Dr. Rosenthal is incredibly knowledgeable, kind and empathetic. As a solo practitioner, you can really see the personal attention and care he puts into his practice. I've seen him for 2 different things over the last 10 years and highly recommend him. Please don't hesitate to make an appointment--Nicole will get you all set up! read more

Provider Feedback: I saw Dr. Rosenthal in December 2025 for neurological symptoms that had me confused and worried. From the very first visit, he took my concerns seriously--even when I wasn't sure they were valid myself. He listened carefully, examined me thoroughly, and clearly cared about finding the root cause. He ordered the appropriate tests, explained everything in a way I could understand, and reassured me that we would figure things out together. Because he works with NYU Langone, I was able to get imaging scheduled very quickly. At every follow-up, he was thoughtful, thorough, and proactive, even personally helping me get an urgent neurosurgeon referral when it was necessary. Thanks to Dr. Rosenthal's diligence and compassion, I had a successful surgery and have been given a new lease on life. I truly believe that if it weren't for him taking my case seriously, I could be in a much worse situation. I feel incredibly grateful to have him as my neurologist and highly recommend him. Office Feedback: The wait time is usually 0-5 mins which is super rare for a lot of doctor's offices. They are also very responsive to voicemails and always call back if unavailable. I also enjoy the artwork on the walls. read more

Cancelled my ZocDoc appointment saying they couldn't figure things out with my insurance company (PPO), which offers extensive out of network and in network benefits. Same deal as the other reviewer. Will be seeing a different doctor and office who tries a little harder to make things work. I mean if you can't even figure out insurance, how will you figure out neurology? read more

Neil S Rosenthal, MD - Stellar email to get when you are seeking medical help and pay for a PPO that covers literally everything. - Neurologist Near Me - New York, New York

Dr. Rosenthal is a game changer for me. I went to him recently for some new issues I was deeply concerned about. He not only saw me early and took me in when I was feeling anxious and upset, but he was thorough yet swift in finding me answers. He explained what was happening every step of the way. Bonus, his office manager, Nicole was equally accommodating and equally humane and kind. I felt support from them both and because of their expertise, character, and human approach, I highly recommend this practice. This practice literally helped me during a very scary time and I won't ever forget it. read more

Dr. Rosenthal doesn't like to explain nor listen to his patients much. After few visits, I was put on a maintenance mode and was asked to see him X amount of time per year, mainly for prescription meds. My condition never improved, again just maintained to not get worse, and there was never a thorough explanation of anything. read more

I've been in treatment with Dr. Rosenthal for over 7 years. His care and knowledge are superlative, and I recommend him unreservedly. Each time I visit him I'm impressed anew by his thorough expertise, and by his optimistic kindness. Thanks to him I'm functioning optimally now, for which I'm grateful beyond words. In addition, Nicole at the front desk is absolutely wonderful: she's a great combination of friendly and efficient. read more

Dr. Rosenthal is a top quality neurologist that gave me relief from a painful nerve condition. He is kind and attentive, and is clearly highly knowledgable in his field. I would recommend him to anyone. The office experience is pleasant, and his office manager is always very welcoming. read more

Dr Neil Rosenthal is the best diagnostician I know! I went to my internist with some unusual symptoms. He suggested I see a neurologist and recommended one to me. I gave this Dr my family history and told him what I thought it might be, due to the fact that my mom had had this particular disease, and I had symptoms that could easily fit into the parameters of that disease. After several visits and performing approximately 10-12 tests on me, his conclusion was...that I did not have the disease that was in my family...the disease I had feared I might have. He sent me on my way, saying that, yes, I did have the symptoms I had come to him with, but that my problem was not neurological. He suggested that I keep looking for an answer, but gave me no guidance as to where to look or who to go to, not even the type of specialty that might be the correct one to pursue. Fast forward two months. I, by chance, happened to be at a friend's house and Dr Neil Rosenthal was there as a guest, as well. During the course of the evening, our conversation turned to the symptoms I had been concerned about. I relayed the story about the other neurologist, above. Dr Rosenthal suggested that the symptoms I had, were compatible with the disease I had feared. He said he thought I had a good chance of having the same neurological disease that my mother had. He suggested that I might follow up with a comprehensive exam in his office, as well as having a test done that the first Dr never even suggested. Soon thereafter, I made an appointment for the suggested test, to be followed up with an exam and discussion of test results with Dr Rosenthal. Unfortunately, sure enough, I did have the disease I thought I had. The first Dr didn't pick it up, despite the fact that I told him my mom had had it, and my symptoms fit well within the parameters of this disease. Dr Rosenthal was able to confirm what was wrong with me, by the specialized test he ordered, and physical exam. Within a week after my correct diagnosis by Dr Rosenthal, I was moving out of state, so unfortunately I could not continue to be his patient. My new Dr, a neurologist, specializing in this disease, confirmed Dr Rosenthal's diagnosis. I would still be his patient, but the distance makes it impractical to continue seeing him. I think he is an amazing diagnostician, and would highly recommend him to anyone / everyone who may have neurological symptoms and not know what to do or how to proceed. And, in fact, I have recommended him to those who need a Neurologist in NY. read more

Dr. Rosenthal literally saved my daughter's life. She had been feeling dizzy and had not gotten an explanation for her symptoms from her doctors. Dr. Rosenthal saw her on an emergency basis. He is a neurologist, but diagnosed her with life threatening anemia. She was admitted to the hospital for an emergency transfusion and recovered well. Dr. Rosenthal is an excellent diagnostician. He is personable and empathetic. He is the antidote to the corporate, soulless medicine that is increasingly being practiced in the USA. I can't recommend him highly enough. read more

I went to Dr Rosenthal for a matter I have had since childhood, that has recently been causing me more concern. He is super thorough, very friendly, and always has time for questions and explanations. So comforting to have him treating me here out. Thanks! read more

Neil was very knowledgeable and gave me a thorough examination..he spent almost an hour examining me and not only answered all my questions but was able to recommend a great surgeon...he has also followed up and examined post surgery..he was great read more

Really nice, really thorough doctor. Receptionist is great as well ( I honestly think they can help make or break a practice) Would go to again if I need to. Although I think it would be great if doctors can tell you the short stuff over the phone instead of having you come in for another visit, another copay, and another $150 charge to my insurance to tell you 3 sentences. Not Dr. Rosenthals fault just something wrong with the medical industry in general. read more

Dr. Rosenthal has been a remarkable doctor to me during a very awful and sudden medical problem. Under his care I received consistent and immediate attention that addressed my emergent & serious neurological issue. Thanks to him I am now well on the road to recovery and pain free. He not only helped me medically and physically but also psychologically; he gave me good answers and reassurance throughout my care.I know I can always reach out to him with questions and concerns. read more

This guy told me I had a stroke and wasn't even very supportive about it. The worst part is that a subsequent second opinion confirmed that I did not in fact have a stroke and that my MRI was nothing to worry about. What a dangerous man! He wanted me to start on statins! read more

Dr. Rosenthal saved my life! On what was routine office visit to look into neuropathy symptoms so as to get clearance for normal torn meniscus surgery on my left knee, he Detected a heart murmur! This led to the discovery of a dilated aorta in which there could be aneurysm at any time! I had no significant symptoms! My subsequent open heart surgery was a success! I feel I got new lease on life! Thank you Dr. Rosenthal for your thorough due diligence! read more

Despite listing my insurance as an accepted insurance, my ZocDoc appointment was cancelled and then I received a call claiming that they do not accept my insurance. When asking questions, it was clear that the receptionist wanted nothing to do with me. After the encounter, I reached out to my insurance to see what was going on. Turns out the receptionist falsely claimed that they are not a provider. My insurance attempted to reach out to their office in order to find out what the issue was and why I was being denied service. As a mature adult, the receptionist just ignored all calls from my insurance provider. After my insurance attempted to contact their office nearly a dozen times over the course of two days without success, I attempted to reach out to them to discuss the situation myself. It turns out they are ignoring my phone calls as well. Knowing that they are a provider, and given the fact that my referral was already approved for their services, I attempted to schedule a second appointment through ZocDoc. In the notes, I gave a detailed explanation of the situation and provided them with all of the necessary information to bill my insurance and contact them if there was a mistake (including referral reference number, provider reference #, etc.). I even offered to discuss the situation further via phone if that was necessary. The receptionist cancelled my appointment without explanation and didn't even bother to call me to further elucidate the situation. Needless to say, if you would like to be treated like a human being and know that your situation or issue matters, go elsewhere. read more

Dr. Rosenthal has been my doctor for many years. He is very thorough and explains things in a manner you can understand. I highly recommend if you are looking for a neurologist. read more

I have never been compelled to write a review like this in my entire life. But after reading the "not helpful" comments in the help section and seeing that someone else had an issue with his office assistant; I have no choice. My name is Connie Loren Walker. And I had a horrific and traumatic experience at this office. So horrible, that I left the office and didn't even have my appointment with this doctor and I was in extreme pain. My Appointment was yesterday at Wednesday August 26th @ 2:30 pm. I was driving and I got stuck in traffic. I was very close to the office. At 2:37pm I called the office to let them know I was going to be 10 minutes late, I was on 24th and 7th avenue and I was almost there. Something must of happened because we were blocked for a while. She didn't thank me for calling. Instead she started yelling at me over the phone that I was late, and that I missed my appointment and she said if I came she doesn't "know when I will be seen". As a first time patient I was shocked with her demeanor. I told her to save time, I did all the forms on line. As this was an office of Neurology. More than likely even if I was on time I would of be given a lot of paper work to fill with medical history and past medications. I wouldn't have been seen as I walked in, I know from past experience. When I got their at 3pm there was no one in the office besides me and her. No other patients. I was like you must be kidding? She then handed me a lot of forms that I already filled out via zoc doc and received confirmation via zoc doc that they had. My condition is endometriosis of the Sciatica which is rare and painful; so I made sure to fill that out via website. I even got my medical records to do so. She gave me the same forms to fill again and I tried to inform that I did it via zoc doc. She was rude. Didn't listen to me and told me "that's all that printed" and I told her it can't be, cause I spend quite a while doing it prior. I went to call zoc doc on my cell phone and she proceeded to come from around the office desk finally "I thought she was coming to help me" but instead she literally starts yelling at me while I am on the phone doing her job with zoc doc trying to send her my medical history. She pointed to a sign that said "no cell phone use" and I explained to her I was infact calling zoc doc to allow her to get my records. She refused to help me and told me to go outside with the call. Mind you, there was no one else in the waiting room, even the rep on the other end heard her and how she talked to me. So I had to go into the hallway with no air conditioning (it was in the 80's) and a massive giant steel fan that was blowing air which made it impossible to hear. After talking to the zoc doc rep who verified that I did fill out the forms and that someone indeed printed it from August 21st, she said if she would just call back they can walk her through it. When I came back into the office she wouldn't call zoc doc. She kept yelling at me that I was late and so fourth. Again. There were no other patients there. Towards the end finally I saw one other patient as I decided to leave. In front of this patient she was rude to me and was extremely nasty about me calling zoc doc to get my records. Infact, I needed her to speak to them. When someone makes an appt to see a neurologist that means that patient is in pain. Neurology is a serous practice. She should keep in mind that this is not a routine visit and offer compassion and understating. I was late. But she isn't the doctor. But yet the doctor was walking back and fourth and I am quite sure he heard her yelling as she stood by his door and yelled at me for calling zoc doc because she refused to; to access my complicated and detailed medical records. I handed back my clip board and told her I would not be seeing the doctor today, and let her know calmly that she was infact beyond rude. She was actually extremely traumatizing and she verbally assaulted me by yelling and and intimidation which was heard by the zoc doc rep on the phone was which documented by zoc doc who was on the phone with me. Since I left the office and wasted a day off from work where I came all the way from Long Island to the city, you think the doctor would reach out to me via email of phone message? He didn't. So he has to be fully aware. I am also plan on making a report to the board of medicine. I will be calling him today prior to doing so, to give his office assistant a chance to relay my feedback and speak to him. Also asking customers to write down on a paper form their entire credit card information full account number and expiration date and 3 code; is extremely dangerous and tacky. If you must keep customer cards on file for automatic billing of future appointments; this should be done electronically. Not on a handwritten form. I've never ever seen that in my life. Call the office now and see for yourself. read more

Dr Rosenthal is caring, knowledgeable, and professional, always. Attentive to his patients needs. He listens, he explains everything clearly. He has made a difference in the quality of my life. Susan W. NYC read more

This doctor does not connect to his patients as a proper neurologist should. It is a shame and a disgrace to the medical field to refer to him as a specialist when he failed to connect with me by understanding my situation. read more

Dr. Rosenthal is an excellent doctor. He and his staff are very kind and accommodating and they make you feel at ease. I went into his office for headaches right before the holidays and he went out of his way to take care of me and get me all the tests I needed even though he was leaving for vacation. He is very knowledgeable, trustworthy and kindhearted. I would highly recommend him to anyone as it is obvious that he cares deeply about his work and his patients and knows what he is doing. Dr. Rosenthal is the best! read more

After being informed of an error, I would like to state that there is a reasonable fee for cancelling an appointment with less than 24 hours notice. It's 50 not 150 dollars. I am incredibly sorry for that error in understanding. The same review applies from before. Dr. Rosenthal is a wonderful practitioner with a great sense of humor who listens well to ones concerns and assuages them, provides treatment and follows up promptly with patients for any appointment aspect from returning a missed call and giving an exam result in understandable terms. Please give him a visit if needed. I look forward to returning. read more

I have been seeing Dr. Rosenthal for as long as I remember (maybe 10 years now?), and I have recommended him to anyone who suffers with migraines. He is helpful, inquisitive, responsive (I once had an emergency on the weekend in the summer -- he called me back quickly), and he is warm. He also is v empathetic to the nonsense that goes on w/ insurers. What I really like about the office is that it is very small. It's usually just Dr R and Nicole, who runs the front end. After years of going there, it feels very close-knit, and they know my history and I don't feel like I am getting bounced around/am anonymous like how I feel at other Dr's offices, where there are tons of docs and lots of receptionists. I would recommend arriving on time to your appt, as he is always booked, and you don't want to be behind in the queue! If you arrive on time, you will get seen on time. read more

Dr. Rosenthal is one of the most thorough doctors I have ever been to. His staff is friendly and professional and I would highly recommend anyone looking for a great neurologist to go see him! read more

Like a review below says. I would give him no stars.HORRIBLE!!!! Avoid because he is slow and not as knowledgable and has the worst staff. This young lady who had an attitude and clearly acts tough behind a phone, puts you on hold twice and third time she hung up as if this is her home not an office. Worst most ghetto office ive had to deal.Not anymore and watch it they keep you debit/credit card on file which i do not trust at all.I see a charge and he has a lawsuit coming.Low life human beings. read more

If I could give this doctor no stars I would. I went to see this doctor as he was recommended by my primary care doctor and the first one I could get an appointment with. I had a constant headache for 2 1/2 weeks so thought I should see a neurologist. It is a small office and a one man show with his receptionist. He brings in specialists to do EEG, EKGs etc. I had an appoint for an EEG scheduled and was on my way, but unfortunately stuck in traffic. I got a call at 1:30 asking where I was. I explained to the receptionist that I was on my way and about 5-10 min. depending on traffic. She said, "Well your appointment is now and since you aren't here the specialist needs to leave so we can reschedule you. The next available is a month from now." I could not believe anyone would do business this way. Even restaurants in NYC give a 15 minute window! I then got charged for a "No show" fee. I showed up, but i was refused service. I also went for an MRI that was ordered and asked the technician for the CD of the scans. He said I wasn't allowed to have them as the Dr. doesn't like to give them away. That is unacceptable!!! My body = My scans. I told him i wasn't seeing that doctor anymore so I don't care what he instructed and I have every right to my medical records. HIGHLY NOT RECOMMENDED! read more

Dr. Rosenthal is my most caring and attentive doctor. His goal is to get to the source of pain, etc as quickly and efficiently as possible. I have referred many people to Dr. Rosenthal over the years, with many different symptons (from carpal tunnel to nerve damage to other serious injuries). He isn't an alarmist, but makes sure that he listens and treats everyone with efficiency and sympathy and enables them to find the correct treatment quickly. He treated a friend of mine who had mild dementia (72 year old male), and stood up for him with his son and social worker. The latter two sent him to a nursing home (for the elderly) without any stimulation or effective treatment for the dementia. Their goal was not to treat his father for his comfort, but to qualify for Medicaid quickly. read more

I scheduled an appointment with Dr. Rosenthal but his office cancelled my appointment because I didn't get them my insurance information fast enough. I received a request at 8:30a on a Monday and by 9:30a they cancelled my appointment. Anyone who works Monday through Friday knows that Monday morning can be incredibly busy and so I didn't have time to send over my insurance information in the 1 hour time limit they gave me. Extremely unprofessional and rude. read more

Agreed. Dr. Rosenthal is a wonderful neurologist. He's better than the book as my physician says. But, I did have an issue once with having my insurance company being billed twice. Was a pain for a little while but it did eventually get resolved. A good neurologist is hard to come by, and I recommend Dr. Rosenthal over any other I've seen in the area. read more

I have been a patient of Dr. Rosenthal's for almost 15 years. He is caring, smart, efficient and patient centered. He always returns calls and has seen me on short notice, even leading up to Hurricane Sandy. Nicole is great, efficient, friendly and always returns calls. read more

Dr. Rosenthal truly cares for his patients. He is thorough in his evaluations, always willing to share his insights and goes out of his way to help patients clearly understand what is going on with respect to their health. I am impressed by him and his receptionist. Highly recommended! read more

Dr. Rosenthal saved my life, after visiting 4 other highly regarded doctors he diagnosed and advised my other doctors to treat my cushings disease - very rare and hard to diagnose. As far as the comments regarding rude receptionists.. that's just crazy and silly, she is and was wonderful! Everyone is entitled to an "off day" and also - perhaps it was a temp? To say you won't see a Dr. and get the care you need because "someone' was rude to you is cutting your nose off to spite your face, Everyone I've referred to this office has been very happy with the care provided. read more

Highly recommend! I've been seeing Dr. Rosenthal for years and he is knowledgeable, considerate and professional. Nicole in the front office is always a friendly face to be greeted by, and is always accommodating whenever if I need to cancel/move appointments. read more

Dr. Rosenthal has been wonderful and has taken such good care of my father in law in addition to all of the family members involved. He is extremely knowledgeable and truly cares about his patient's best interest. His office staff have been extremely accommodating and Nicole is a pleasure to work with. I would highly recommend him. read more

I am writing a second time to again say how Dr. Rosenthal's care and expertise has quite simply saved my life. I am a Registered Nurse, yet in early May could not figure out why I was experiencing numbness in my hands and feet. My first exam with Dr. Rosenthal was a more thorough exam than I have ever received. Not just the physical tests, he asks questions, observes how I am reacting. Long story short he diagnosed an extremely rarer form of a very rare syndrome. I was admitted to the great care of Beth Israel hospital. I see Dr. Rosenthal every two weeks to monitor my progress. My progress will be slow but steady, yet every time I leave his office I am in greater spirits than when I arrived. Dr. Rosenthal also works very hard to keep his patients wait time to a minimum. I can tell you from experience that is no small task as most situations are completely out of his control. I trust Dr. Rosenthal with my life. read more

Dr. Rosenthal is wonderful! Very professional and thorough in his diagnosis and analysis. He is extremely attentive and detail oriented, as well as funny and friendly. I felt very comfortable and can highly recommend him! read more

I went to see Dr. Rosenthal for chronic headaches and I wish I had stopped seeing him after my first appointment because I do not feel like he gave me good advice nor did he seem invested in my well-being. His bedside manner could definitely use some work and of the 5 or so appointments I had with him, I often found myself staring blankly into space as he typed notes on his computer without informing me of his opinion. He did not provide me with any alternative options when I expressed concern over the amount of prescription medication he wanted me to take. When I finally decided to switch neurologists, his office would not send over the results of the EEG exam I had taken at his office to the new doctor even though I had signed an authorization release form. read more

Listens, takes notes, asks questions,explains diagnosis and treatment, and, next visit, reviews everything. Oh, and personable. I felt quite comfortable and assured I had the right doctor. Also, very little waiting time, and his staff follows up if b/t visits there are questions. Excellent choice. read more

The rub here was about insurance and payment more than the care. The office assistant refused, until the doctor instructed her, to call my insurance company to verify MRIs and tests were 100% covered. It became such a hassle I fired him and hired a different doctor. I think he felt badly by the end of things but I lost faith in him for how his office manager handled it. read more

I had developed a terrible lingering lower back pain from lifting my 3 year old grandson, and as I am his frequent caregiver, I had to find a treatment. It was determined that I needed a Neurologist and from reading so many wonderful reviews, I chose Dr. Neil Rosenthal. Dr. Rosenthal is as warm and personable a physician as I have ever met. He immediately put me at ease with his down to earth manner and sweet personality. He asked me a number of questions and then had me perform a series of physical movements to help him determine the nature of my problem and if it was more serious than muscle strain. He gave me a list of easy to do but incredibly helpful exercises to help strengthen my back, explained what I must and must not do in lifting weights and was so kind and patient when dealing with all my questions and concerns. At all times, Dr. Rosenthal was professional, knowledgable, kind and resolved that I understand the underlying cause of my problem and that I how to help myself to get better and stay better. He even called me the next day to see how I was doing with the exercises and how my back was feeling. His staff was very pleasant and helpful. I recommend this wonderful doctor completely. He is an absolutely incredible diagnostician! read more