Not to worry! Lamotta's is still essentially here it is now Matthew's. We rolled up on a Saturday night after 7pm and noticed the name change on the sign. The tiny place was packed which is not typical. This place does a lot of takeout business. The wait staff is the same (great service!) and the food is still yummy. Pricing for pizza can get steep when you add lots of toppings but we get multiple meals from one large delicious pie so it's worth it. My only complaint is this: as a dine in customer it has the feel of a fast food restaurant rather than the ambiance we prefer from a nice Italian restaurant. Not much can be done about that in this venue ( there are only about 6 tables! Hopefully they can expand into a larger space to round out the dinner experience. For now we'll keep coming back for consistently good food and service. Give them a try! read more

We stopped into MPK as part of our Cape Coral pizza tour. You're happy to report that this place made the cut. The crust was cooked perfectly and the ingredients tasted fresh. We would absolutely order pizza from here again. read more

Matthew's Pizza Kitchen - Tasty garlic knots - Italian Near Me - Cape Coral, Florida

See all

Really good pizza with a good variety for the family. The hard part was having the family agree on a pizza. Highly recommend take out vs dining in. Since drinks are served in cans. read more

Matthew's Pizza Kitchen - Cheese Pizza - Italian Near Me - Cape Coral, Florida

See all

On consecutive days we ordered the Grand PApa and Bianca which is Matthews white pie. Both were excellent. Dough is very good and the other ingredients are top notch. Not an in depth review, but definitely a pizza place we'll frequent and I recommend you do as well. Young ladies that answer the phones are friendly and very helpful on the pick up. Absolutely zero issues placing an order. Pizza is top notch! Prices are excellent too. read more

See all

This is surely a "world-class" place. It's not just a pizza place, it's a small restaurant. There's a rather extensive menu with lots of Italian specialties! Many sit-down tables were all dolled up in red and white, and looking clean and inviting. The whole space screams clean, neat, and well managed. Matthew was in the kitchen doing his thing. Our server Faith, was handling the dining room like a pro. Believe all the hype, the pizza is awesome and very photogenic. Don't hesitate, go here! read more

Matthew's Pizza Kitchen - 16" Cheese Pizza - Italian Near Me - Cape Coral, Florida

Great pizza Will be back soon The family enjoyed the meal.We have ordered from here on several occasions read more

Stopped in for the first time the day before Memorial Day and it was amazing! Absolutely wonderful pizza, kind and friendly staff, and great value. Made me feel very welcome. You will leave satisfied! A hidden gem and I'll be back for sure! read more

Matthew's Pizza Kitchen - Italian Near Me - Cape Coral, Florida

Seems like this place has changed ownership. I'm gonna guess it's maybe the son? I've always enjoyed the food, but the prices are just a little bit higher justified. Better than many. I will visit from time to time. read more

Went to this little hole in the wall place. Blown away! ALL good is fresh. Dough and bread knots made by hand on premises. Everything is delicious. Try it! You'll go back over and over. Very impressed. My MIL was from Italy. This! Rivals hers read more

Nice little family run Italian restaurant in corner of little strip mall. I just had the lunch special meatball sub for $5.50. It was so good! 3 large meatballs and they didn't skimp on the mozzarella ...I love cheese! Sorry I devoured it before thinking about doing review! read more

Matthew's Pizza Kitchen - Italian Near Me - Cape Coral, Florida

Expired drinks first one had black mold the second was flat . I looked up the code and it expired over a year ago .First time there waited 45 minutes and was given the wrong pizza . I could hear the cook yelling in the kitchen.He then told the waitress we would have to wait another 20 minutes. The high school girl looked frazzled probably from getting yelled at . I pd and tipped and left .Never again theres a lot of good places to eat . read more

We made the mistake of choosing to eat in the restaurant. Food was delicious when it finally was served. Not all food was delivered together. First pizza was not made correctly, no sauce due to tomato allergy = pizza made with no cheese! It took over an hour for chicken tenders kids meal and pasta dish to make it the table. I got NO COMPENSATION, no discount, nothing. If I order again it will be to go. read more

Food is amazing and the owner Matt goes beyond amazing to please he's customers! Must try! Had the antipasto today and I have never enjoyed such an amazing salad read more

Matthew's Pizza Kitchen - Italian Near Me - Cape Coral, Florida

See all

Great cuisine, and If you are looking for a pizza that is just like a NY pie, then order the Grandpa's Pie! Amazing thin crispy crust (request crispy), the sauce is rich and flavorful, with plenty of garlic and mozzarella. You will not be disappointed. Bon Appetito! And try a glass of their imported Italian wine. Salute! Cin Cin! read more

Amazing selection and honest staff. I accidentally ordered the same delivery order twice and they were quick to cancel the duplicate order. Food was delicious and we ordered again just 2 days later! Highly recommend! read more

"Not the best pizza I've ever had. Weird Sauce" - Kasey Something was just off. Could've been better. Not sure if sauce had enough sauce. Cheese was slightly over cooked. A bit melted on the pie. Will be giving this place another shot and will report back. read more

Excellent service food and nice seating and parking. Hidden gem in Cape Coral! We will certainly return for the pizza and excellent pasta! Don't forget Bruschetta appetizer! Not touristy- more of a local spot where it is nice that there are not a lot of out of town crowds. Don't be fooled by the strip mall and humble surroundings. When a good garlicky pasta or creamy alfredo is the only thing that you are craving, then this is the place to go. Fountain drinks would be nicer than the canned soft drinks but that is not a disaster. I am looking forward to the next time we order to try something else like piccata or chicken parm. The servings are HUGE! read more

We've been coming to this place since November 2020 and every time we've eaten here the food has been fantastic Now under new ownership the place is even better read more

Walked in and were the only people in there, so I thought it would be simple to order takeout. No. The guy that was taking our order had to ask multiple times what we wanted, not sure what the problem was. Anyway, we get home and they did not give us what we ordered. And we tried the food anyway and it was terrible, just threw it away. Don't know why so many people recommend this place when there are so many other real authentic Italian restaurants. read more

We ordered delivery, wings, and margarita pizza. The wings were very good, and the pizza was excellent. The pizza was fresh and flavorful. It's definitely a repeat purchase. read more

Great service on Mother's Day. The food was delicious. The only downfall is it's a small place but I still give this a high rating because the service and food was great. read more

My normal pizza joint was closed yesterday, so decided to try this spot. The pizza I ordered was delivered on time, and seems to have been what I ordered. Nothing special, middle of the road pizza. I did notice something off with it however, and stopped after one slice. Ended up a bit later with a pretty good case of food poisoning. The restaurant might want to review its food handling processes. I'll certainly never order from them again, and I would urge you not to either. I generally don't give reviews to restaurants but when they make me sick, I feel it is in the public service to let everyone know. read more

We ordered delivery from LaMotta's for the first time today. We got a Hawaiian pizza and the Romano Puttanesca with chicken. The pizza was pretty good and a great size too for a "small" It is easily as big as a medium pizza from Domino's so you get a lot of bang for your buck. The pasta was a big portion as well and it looked delicious but it had way too many anchovies. Like A LOT!!!! to the point that it was overpowering the rest of the ingredients. I couldn't finish it. The chicken was tender and it tasted awesome.the salad was fresh and the garlic roll was BOMB. It would've been a 5 star review if it wasn't for the huge amount of anchovies. Not writing them off tho. I think this place has potential for sure. Will order from them again just not their puttanesca. The staff was super friendly and very accommodating when I asked them not to ring the bell because the baby was asleep! read more

Matthew's Pizza Kitchen - Pile of anchovies - Italian Near Me - Cape Coral, Florida

Ordered take out by 8pm and very sad. Like sit under the stairs sad and question life. So many good reviews and was so sad when I got my order. Pizza was okay and the garlic knots was dry shoe leather. Burnt garlic on and not eve soft and chewy, least the pizza was very chew and plain even though I had pepperoni. U wouldn't know it did but I seen them on thier but missed the taste. read more

Matthew's Pizza Kitchen - Chewy pizza with what lacks pepperoni flavor. And yes that's fire house wrapper under it. I have know clue. - Italian Near Me - Cape Coral, Florida

See all

Wife got an orange cream soda that had no expiration date and had mold under the cap. Ordered a pizza with mushrooms on the side. Told girl to either sauté them or cook in pizza oven on a steel plate. After 40 minutes I asked waitress does he need me to come back there and cook my own pizza? 15 minutes later the pizza came out with mushrooms all over it. 55 minutes for the wrong pizza. She said he said it would be 20 minutes to make another we said no cancel paid for our sodas tipped her and left. Half the menu was blacked out. Note there were only two other tables with total six people in there. I give this place maybe 4 months till they close the door. Will never make it off season. Was first and last time there. read more

I was there on Sunday with my friend. Excellent service. We both got a pizza. She had the meat lovers. I had the margarita. Crust is excellent. Pizza was really tasty. I will be back. Give them a try. read more

new cape coral location,....Okay I am from ny, this was worst sicilian pizza I ever ate, the doe was dry and no flavor, had a bad aftertaste that was not very good at all realized something was definitely not fresh about this pie....we also order a round pie which was okay but not very good at all...wish it was great but was probably worst I've ever eaten. we all got really sick four people from the sccillian pie all said doe tasted stale with a bad aftertaste.... .....best pie around cape coral is fat apple, and Joe daddy's... read more

Matthew's Pizza Kitchen - Sccillian pie - Italian Near Me - Cape Coral, Florida

See all

We just love Matthew's Pizza! Best in SWFl so far. The girls up front are always super nice and tonight they went above and beyond to make a bad delivery service (not their own) a corrected problem and made all good. Something Matthew's did not have to do but did to make our night better. Thank you Mathew! We bragged on you before now will do it a little louder. Great to see there are still great sincere businesses. With great customer service! Joyce & Aaron Phillips read more

We've had nothing but excellent food and service at Matthew's Pizza Kitchen. Our Favorites are the bruschetta and Sicilian pizza so far. Nice, clean little place to eat, with a steady take out crowd stopping in. Theresa is amazing! read more

I've added LaMotta's to my list of favorite restaurants because of its consistency. It consistently provides great food and customer service. Food is always fresh and delicious, and the service is always on point (no matter if you're dining in or ordering out). If you order for pickup and they say your food will be ready at a certain time, it actually is ready at that time. I haven't had a bad meal or experience there, yet. I've been a customer since their days in Fort Myers. My favorite meal there is the Eggplant Parmigiana, but everything is good. Thank you LaMotta's! I'm truly a happy customer. read more

Now it's called Mathew's pizza kitchen.... The place should close down! Food/pizza is tasteless. The 1980's parsley sprinkled on the food needs to go. Service was terrible! Another restaurant owner/chef that has no clue about the restaurant business. Another restaurant that's gonna shut down. Good luck!! read more

Will never order from here again! Ordered fried zucchini got French fries! Ordered the chicken marsala it was like soup and had spilled all over the bag....just a bas experience! read more

Tried a meatball sub and fettuccini Alfredo. Meatball sub was amazing. Meatballs were flavorful and tender really delicious. Bread was out of this world! Crusty and crispy and soft all at the same time. Fantastic flavor. Garlic knots were so good too. Fettuccini Alfredo fell very short for me. Pasta was cooked perfectly but the sauce was basically a cream sauce. No saltiness from the parm. Idk maybe this is how it really is in Italy and I'm just warped from eating American Alfredo. But based on the taste alone, had I been blindfolded, I would never have been able to identify this as Alfredo of any kind. Maybe they forgot the cheese during cooking? Either way the food quality was so good I'm down to try their other stuff. read more

I wish I could give a minus rating. Tonight I ordered a pizza and some pork wings. The pizza is my husband's dinner and the pork wings are mine. They eventually sent a message that they don't have any pork wings and will just send the pizza. I guess I don't eat tonight. How about a phone call to the customer with the opportunity to order something else? I won't be back. read more

LaMotta's has moved from Fort Myers to Cape Coral and is under new management. They follow a lot of the previous award winning recipes, serving great homemade dishes and Pizzas. We went yesterday for the first time since the restaurant move and found that their Bianca Pizza (white pie) was exactly the same taste and quality as the previous owners. We came down from Venice Fl. just to check the new owners out. We definitely will be back and highly recommend LaMotta's Pizza. When you walk thru the door, Theresa will definitly take good care of you. Give it a try, you'll be glad you did!!! read more

Two stars (except for the overstressed waitress) a few Saturday nights ago. A ten top next to us thought it was super cool to sing Italian songs to the muzak AT THE TOP OF THEIR LUNGS, killing any chance of others enjoying our meal or conversations. Not one or two songs, but for an hour. Management did nothing, even with complaints. Pizza, 'Sicilian', was a large, hard loaf of bread, minimal sauce and toppings. The flat pizzas had crazy applications of toppings, one piece covered in onion slices/soggy green peppers, another piece next to it with nothing but cheese. I really was disappointed due to a number of great reviews from others but our night was a disaster on all levels. Except that poor waitress, bless her. read more

Great pizza. the crust was so nice and crispy. great service also. The owner was very friendly he ask how the food was. I will go back and try something different next time. read more

(9/3) Food - Service - Chef - was Great lunch on Sunday noon with a Birthday Cake was GREAT thank you

MONDAY my wife ordered a large pizza special with 10 wings and a 2 litre drink. I went for their Meatball Parmigiano sub/hero/sandwich that was packed up from their kitchen yesterday. $11.00+ for 3 meatballs on maybe 7 inches of edible bread. NOPE, NOT EVER AGAIN. I asked the rather large gentleman relaxing/lounging/laying over the first booth/table if they made any New York style sausage rolls like those you might find in Mineola. His answer "what is Mineola? No Sausage rolls here, we'd lose money on them". But if you like little tiny portions of food, this may be your kinda place. read more

Matthew's Pizza Kitchen - Meatball Parm Sub with 3 meatballs and and 1/4 of the sandwich (the half at the top) you can see they just served a giant bread knot. - Italian Near Me - Cape Coral, Florida

LaMotta's is the best. Their pizza is fantastic. The best I've ever had. The owner does not know how to do things small. The Calzones and Stromboli's are large enough to feed two. All of the meals are prepared with the utmost of care. If you're looking for some great Italian food, you're going to the right place. read more