New Year's Eve and I wanted to wear earrings that my late husband gave me. They really pinched. 3 pm and everyone closed except this store. Owen could not have been nicer. He had estate pieces and I will definitely be back. He would not charge me. read more

Loved my experience at Mendham jewelers! Bob created a beautiful diamond necklace for me out of some jewelry I inherited. I am so thrilled, and I get compliments on it every time I wear it!! read more

My first time. Will definitely be back. Thanks Bob and Kathy for the repairs and my new necklace.

The other day, I accidentally stepped on one of my favorite rings. I was rather upset because the ring had sentimental value. So, I decided to take the ring to Mendham Jewelers to see if they could fix it. I have been to Mendham Jewelers twice before for small issues (knot in my necklace, etc.) and the main jeweler, Bob, was always extremely friendly and helpful. Even though I knew the quality of the establishment, I was still worried that it would be impossible to return the ring to its perfect shape. I explained my situation to Bob and showed him a picture of how the ring originally looked. Within minutes, he was able to bend the ring back. Now, it's like the ring never even got damaged. As an added bonus, I asked Bob if he had a polishing cloth (I received one from him when I got my necklace fixed a year or two back) because it worked wonders on polishing my gold jewelry. He didn't even charge me for the polishing cloth or even the ring fix. Overall, such a great knowledgeable place and such friendly customer service! Attached to this review you can find a photo of the original shape of the ring, the squashed ring after I stepped on it, and finally, how the jeweler returned the ring to me after fixing it. read more

THE BEST! My husband and I could not have been happier with our experience at Mendham Jewelers. Bob and Cathy are SO sweet. Bob was extremely knowledgeable and great when it came to helping us choose our wedding bands. He was able to engrave a message on my husbands band, which was awesome! They were ready so fast and looked absolutely beautiful! They both were perfect and show shiny when I picked them up. I have received so many compliments on my band. I truly appreciate all your help Bob... you're the best! Thank you again Mendham Jewelers! read more

Amazing place. Bob took care of us from the start with all our questions and helped us pick out fantastic wedding bands and bridal party gifts. We trust him whole heartedly to steer us in the right direction and couldn't be happier with our jewelry selection! read more

I've had several experiences at Mendham Jewelers and been very satisfied. The staff is pleasant and knowledgeable and the jewelry is very good quality. read more

I went to Mendham Jewelers to ask if they could resize my engagement ring. The man (owner?) there was EXTREMELY rude to me. He asked where I got the ring; I replied that my fiance got it online. He had this sort of angry outburst, and then made fun of my fiance for buying it online. I hightailed out of there. Also, he does ring resizing offsite (in NYC), which is not ideal -- my ring isn't insured, so I'm not really comfortable with someone taking it to NYC for a few days. Anyway, long story short, employee/owner is very rude, and they resize rings offsite. read more

Amazing customer service! Super accommodating and the owner, Bob, will find whatever special piece you are looking for at a very reasonable, fair price. Can't say enough about the personal attention. Highly recommend! read more

Loved my experience at Mendham jewelers. Bob was very accommodating with both the engagement ring and wedding bands. He worked with me regarding price and timing and was always looking out for my best interest. I absolutely will return. The previous review could not be any further from the truth. read more

This Piece of Shit Business is so unprofessional and don't know how they even stay in business with the rotten attitude they give their long time customers. SHOCKED and appalled I was to find out, that my finance was treated with complete disrespect. He called the Mendham Jewelers in the Kings Plaza to see if that place could fix the engagement ring. After talking about the price and time it would take the owner on the phone asked where the ring was from, Once my fiance told the person it was purchased from another company , the owner said "forget it I dont deal with people who want to get jewelery at discounted prices online and expect me to fix it if I dont get their business in the first place" and then he hung up on my fiance. Little did the owner notice that my fiance's family had been a long time few generation of dedicated customers, and in turn made me a customer at one time , and to then be treated like SHIT is utterly undeniably inexcusable behavior. He will never have our business again, and we will spread the fact this business has low class ethics. That is NO WAY to treat your customers. read more