I leased with Toonen Properties for just over 3 years: 2 years at The Shores and 13 months at Cedar…read moreLake. My lease at Cedar Lake was set to expire on 10/1/2022. In July, Toonen reached out regarding lease renewal, which included a large rent increase of 14.5%. Although I anticipated a rent increase, I did not expect it to be 14.5%. I called the office to inquire if there were any plans for improvements to the apartment (i.e., replacing the old carpet, updating to hardwood floors, replacing old appliances, etc.) but NO, it was an across-the-board market-inspired increase.
I was in the process of looking for a home (condo) to purchase, but the housing market being what it was earlier in the year, the search was going very slowly. I pondered the situation and knew if I didn't find anything by October 1st, I was going to suspend my search until spring. Eventually, I decided to sign the year lease, thinking it was unlikely I'd find anything by October and that by the time I started searching again in Spring and went through the whole process, I would be close to renewal again in 2023. So, late in the evening of August 3rd, after business hours, I signed the lease renewal.
On 8/4, I received an email around mid-morning, confirming Toonen had received my renewal and also signed it. An hour or so later, my realtor texted me about a condo that was coming to market, within my price range, and was I interested. And I was definitely interested! I immediately called the Toonen office and spoke to Tina. I was very transparent with her, and asked her if we could negate the JUST-signed renewal and sign the bi-monthly renewal instead and she said no. I was disappointed to say the least, that less than 2 hours after completing the renewal there was not even a consideration.
Nonetheless, I viewed the condo, loved it, and put in an offer and my offer was accepted. On 8/11, I submitted my formal 60-day notice that I would be vacating by 10/31/2022. Again, I contacted the office to see if there was any way Toonen would consider terminating my lease early. I had been an excellent tenant for +3 years. I'd always paid rent on time, followed the rules, etc. I was hopeful that Toonen would take all the circumstances into consideration, especially given that it was literally less than 2 hours after Toonen had signed the renewal and allow me out of the lease. My hopes were dashed.
I was out of the apartment before 10/31. I'd been monitoring the apartment listings since August and apartments were renting fairly quickly. I again was hopeful that my apartment would rent quickly. Wrong again. Very little effort was put by Toonen into re-renting. I advertised it on social media, but my circle is only so big.
I knew November would be rough for me financially as I got everything in order at my new condo, but that I would be able to catch up on the rent I was expected to pay on top of my new mortgage, HOA fees, etc. Unfortunately, on Nov 11th, my job was eliminated and I was laid off. So here I find myself, without income, with a mortgage, and HOA fees, with normal expenses (lights & gas, water bill, phone bill, etc.) and with a 2nd rent on an apartment that I don't live in. And so, I reached out to Toonen again, begging for mercy, to have the lease terminated. I would do my best to pay the rent they charged me for November and December, and their late fees, as quickly as possible, but for them to keep piling on rent fees every month meant I would be buried in debt.
Mind you, Robert Toonen owns the following:
* 5 apartment communities in the Green Bay area AND
* 6 apartment communities in De Pere AND
* 3 apartment communities in Appleton AND
* 1 apartment community in each, Kaukauna, Little Chute and Menasha, for a total of 17 apartment communities; AND
* 1 storage facility in Green Bay.
He collects many hundreds of thousands of dollars every month, if not in excess of a Million... yet there is no consideration for the folks who are putting that money in his pockets. The unconscionable greed is sickening.