I'm not a fan. Not real good pizza. It's not awful, but it's nothing special for sure. What I do like that I order regularly is the Italian Sub. It's pretty good. If that's what you want to get, go for it. But don't get your hopes up on the rest of the menu. read more

The food was gross and gave me food poisoning there tables were also nasty and not cleaned up not coming back

Amazing got my food out in at least 5 minutes and tastes really good I definitely recommend read more

Great new manager. I can say this place has come along way from where it was 6 months ago

Don't go there if you are on your work lunch for the buffet! It won't be ready! They are rude and hadn't started any of the food for the buffet! They didn't start it till I walked in! So, I left. I was very hungry and they weren't ready! They were also very rude! read more

Served us 4 cold spaghetti's for delivery on 9/18/2021. Order #56. They told me they could replace the spaghetti's and they would have to pick up the old spaghetti's. I asked for my money back and they said they would have to pick up the old spaghetti's first. I told them I wouldn't be back read more

I gave it one star because zero stars wasn't an option. We were passing through on our way back home for a quick lunch during a 7 hr drive. The place was packed as the church crowd was in. There was no pizza!!?? We waited 15 mins and no pizza was coming out. When we asked the lady at the register, she said they just put pizza in. We told her to refund or money. No excuse not to be on top of that major detail. If you have a buffet, you may want to ensure there is food on it. read more

Mazzio's Italian Eatery - Major fail during the buffet - Italian Near Me - Pryor, Oklahoma

We ordered online at 4:10 PM. We figured we would order early to beat the rush. At 5:25, my hubby asked where the pizza was, so I tried to call. I obviously got someplace other then Pryor. They took my order I. D. number, put me on hold, came back and said that was a very long time to wait, asked me if I could be placed on hold again, another man answered, I went through the whole thing again, being very patient because I knew it wasn't his fault. He put me on a long hold, came back and said he apologized but he had been calling the local store to see where they were on the delivery. He called several times and it kept going to the fax machine. He said I could wait on the pizza and he would knock off 50%, or he could cancel the order and it would take a bit to get my money I had paid when I ordered, plus the $5.00 tip. We chose to cancel. He was very sweet. It wasn't his fault. I looked at my account to see if they had debuted the price,,, they had, but it was already put back in!!!! I was grateful for that. At 6:45, I received a text that the pizza had left to head our way. Of course, it never showed. I know they have a hard time getting delivers, but I own a business and wouldn't offer a service I couldn't do. This was our last time to eat here, or order. It makes me cautious of what service is being done IN the kitchen. Just our experience. Our Order ID was #77, on 12-28-19. read more

The first thing that happened was a teenager came out texting on his phone. Didn't greet us but then an adult walked around him to greet us and he commented "shit" at her for interrupting his texting. Food wasn't great. read more

I can't believe some of these low ratings here! We've seldom ever gotten really bad service, and never gotten bad food here. The staff has always seemed friendly and helpful and the food delicious. We do think the price is high, but everything they offer is way better than the other "Italian Eateries" in town! And one of those other eateries gave themselves an unathorized gratutity of $25 on my card, and it took me 3 months to get it back, and no one got fired or arrested! No telling what happens to the people who don't watch their card transactions! But Mazzio's has always been the best here, and still is, you best check it out yourself, I will say the toppings are a little sparse but yet they're much better than the others! So yeah, there is some room for minor improvements, but they're a franchise and required to make it the same as all other Mazzio's. read more

Mazzio's is not the best but it was close. The staff was nice. Their pizza is ok. The salad bar was ok. Mazzio's is ok. I don't really know what else to say. It was close. read more

Bad..... found mold in 2 different parmesan shakers. I can only imagine how clean everything thing else is. They simply told me "sorry they were supposed to clean them yesterday" do yourself a favor and stick to pizza hut or a frozen pizza read more

Mazzio's Italian Eatery - Mmm mold - Italian Near Me - Pryor, Oklahoma

This has got to be the worst food I have had. I ordered lasagna which was a very sad excuse for lasagna. The sauce was horrible plus it was so thin and such a small piece (which actually was a good thing) for the price you pay. I will not waste my money again and definitely would not recommend it to my worst enemy. BIG WASTE OF MONEY!!! We don't eat out but maybe twice a month but it makes eating at home all that more enjoyable. It doesn't even deserve 1 star cause their pizza is mediocre to say the least read more