. So we had 80 people, only 3/4 drinking alcohol with awful cocktails, no water and no non alcoholic beverages. Two of the guests became dehydrated and got ill. Do NOT under use Asher and Olive under any circumstances. He is beyond expensive, the food is mediocre at best and his attention to detail is pitiful.

    Terra Tovela Catering - Smoked Salmon Crostini

    Terra Tovela Catering

    (11 reviews)

    Terra Tovela Catering was absolutely phenomenal. They catered my Winter Solstice birthday dinner,…read moreand we chose a buffet-style setup -- and it exceeded every expectation. The buffet was beautifully arranged, abundant, and incredibly thoughtful. Every dish was bursting with flavor, perfectly cooked, and clearly made with care and intention. Guests went back for seconds (and thirds), and people were talking about the food long after the night ended. What really stood out was how elevated and seamless the experience felt, even with a buffet. Nothing felt rushed or chaotic -- everything flowed effortlessly, and the presentation was just as stunning as a plated dinner would have been. The Terra Tovela team was professional, warm, and attentive, allowing me to fully relax and enjoy my birthday celebration. They truly understood the vibe of a Winter Solstice gathering and brought it to life through food and service. If you're considering buffet or plated catering and want something that feels intentional, soulful, and unforgettable, Terra Tovela is it. I would book them again in a heartbeat.

    Heaven the owner of Terra Tovela is super responsive. She helped with my event of 100 people for…read moremy mom's memorial. It was very difficult for me as there was issues with the siblings and organizing. Heaven was there to manage and help in a wonderful way. She also organized the tables, chairs and linens. She sent me a beautiful map of where everything would be placed. The food was to die for and all super fresh. The presentation was wonderful and her people were wonderful. We are so happy!!

    McFarland Catering

    McFarland Catering

    (4 reviews)

    The food was absolutely delicious!!! Such a nice variety and so fresh!!! The service was above and…read morebeyond!! When are ferry got delayed on San Juan Island, Jessica hand delivered our 16 Graze boxes to our hotel at 10:30 PM. Yes, that's correct, hand delivered at 10:30 at night AND made sure the hotel put each box in the fridge in every room so they were there when we got back!! I highly recommend!!!

    On behalf of the PTSA of an Elementary School in Bellevue, I am very disappointed by the quality…read moreand service of this catering service. Judging from their website and initial responses, we selected them out of 6 other caterers for our annual Teacher Appreciation Lunch. It is a much anticipated celebration for all the hard work and dedication by our teachers & staff. We wanted to provided them with higher quality of food than store bought deli. We raised $2300 thru a lot of effort throughout the year to make this happen. This is what we paid McFarland plus a $120 gratuity. To our dismay, the food they provided are nothing like the pictures on their website but looks & taste alot like platters from Costco. We had to scramble at the last minute to make up for the inadequate menus & lack of quality & variety of their catering service. When we reached out to them, no one responded. Hopefully, you will not have the same experience as our 100 teachers & staff had for their well deserved luncheon that turned out to be a cheap quality and very overpriced catering event. Please feel free to contact me for more information.

    Orcas Island Catering - catering - Updated May 2026

    Loading...
    Loading...
    Loading...