Stopped here late on a recent Thursday night. The place wasn't at all busy and that's probably for the best because the lone guy working here that night to take the orders, cook the pizzas and charge customers was either very new, slow or stoned. He appeared to have difficulty working the point of sale machine, and when customers came in and placed an order, he seemed to need time to process what they'd told him before he (slowly) went into action. We each had a pizza slice and a beer. Both were good, but we had to wipe down our own table from the last customers who'd sat there. Total bill before gratuity came to just under $25 for 2 slices and 2 beers. read more

BUYER BEWARE! It's a pizza joint... only open late night on the drive...catering to drunk people. Quality??? I say- negative. Over priced because intoxicated people will pay whatever to eat. Trash pizza and but nice service. read more

over priced and poorly staffed on Fri night. maybe mad that they worked? should be nicer to gays if you're going to work here. 19 bucks for 3 slices. Cold slices read more

Nick's Pizzarelli - Pizza Near Me - Wilton Manors, Florida

Possibly the worst pizza I've ever had in my life. This place used to be Humpys and had decent if not, outstanding pizza. I went to grab a slice last night. I should've trusted the hesitant feeling I had when I looked at more than a dozen pizzas With slick, shiny congealed cheese surfaces, all waiting for customers like me to ask for them, after which they handed over after a quick two minute run into an oven. I took my slice on the paper plate took one bite spit that out and left. It was terrible. It smelled bad. The place is filthy. I had to wipe my table off and would've had to wipe any of the others that were available. And it's objectively overpriced. There's a much better place down the street that serves slices for four dollars. These were eight or nine because my bill was over 11 counting a bottle of water. I will not go back. read more

Ok so wrote a 1 star review awhile back and said I would never go back. Well, they said they hired new cooks so I gave in and tried them again. Well I should t have. They put a bad taste in pizza. This place only survives as it's the only thing open other than New York grilled cheese when we get out of the clubs. Only someone intoxicated can swallow suck dried up cardboard. The crust was so thin like paper thin. Barely any sauce , any cheese or topping. Not to mention they charge you $5.72 a slice with an upgrade for having cheese on the pizza for .26 cents per slice. We couldn't even eat it threw it away. They really need to give up. Just horrible I've included a picture of the pepperoni pizza and received for up charge. Ambiance is cafeteria like. Has a bunch of lockers that takes up half the place for no use or reason. Just gross read more

Nick's Pizzarelli - The WORST pizza in history - Pizza Near Me - Wilton Manors, Florida

See all

This place is a complete joke. They advertise salads and hotdogs and pasta right on the window, but they don't offer any of them. There's not even have any tables inside right now. I've never seen such a low effort operation that could be so much better with barely any more effort. I have to wonder what kind of fool owns this place. It would be so easy to do a lot better. Stay away if you can. read more

Cold pizza. Dirty. Filthy. Gross. My first experience will be the last. This place was gross. read more

The pizza has changed and it's super expensive!! For a mediocre slice it's $6.40! That's insane.... And I always give a dollar tip so for a terrible slice I am out almost 8 bucks. read more

Hours listed on Yelp says they open at 11:30am However the hours marked on their door say they open at 4:30pm So much for getting a slice for lunch... read more

I read a lot of the reviews on Nicks before going in for a couple slices. You have a lot of 4 and 5 stars and then a lot of 1 and 2 stars. I think the overall rating (3stars) it has is accurate. I don't think Nicks is off putting but i don't think there is anything that stands out about their slices. They are as one helper said "your standard reheat and eat" place. If you aren't going to Nicks or already in the shopping plaza you have no idea its there. It's tucked away in the back corner of the plaza. Somebody told me it's a new pizza place that took the place of an old pizza place but i never tried the old place. We walked in and we were the only two in there so we were greeted instantly and he told us about the lunch special (2 slices and a soda for $6.95) and also told us the Chicago Dogs were currently off the menu. Bummer for me who wanted to try one but i was ok just getting a couple slices. The slices were thrown back in the oven to reheat and in a couple minutes we each had two slices in front of us. I started with the cheese and it tasted like your typical cheese slice. Sauce was alright, cheese blend was good and it had a good texture. The problem was nothing was special about this slice. With some many slice places in the area, this one did not stand out. The pepperoni slice for me was a little better but only because the pepperoni added some flavor. The crust was a little doughy and chewy. Overall, if you're in the plaza it's not a bad place for a slice but I'd rather drive an extra 2 minutes and get a couple slices that i know are better. read more

See all

On New Year's Eve went to get slice of pizza for my spouse and store employee for no reason called the police. Was forced to leave by police. Don't patronize this establishment. This is unacceptable. read more

The quality went way up the last couple times I went. But so did the prices. However I recently heard the nice older lady making the pizzas the past couple years isn't there anymore. Hopefully they keep the quality up. read more

Last year, in 2023, I visited Nick's Pizzarelli when visiting Wilton Manors with friends. I had a bad experience with the pizza in 2023 when I was visiting the area, and I sent Nick's Pizza note via Facebook Messenger to explain the situation. I received a very polite reply at the time that said next time you're in the area which would be in 2024 that I should stop in and get two complimentary pieces of pizza for my troubles in 2023. When I went to the restaurant recently in 2024, I spoke to the staff member on duty and she asked me to contact the owner. I contacted him again through Facebook Messenger and by telephone call. When he called back, he was very rude and said he would call the police if I did not leave his restaurant immediately. I did nothing to provoke this response. I was simply following up on the polite Facebook Messenger message I received from last year. The response from Nick's Pizza was total about face from the polite and courteous response I received via Facebook Messenger in 2023. While I would have given them credit for making reasonable attempts last year to make me a satisfied customer, they totally failed me this year. Why a pizza owner would threaten me that he would call the police for my doing nothing is poor customer service. I cannot recommend Nick's Pizza, especially for how it treated this customer and they did not resolve my problem from the previous year. I am a very disappointed customer. read more

OK guys their pizza is amazing a Wilton manors institution. What a great guy Nick is. The absolute best if you go in to get the single pizza make sure you ask them to leave it in the oven extra long so it's crispy but amazing pizza people. A must when you're in Wilton Station or Fort Lauderdale Don't order from a chain order from Nick's! read more

Nick's Pizzarelli - The absolute best pepperoni ask them to cook it extra long so it's nice and crispy Support local business order from Nick's! - Pizza Near Me - Wilton Manors, Florida

See all

Five dollars for a cheese slice is stupid. Asked for ranch dressing and it was gunna be another two bucks on my slices. Get outta here. read more

After a most recent visit (I have eaten there in the past) I noticed a few things that customers need to be aware of at Nick's; 1) There's no menu board displaying food items AND without seeing such pricing is on their items,they can charge whatever,I think is a violation in itself!! 2) When I've ordered the same slice and was charged $1.75 more because it was a busy Saturday night,what I believe is 'surge pricing' every customer needs to be aware of this practice! As a consumer,I always loathe asking what the cost is of said product before ordering!! 3) Can't remember ANY quick serve restaurant doing this!! read more

First of all, I can't compare to Humpys as I haven't had their pizza in years. Nick's will have to stand on its own. I've been to Nick's 2 times for a pizza slice. Nick's is really a pizza-by-the-slice place. Pizza and late drinking nights seem to go together, so it's in the right spot! All the staff I've encountered were friendly and accommodating. Both times there was a good variety of pizzas, and if there weren't any mushrooms on them (my main requirement), they were glad to toss them on and stick it in the pizza oven. The pizza slices were good, especially one with shrimp and I think basil (and my mushrooms). Crusts were just as I like, not too thick or thin. I prefer my pizza hot, and both times they were not re-heated in the oven long enough (especially with raw mushrooms tossed on). I'll be back, and next time I'll mention to warm it up longer. I don't mind waiting. read more

Nick's Pizzarelli - Pepperoni & Mushroom - Pizza Near Me - Wilton Manors, Florida

See all

Treated like trash tonight. Not busy for some reason but won't be back. I've lived here for 10 years. Will never recommend. Great pizza down the street. read more

Nick's Pizzarelli is a brand new pizza place that serves diners into the late hours of the night. Located in the same plaza as Tee Jay Thai restaurant, Hunters nightclub, and Georgie's Alibi Monkey Bar, Nick's serves a wide array of comfort food like pizza, hoagies, hot dogs, and desserts. My friend invited me to try Nick's for our Thursday cheat meal. The parking lot is kind of small for the vast array of businesses in the plaza, but there is also street parking and a parking lot around the corner. The business is located next to We Financial, and is well-lit and clean inside. They have booths and tables inside the restaurant, as well as covered tables outside on the patio. They offer huge 16" pizza pies, either from a set menu or you can customize your own. You can also choose giant single slices for very affordable prices (from $3.50 - $4.50). You get a lot of food for your money, and they do NOT skimp on the toppings or cheese. The crust is thin and crunchy, baked right at the counter. You can watch them toss the dough and make the pizza from your table. My friend and I shared three slices of the: -Mac & Cheese: mozzarella cheese sauce, elbow macaroni, and cheddar cheese. This pizza doesn't skimp on the cheese! The macaroni is cooked soft, and when you bite into it, the cheese pulls like just in a commercial. I loved this slice and it brought the little kid out in me. - Shrimp Scampi: mozzarella cheese, garlic butter, olive oil, basil, and shrimp. This pizza is like an Italian dish in a slice. The shrimp is HUGE and they put a lot on the pizza. Really unique creation that I've never seen anywhere else. - Chicken Bacon Ranch: mozzarella cheese, chicken, bacon green onions, and ranch dressing. This is a filling and delicious pizza. They have lots of toppings, and dressing... It's a very filling slice of yummy flavors. Nick's also has appetizers like a pepperoni-rose bread roll, which is a roll with slices of pepperoni that look like flower pedals and held together with cheese. My description does nothing to attest to the cute creation it is. I also ordered garlic knots, which come in a set of 4 and are smothered in garlic, olive oil, and Parmesan cheese. We also tried a Chicago-style hot dog, which brought me right back to my hometown. You have a fresh, thick Vienna pure beef sausage, topped with relish, onions, pickled tomatoes, hot peppers, celery salt, and mustard (no ketchup!) in a poppy seed bun. An absolute MUST TRY are their desserts! Most are made in-house, by the owner's mother, such as the tiramisu, the rainbow cupcake, and the divine coconut cake. The tiramisu is AMAZING! Lots of cream and the lady fingers are soaked to perfection. It's my favorite Italian dessert, and it is delicious here. The rainbow cupcake is also yummy, and so cute to look at. The frosting isn't overly sweet but the dessert hits the spot. We also tried the Chocolate Milky Way cupcake, which is a chocolate cupcake with caramel drizzle. There is a surprise of a cream filling when you get to the center, which added an extra bite of sweetness to the dessert. I loved everything... just pick a dessert with a flavor that interests you, and you will NOT be disappointed. They offer a wide array of beverages, from fountain drinks, to beer and wine, and coffee and espresso to end your night. The restaurant is well-lit, and clean inside. The employees are all very friendly, and each one asked if we needed anything throughout our dining time. They are fast to serve and fast to clean, but most importantly, you could tell that everyone wanted you to have a great dining experience. They are open until 11 pm on weekdays, 2:30 am on weekends, and midnight on Sunday, so it's a great option for late night food and a better alternative to fast food. I had a great time at Nick's Pizzarelli, and I will definitely be back for another cheat day meal! read more

See all

It was a sad day goodbye along The Drive when Humpys Pizza & Cupcakes closed its doors in Shoppes of Wilton Manors. I used to really enjoy having a slice of their pizza along with a bowl of their special gazpacho. So I'm more than thrilled to give a big welcome Nick's Pizzarelli which has taken over the old Humpys location in the Shoppes. Better yet, except for the delicious Humpys gazpacho, Nick's not only offers everything Humpys did but more and, from what I've tasted so far, better. And to beat that, Nick's has a better wider range of menu offerings with my particular delight being 100% Vienna Hot Dogs done Chicago Style, which is to say with mustard (no ketchup...use of ketchup is a culinary felony in Chicago), onions, pickles, tomatoes hot peppers, celery salt and the ever so special neon relish in a steamed poppy seed bun. Another thing I really like about Nick's is that they offer a larger choice of toppings with pepperoni, ham, meatball mushrooms sausage, bacon, caramelized onion, pineapple, tomato, sundried tomato, garlic, basil, Kalamata olives, mozzarella, cheddar, provolone, ricotta, blue cheese crumples, shrimp and, as if it were a special for my particular palette, anchovies! Hooray! I no longer need to carry my own can with me. Besides Nicks "extra big by the slice," it also offers gourmet 16 inchers, 8 inch Stromboli, salads, hoagies, wine by the glass or bottle, beer, varying desserts, starters and soft drinks. On my visit I had a slice of what I was merely told was Nick's Special which I had selected from their slice offerings as it looked so delicious and, to my delight, also proved itself to taste every bit as delicious as it looked. Of course I can't help but draw a comparison with those of what was Humpys, and though by comparison close, I'd have to say I found Nick's to be the better in every aspect. But the one thing that is very much the same as Humpys was is the friendliness of the counter staff; not just friendly but super nice friendly, helpful, courteous and polite. read more

See all

Been coming here a long time but last visit got a skimpy slice of just plain cheese and a fountain drink and it cost almost $9 so I think I'm done read more

Angelica is my go to when it comes to ordering! If it's not her I DO NOT want her. I love her than going out and anything else! she is a queen! read more

The pizza was awful-husband and I went last night-4 slices two with sausage and two chesse-no drinks $24.00-paper thin-crust undercooked-sauce was awful-last time -we didn't feel like walking down to Pizza and Gelato 100% better then Nicky's read more

Someone had a bit of an attitude tonight but none the less the pizza here is phenomenal, and so are their cupcakes. I've tried the supreme, meat lovers, pepperoni and BBQ chicken and I love them all. Cozy spot tucked in between two major bight read more

Best pizza in Fort Lauderdale!! I was told it is open Tuesday through Sunday starting at 4pm. read more

Should have prices posted or menus. Sorry but I will not order food without at least an idea... and your staff saying whatever price they want to charge seems more like a ripoff. I went in at 6:45pm on a Saturday evening, and they had a variety of 6 cooked pizzas on display, 2 of each and not a single slice was missing from any one of the pizzas. So do they sell by the slice, or did they sit there for over 2 hours. read more

For 2 slices of bad pizza and 2 bottles of water $17.50....RIPPP OFF. Pizza not even fresh...WAY OVER PRICED. They lost my business.

What a joke! Went there at 11:00 on a Sunday.(open till 12). They would only sell slices!!!! There is no reputable pizza on Earth NYC , Ft Lauderdale, Wilton Manorial, Chicago, Rome, Naples that won't sell you a whole pizza an hour before closing time. If you want an overpriced, automaton, no soul, f the customer slice, you are in luck. Might as well be a vending machine. I never thought I would write these words, but 7/11 is a better choice. Dolce Salato within walking distance, is by far a better place. Fantastic, superior., REAL pizza. Not plastic vending machine pizza, Actually care about their customers. read more

Idc how late it is how hungry you are , paying over $4 for a stale disgusting slice of pizza isn't worth it . You're better off making ramen or just falling asleep hungry . read more

This place is where Humpy's used to be, and while it's not fair to judge them based on who was there before, since the place doesn't really look any different, I think it's fair. The pizza at Humpy's was great. This place, not so much. To begin with, the pizza has a good flavor but not much sauce, cheese or toppings. And for the price they charge per slice, I think I deserve better. The crust isn't my favorite, but I'm okay with it. I prefer a thicker crust but it's hard to find in south Florida. So I don't penalize them for that. But spreading the sauce so thin you can see the crust beneath, not acceptable. I understand why they have to charge so much for fountain drinks; rent in this plaza cannot be cheap. The parking lot is pretty much always a challenge finding a spot. So they have to make enough money to turn a profit. I get that. But if you're going to keep everything that Humpy's had (including the case of cupcakes), why did you get rid of birch beer? There are very few places here that carry it, and that was one of the things that made Humpy's so endearing for me. Now, Nick's is just another mediocre pizza parlor. They'll make money from the people at the bars, but if you want good pizza, keep looking. This isn't the place. read more

This pizza joint is the best. Thin, crispy, chewy crust. Delicious toppings. We always go for the white pie slices... chicken bacon ranch is my favorite. But haven't had a bad slice ever and it's been 3 years! A must go for pizza in WM. read more

Nick's Pizzarelli - Caramelized mushroom and onion pizza, buffalo chicken pizza, and chicken/bacon/ranch pizza. - Pizza Near Me - Wilton Manors, Florida

Amazing pizza! They served us quickly and the food was delicious. I recommend the special and pepperoni

The pizza was good. Not as good as humpies but I paid 17 bucks for four slices and don't provide water which I'm sure is illegal. I had to buy it. They had no Anchovies. The staff was zombie like when questioned about both these issues. read more

Looked like a New York City "Slice Shop" so we gave it a try. No prices posted...no menu, so they charge you whatever they feel like...for us it came to nearly $5.00 per slice, whether plain or with (sparse and uninteresting) toppings. Cold dry-looking pies sitting uncovered for heaven knows how long, slices popped into the oven to heat up prior to being "served." It's a good thing that I looked at my receipt before leaving. I had been charged for additional toppings (including pineapple, which I don't like) that I did not order and that did not appear on the slices. High price rip-offs are one thing, but this seems like plain old-fashioned fraud to me. Dirty, nasty place. Floors needed sweeping, sticky tabletops needed wiping, the bathroom looked like it had been bombed during the Vietnam war. The bathroom door, a single, open bathroom with an indirect view into the dining room, not only did not lock...IT HAD NO LOCK AND THE KNOB HAD BEEN BROKEN OFF apparently a long time ago! And don't get me started on the smell, which seeped out into the dining area! The person who took my money with bare hands also handled my food with those same bare hands without so much as a rinse, let alone a wash. AND OF COURSE, PANDEMIC OR NO PANDEMIC, NO MASK. I would not go back if it were free. Do yourself a favor and stay away! read more

This is my first and last time here. The fountain drinks taste terrible. They are selling the cheapest off brand. All three slices of pizza tasted like mush when you bit into them. If the pizza place just up the street was open I could have saved myself from this experience. You have a business in Wilton Manors. Hello! The guys behind the counter were very friendly and nice. read more

Chicken bacon ranch is the best I've had anywhere in the county, and I do cross country trips yearly.

Abe was Great at heating My slice up Mitch there is Also very Handsome I sang the National Anthem for them ... Memorial day God Bless America and Nicks Pizza read more

The pizza here is great but the problem is that the store hours are not all accurate. It's not even close to opening at the listed hours. Perhaps they can't get enough help but, at the least, they should change their hours to accurately reflect when they will be open. read more

Amazzziiiinngg!!!!!! You must try!!! The Best Pizza Ever!!!! I live in Miami by expediently went there to get a slice of pizza when i bite in the first time i got addicted ! Me and my friend we use to go there after clubing, Nick always welcome and super nice to us, My favorite is the cheese what have the thin dough and crispy base.Sometimes i'm driving up from Miami to Wilton manor to get a slice of pizza and bringing always new friends over and share my experience . read more

Great food and always kind ! Considering the location between 2 bars and the often drunk clientele. Abraham does a great job even GOD would endorse ! # patience of Jobe Don't let the flour covered mask full ya ! read more