1. New Nautilus Hotel

    0

    Atlantic Beach, NY

    Cancel

    Open app

    Search

    New Nautilus Hotel

    5.0 (1 review)

    New Nautilus Hotel Photos

    You might also consider

    Recommended Reviews - New Nautilus Hotel

    Your trust is our priority, so businesses can't pay to alter or remove their reviews. Learn more about reviews.
    Yelp app icon
    Browse more easily on the app
    Review Feed Illustration

    2 years ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    Ask the Community - New Nautilus Hotel

    You might also consider

    Verify this business for free

    People searched for Hotels 14,379 times last month within 15 miles of this business.

    Verify this business

    New York Beach Club - Beach

    New York Beach Club

    (19 reviews)

    One Saturday night after work I wasn't sure what I was going to do, I didn't have my son. I checked…read morewith my friend from church before going out to see if he needed media ministry help. Most of the time he isn't at the church after 5 on a Saturday but I like to check sometimes. Another friend wanted to come here to see streetfighter the rolling stones tribute band. I'm not overly crazy about the rolling stones but I'm open to checking out stuff I'm not too familiar with and getting exposed to new things. So I told my friend I'd go with her. I think they are open to the public after a certain time so if you aren't a member you can still stroll on in. Smart move on their part because they'll get extra business that way. I wasn't too much of a fan of the band playing but it was really nice to be on the beach hearing some music that part was pretty awesome. I walked down to the beach area to check it out. My friend wanted to eat and I didn't have a lot of money so we shared a pizza. She picked the toppings. Many times I'm a people pleaser. I just don't want to get into an argument and will comply with the wishes of others pretty easily if I am okay with it so I let her pick the toppings. Overall it was a nice experience being here and I would come here again especially if they had a band I like better than the rolling stones tribute band.

    My girlfriend sent me this link from a Facebook page which has 4.5 star reviews for this place…read more After the fact, looking at YELP, I found out the reviews were not so stellar. I should've looked into the reviews on all platforms before making reservations. It shows, what looks like professional Hawaiian performers on the flyer. So we decided to take her daughter as a surprise and thought it would be a great night to sit by the beach. Have dinner and watch the show. The price for a buffet dinner and the show is $59.95 for adults and $29.95 for kids 12 and under. Now I didn't mind paying the price because I thought even if the food wasn't going to be so good, at least the show would make up for it. CONS/CONS AND MORE CONS: Unfortunately this flyer was very deceiving. The show was not by any means performed by the people they advertised on the flyer. The amateur performance was definitely not what we expected. The food was worse. They had a grilling station with shrimp and pineapple chicken. The only edible thing was the shrimp and grilled pineapple. The chicken was tasteless and dry. Don't even get me started on the buffet. The pasta was inedible. How can anyone make rigatoni with red sauce taste so bad. When you're charging that price for food, it should at least be served hot. All the dishes were cold and tasted sub par. The only thing that tasted half decent was the mozzarella sticks. The food was laid out nicely in chafers, but the sternos were not being kept up with. Our waiter was quick to come to the table to take our drink order. Normally water is automatically served, but not here. 1/2 hour later he comes back with two of the non alcoholic drinks and tells me they can't make my drink from the menu. So I ask for water for the whole table and 15 minutes later, we only get one cup of water. So after the show, we didn't even bother to get dessert because of our experience with the food. We were so disappointed with the whole experience. For $59.95, I ate three pieces of shrimp (which is all they served you), one mozzarella stick and some of the macaroni salad which was not so good. But I was hungry so I had to eat something. Most of the food we put on our plates was left our plates. My girlfriend asked to speak to the manager and see if they could do something with our bill. Although they didn't charge for the child and the two non alcoholic drinks, the overall experience was not worth $142 and change. We were still going home hungry and disappointed. Definitely not worth the price. But we live and learn. I would say if you have younger children and spend the day at the beach, then go to this amateur show, it may be worth it for some people. For anyone looking for an and authentic Hawaiian style food and show, this is definitely not the place to go. The one star is for the beach view, table seating and the waiter who was very apologetic.

    Allegria Hotel - Banquet room

    Allegria Hotel

    (659 reviews)

    $$

    Location, Location, Location! As another recent review stated, staying at the Allegria is all…read moreabout the location. Right on the Boardwalk with a ramp to the beach right there. We did not stay at an Air B & B because we needed handicapped accessibility, so the hotel worked out great. I booked a handicapped, double beds, and ocean view. They gave us a corner room on the eighth floor. The View was amazing! I overheard an employee saying that the rooms were recently updated. I would NOT say that the rooms were run down, but the attention to detail in the rooms and hallways is noticeably missing, particularly for the price of stay. Couple of small examples. The toilet paper holder was drooping off the wall. Every time I went to tear a piece off, the whole roll would fall. Also they placed one of the hand rails behind the toilet. Handicapped room, so great. However, they did not place it high enough on the wall for the toilet lid and seat to clear it, which caused the seat to constantly fall. Also the paint did not exactly look like it was applied by anyone that pays attention to detail. As far as the good, beyond the location and view. The staff were super friendly. I can not say enough kind words about all the staff I encountered. They were all very friendly and attentive. The room was clean. It was also easy to find street parking during the night. A day or two after we departed they sent me a text offering 25% off if I come stay again within the next two weeks. Given that I don't live downstate, that is not likely to happen. I do have to go back to Long Island next year for a wedding in Suffolk County. Given the price, I am not sure it would be worth it to stay there and travel to the wedding. Maybe if they had offered 25% off my next stay, without an expiration date, I might have considered staying there when I go back down again for the wedding.

    We sat at a high top in the bar area on Friday night. We were never given a menu, no one showed up…read morefor 30 minutes. We saw the waitress ( unfortunately we didn't get her name) waved to her and she turned away and left. I went to the host desk and a very kind, hardworking gentleman gave us some menus. We continued to wait so I went to the bar and bought a round for the 4 of us. Finally the waitress came over and rudely said , so I see you got your own drinks. I thought she was joking and she said she would be back, I said wait it has been an hour can you take an order. She said I'll be back left and never returned. The kind host came back, took our order and we eventually got food. Unfortunately of all the items we ordered, the only thing decent was the burger. The pizza was straight out of the freezer, the bao buns dried out and the steak sandwich raw. We missed the movie on the beach. Shout out to Dennis at the bar and Karleke the host. That short waitress with attitude Friday night should be released.

    New Nautilus Hotel - hotels - Updated October 2026

    Loading...
    Loading...
    Loading...