I like Newington a lot.
Not coming from Edinburgh but having a bit of a connection with the place (half the people I know used to stay there, including my aunt who lived in Morningside for years), it makes me a strange judge when it comes to areas. I felt well acquainted with Morningside since it's my aunt's first love, and she's been telling me about it since I was three and read Maisie books. I have friends who stay in Leith, Corstorphine and my ex's sister used to stay in the Grassmarket. So it's safe to say I've seen a lot of Edinburgh through my many, many visits over the years (it really is a second home these days).
It was actually only a few weeks ago that I discovered the whole of Newington. I recall having a coffee here after I did the Moonwalk a couple of years ago (the caffeine was definitely earned), and I've drifted in and out of bars at intervals over the years. But taking the time to walk around and get to know the area, I see how many merits it has. It seems generally clean, well kept and with some wee gems of businesses, even in its roughest parts. The houses around here as you head further away from the throngs of Nicholson Street seem lovely, and it looks like a fairly peaceful place to stay. There are some upmarket boutiques, a really cute wee chocolatier called Choccolate, some friendly local grocers and some great, airy coffee shops. My top picks are Trouve, the Himalayan Coffee Shop, In Dehli, Casablanca, Vogue Video and (further up the road) Armstrong's.
Generally, my experiences in Newington have been relaxed, and all shop owners were exceptionally friendly. If I ever move to Edinburgh I would try to get a flat here - even if it was higher up the price scale it would be worth it. As Gavin said, it's more authentic than a lot of the showy, tourist orientated districts in Edinbugh, and strikes a perfect balance of upmarket and down to earth. read more