This Law Firm is by far is the best that I've ever experience they passed my expectations by far especially Jeff Pontian everything I came to him about he handled for me and I also would like to acknowledge Chloe ( forgive me I forgot her last name) bottom line if you guys need a law firm that has your back and best interest at heart this is the law firm to go with !!!!! Thank you Jeff , Chloe and McNicholas & McNicholas.... read more

I would give a zero if possible because I contacted them in 2023 and Michele Hardy said she would get back with me AND you guess three years no call back. I reached out again not realizing I contacted them before. Something told me to check my email because here voice sounded familiar and they wanted a lot of info sent to them. They did the same thing, leaving you hanging and no follow-up. So, I called left a message and let her know she did the same thing in 2023, and if they could let me know their decision. After another two weeks, which was a month in total she left a voice message stating they unfortunately would not take the case and call her if I had questions. No questions to be asked since the case was denied, duh. For anyone looking for an attorney if they don't call you back in two days move on because that's more than enough time to respond to an inquiry, and don't give all your info to them because I believe some attorneys work out a deal with your employer and get a kickback for not taking your case. Easy money for them and and a lost for you. So, I would definitely not recommend this law firm to anybody, period. Hi Michelle, I called on Tueaday to follow-up from my consultatuon and I have not received a return call. In addition, I have forward what happen when I contacted you on 8/10/23, in which I never receive a response.  Is there a reason for the no response? Regards, Youlanda read more

My experience with McNicholas & McNicholas was one of the most unprofessional and damaging legal interactions I've ever had. From the very beginning, communication was inconsistent, delayed, or completely nonexistent. Emails went unanswered, calls weren't returned, and I was left in the dark during critical phases of my case. They missed deadlines, submitted documents without my consent, and even continued acting on my case AFTER I revoked representation. They sent in rebuttals and communications to the Claims Administrator behind my back, which made me feel misrepresented and completely powerless. Despite multiple requests, they never provided my client file, never provided my signed contingency agreement, and never gave me a proper accounting of anything they were charging or holding. I repeatedly asked for basic information and was ignored or given vague, incomplete responses. Their negligence caused real harm to my life. I dealt with stress, instability, anxiety, and financial hardship because of how poorly they handled my case. Instead of support, I got confusion, pressure, and abandonment at the worst possible time. Based on my personal experience--and what I've seen happen to other clients--this firm has serious systemic issues with communication, transparency, and basic professionalism. They did not treat me with respect, did not protect my interests, and did not handle my case responsibly. This review reflects my firsthand experience and the negative impact their actions had on my life. read more

Well, they don't really get back to customers. Intake call took over a week. Then i was supposed to get a follow up call within 5 days which never happened. Just do what you say you will do, pretty basic. read more

My experience with this firm was extremely frustrating and, at times, concerning. From early on, I felt that the potential value of my case was presented in an overly optimistic and, ultimately, misleading way. The numbers and expectations that were discussed initially set a certain level of confidence, but as things progressed, it became clear that those projections were not grounded in a realistic outcome. What made this worse was the lack of clear, consistent communication around how those estimates were being calculated. I was not given a transparent breakdown of the factors that could significantly reduce the value of the case, nor was there enough effort to reset expectations once it became obvious that the initial outlook was unlikely. Instead, I was left feeling like I had been guided toward a perception of my case that didn't reflect reality. Communication overall was inconsistent. There were delays in responses, limited proactive updates, and a general sense that I had to push for clarity rather than it being provided upfront. When you're dealing with something as serious as a lawsuit, that kind of uncertainty adds unnecessary stress and undermines trust. To be clear, the firm may have experience, but my issue is with how expectations were managed and communicated. Clients rely heavily on their attorneys for honest, realistic guidance. In my case, I don't feel that standard was met. I would strongly caution anyone considering this firm to ask very direct, detailed questions about how they evaluate case value, what assumptions they are making, and how those expectations might change over time. Without that clarity, you may find yourself in a situation similar to mine--feeling misinformed and disappointed. read more

Alfredo Lorenzo should be fired he is deceiving unorganized and incompetent his excuse for his incompetence as he put it that he is a new hire Mcnicolas and Mcnicolas according their own investigation agency they hired warned me about thier incompetence to make sure they have everything in order after them asking me over and over for same paperwork that they misplaced I have the whole conversation taped and have reported to bar association read more

I'd like to thank Steven with McNicholas & McNicholas Law firm for being very helpful with the process of everything that's going on and being available to answer all questions when needed I truly appreciate you for all your help I definitely would refer anyone to this law firm they do great work and thanks again. read more

Wasn't able to connect with anyone there for a basic intake call. Then sent me a rejection email that they didn't want to represent me. What? read more

I can't express enough gratitude for the exceptional service we received from Attorney Brandon Castor during one of the most challenging times in our lives. Our family was affected by the devastating Paradise fires, and it felt like the weight of the world was on our shoulders as we tried to navigate the aftermath. From our first meeting, Brandon was not only incredibly knowledgeable but also genuinely compassionate. He took the time to listen to our story and understood the emotional toll it had taken on us. Throughout the entire process, he was always available to answer our questions and provide updates, making us feel supported every step of the way. Thanks to Brandon's expertise and dedication, he secured a settlement that will truly help us rebuild our lives. We can finally see a light at the end of the tunnel, and we owe so much of that to his hard work and determination. If you're looking for an attorney who genuinely cares about his clients and knows how to fight for what's right, I highly recommend Brandon. He is a true advocate, and we are forever grateful for everything he has done for our family. Thank you, Brandon! No puedo expresar lo suficiente mi gratitud por el servicio excepcional que recibimos del abogado Brandon Castor durante uno de los momentos más difíciles de nuestras vidas. Nuestra familia se vio afectada por los devastadores incendios de Paradise, y sentimos que el peso del mundo estaba sobre nuestros hombros mientras intentábamos superar las consecuencias. Desde nuestra primera reunión, Brandon no solo estuvo increíblemente informado, sino que también fue genuinamente compasivo. Se tomó el tiempo para escuchar nuestra historia y entendió el costo emocional que nos había causado. Durante todo el proceso, siempre estuvo disponible para responder nuestras preguntas y brindar actualizaciones, lo que nos hizo sentir apoyados en cada paso del camino. Gracias a la experiencia y la dedicación de Brandon, consiguió un acuerdo que realmente nos ayudará a reconstruir nuestras vidas. Finalmente podemos ver una luz al final del túnel, y le debemos mucho de eso a su arduo trabajo y determinación. Si está buscando un abogado que realmente se preocupe por sus clientes y sepa cómo luchar por lo que es correcto, le recomiendo encarecidamente a Brandon. Es un verdadero defensor y estaremos eternamente agradecidos por todo lo que ha hecho por nuestra familia. ¡Gracias, Brandon! read more

If you have a potential legal claim and want to consult with a law firm, don't use McNicholas and McNicholas. I spoke to Matthew McNicholas, a partner in the firm, regarding my case. I found him to be rude and inconsiderate. He failed to commit to handling my case. After weeks of being on "pins and needles," I finally received an unsigned, form letter declining representation. If you want a law firm that treats you with contempt and disrespect, contact McNicholas and McNicholas. read more

McNicholas & Mcnicholas If you had the great fortune to have found this law firm, please take a second to read my heartfelt review of Attorney Matthew McNicolas. From the very beginning, I was very impressed with his professionalism and his interest in learning about me as a client. My particular situation led me over a very difficult road of approximately seven years. During that seven years, he stayed with me the entire time. I never felt as though I was alone. He never gave up on my case and he never gave up believing in me. I know that I was not one of his most successful cases, but it's important to note that it was my most important case. Matt always treated my case that way. In the end, my reputation was restored and a settlement was reached beyond my expectations. I would like to continue saying even more praises but instead I would like to include a message from my wife wrote to send to Matt. Thank you for taking the time to read this review. Matt, On behalf of our 3 sons and myself we would like to say thank you to Doug and yourself for your hard work, believing in my husband and not giving up on him. Thank you for restoring his character and giving him his self worth back. But most of all we would like to thank you for giving back the husband and father we once had years ago before this all started. For that we will always be grateful. Sincerely, Kristy, Nick, Tyler and Trevor Thank you Matt and to all the people who work by your side during those seven years. Sincerely read more

I have dealt with both Matthew and Courtney on both sides of the table. I can say there's no one I'd rather have on my side in a fight. Courtney has assisted me personally and I can say she's more of a friend than an attorney. She's straight to the point and honest. I give the firm my highest rating. read more

When I first walked into the McNicholas & McNicholas office, I felt a little nervous looking at the large wall of verdicts and settlements, thinking that my case wasn't as important as other cases they were working on. Once I spoke with Matt, my concerns were instantly erased. He listened, was engaged and gave my case the attention that made me feel like I was his only client. I remember sitting in the office with my two small children, and at one point, a paralegal came in to entertain them while I continued to talk with Matt. Little things like this differentiate McNicholas & McNicholas. They always go above and beyond to make sure your voice is heard. Matt, Doug, Abel and David worked on my employment law case and throughout the entire litigation process, they stood up for me when it seemed like everyone was against me. Not only did McNicholas & McNicholas obtain a favorable verdict on my behalf, they restored my confidence to go back into work and hold my head up high. D.W. read more

The furthest thing from my mind was bring involved in a lawsuit. However due to circumstances beyond my control that is were I found myself. My voice wasn't being heard through the standard channels of a work place compliant system so I was referred to McNicholas and McNicholas Law Offices by a very reputable source. It was the best decision for me. Since the onset of meeting with attorneys Matt McNicholas and Abel Nair I have been afforded the opportunity to have my voice heard and to make what was once wrong right. The attorney's at McNicholas and McNicholas Law Offices treat you like an individual, not a number. They have explained every step of the process and made sure I understand the logistics, they are also there to answer my questions and calm any fears that arise. Most important is their winning track record. McNicholas and McNicholas are the best of the best. Would recommend them to my own family and friends. read more

The McNicholas & McNicholas Law Firm has treated me more like family than a client. My life and that of my family was destroyed by my employer, the LAPD. I did not know how to get my life and self respect back together. Matt, Doug, Justin and the staff were amazing and comforting and provided jokes to lift me up. One can never see or understand why unfair, bad an evil things happen to us but I see why God put Matt, Doug and Justin in my life....and it was to right an unjust wrong. Matt, Grandma Nena (my mom) prays for you and your firm every night for all the great and compassionate work that you all do. Thank you from every angle and center of my heart. Maryhelen Montoya read more

Mr Doug Winter and all of the lawyers and staff at McNicholas and McNicholas made the potentially gruesome task of recovering for my personal injury case feel smooth and easy. It was a very frustrating and trying time in my life and they put me at ease and took care of me without any inconvenience to my personal and professional life. I had every confidence that I was in the right hands with McNicholas and McNicholas, and their results proved that I was and still am. I cannot thank this talented and dedicated team enough!!:) read more

Juan Victoria and the McNicholas team deserve more than 5 Stars. Words can't describe how grateful I am to have received help from McNicolas law firm. Juan is very SHARP, calm strategic thinker with a very approachable, down to earth manner. He is so dedicated, very hard working. I could not imagine dealing with anyone else. Juan always took the time to explain and answer any questions or concerns. Matt was very involved as well, both talented attorneys with so much experience and professionalism. Thank you so much from the bottom of my heart, I am happy and stress free!! Thank You, Veronica Ramirez xoxo read more

I'd like to first thank this team of attorneys, for making my civil claim an awesome experience. Patrick McNicholas, is in my opinion one of the sharpest and most knowledgeable litigants I've ever encountered, You'd ask why? Kind, sincere, humble is this attorney, absolutely stellar in his meticulous practice of California law. His support staff of Michael Kent, and veteran attorney, Doug Winters, makes this firm among the top in the country. There success stats are remarkable, do the fact check. It was my pleasure and blessing to be represented by them. read more

Matt McNicholas is a very knowledgeable, approachable and skilled trial lawyer. If you're looking for a firm that provides great service and maximizes your return on a personal injury or employment case, McNicholas & McNicholas is a great option. read more

We like so many others never imagined being involved in a lawsuit. Essentially we had no choice because of our child's traumatic injuries. It was a very dark place to see our son suffering and to be made to feel as if he was being put on trial by big insurance. Our original lawyer steered us over to Mc&Mc. Juan Victoria was the senior lawyer assigned to our case and he is a powerhouse, undaunted and very skilled as well as being very down to earth. Matt McNicholas also was very involved and would be the trial lawyer if need be. He brings so much experience, poise and confidence. This kind of stuff is not for the weak of heart, it is a high stakes situation and you need professionals you can put your faith and trust into. It wasn't an easy process but working with these guys did give us a lot of peace of mind. Luckily the case was settled out of court and we felt the settlement was very fair and feel so happy to have it behind us!! This firm is the best of the best at what they do and we will always be grateful to them for their support, knowledge, skill, and professionalism. Thank you Juan, Matt and the rest of the staff!!! What you do for the common person is so important! read more

I am very happy with the progress on my case, and with McNicholas & McNicholas. I am especially happy with the outstanding job Abel Nair has done. Abel recently won a motion to dismiss my case , which has allowed the case to go forward to the next step. Abel is a hard working and knowledgeable attorney who does not give up. Abel was able to explain everything that was needed. I found Abel to be professional , personable and enthusiastic , and I would highly recommend him, and the firm McNicholas & McNicholas. read more

The McNicholas law firm is a highly professional and dedicated group of highly skilled and experienced attorneys that will provide uncompromising legal representation for their clients. Their dedication is to their clients in achieving the most positive outcome of their legal case as possible. read more

I have so many nice things to say about this law firm. I never thought in my life I would ever file a lawsuit against anyone. Mcnicholas Law made me feel like someone was finally on my side. They stayed in constant communication with me and basically handled everything. Often times I would call and catch myself just venting to either Matt Mcnicholas or Alyssa Schablonski. Not once did they ever shrug me off like they were busy. Towards the end when we were going to mediation, they made it easy on me. During my final mediation I witnessed Matt and his attorneys handle my case with true professionalism. At times, it seemed like they new my story better than me, (Often I would forget some details, but not Mcnicholas Law) which shows how much work they put forth into my case. It was amazing. Finally, I was awarded a $1,500,000.00 settlement. This completely went way over my expectations. I highly recommend Mcnicholas and Mcnicholas law. What a class act. Thanks Mcnicholas Law. read more