I have never been inside so I can't give 5/5, but it's by far the best pizza I have had in Pennsylvania. I'm a life long New Yorker who moved to Central PA. It's been four years of wack "New York style" pizzas. I saw the reviews and ordered from here. We were all ready to cry when we opened the box. The pizzas smelled great, were cheesy hot and delicious. The sauce and the cheese do not taste cheap like some other places, it tastes like love. I have no pictures because after the first bite we all inhaled pie after pie. The extra cheese pizza is a proper extra cheese. This place is a treasure. I hope their in person service is great because their pizza is gold. 9/10 read more

Good for a quick slice, but not the best pizza. Dinner was OK, as were the heros. Stay away from the soup.

What is this !!!??? . Husband got the lasagna and for how layered it was .... Mediocre at best . Marinara sauce is watery and tasteless. Stick with the pizza ! This was terrible . So much sauce and again tasteless! And yes this is the actual color of the dish. Had two bites and just couldn't do it. read more

Mamma's Pizza - Gnocchi al pesto. - Pizza Near Me - Loganville, Pennsylvania

First time trying Mammals pizza friendly staff the ambiance is soothing the floors are clean the cheesesteak is delicious two thumbs up!!! read more

Mamma's Pizza - Cheesesteak - Pizza Near Me - Loganville, Pennsylvania

I ordered two meatball subs and one pepper steak hoagie today. The rolls were hard over baked and they were soggy. When I called I was immediately put on hold but when I arrived at the restaurant there was only one couple in there. It's very disappointing. read more

My friend and I stopped in for lunch and there were many lunch specials on a blackboard. But it's a pizza place so we got pizza! We both asked to add mushrooms to our slices. Fresh mushrooms and plentiful- all over our slices! On the not so good side, I thought the crust was too thin and that there wasn't enough sauce. On the plus side, I asked for a little red sauce which they happily provided and there was enough for the two of us to make our pizza just right. There was plenty of good tasting mozzarella too. There are shakers of garlic, oregano and red pepper flakes available. There is a dining room for dinner and on the other side there is a counter and lunch area where we sat. The guy at the counter was very friendly and it was a good place for a leisurely lunch. read more

Mamma's Pizza - Counter area. Look at those sub rolls! - Pizza Near Me - Loganville, Pennsylvania

Hands down the best sub rolls around. I use to work in the bank across the street and I probably got lunch from here at least twice a week the whole time I worked there. Fries have the perfect crisp to them. The family that owns this location are the nicest people you'll ever meet. After the renovations the shop looks beautiful. Any time I'm in the Loganville area I try to stop in. read more

Just not what it used to be. Very bland; greasy at times. Always Uncooked or burnt. No flavor. Loganville needs new pizza place for certain. They need to either step it up or hang it up. read more

We want to love Mamma's and mostly do. The food is consistently great - lunch specials, dinner at the restaurant, or take out. Last evening we had our last dine in experience where we are a small party and there is a large, happy, and then of course loud party seated in the dining room. We will sadly not be eating in if we walk into that situation again. Everyone has the right to their dining occasion. The restaurant is such that when there is a large, happy, loud party in the dining room there is so much noise echo that we can't talk to each other and last night it actually gave me a headache. The food was a five, the staff was going their best (it was busy!) and a solid four, the ability to enjoy our meal was a one. It is what is and others like that; it simply doesn't work for us. Just know what it is. (The second dining room was fine, but that hasn't been open since the pandemic.) read more

Food was really good, got a Philly pizza and it was great. The steak was cooked well I just wish it was more spread out on the pizza because it was mostly towards the middle of the pizza/bottom of the slice. The personal was huge though, could feed two people for sure. Great prices and nice staff this was a cute spot. read more

Kinda odd when you go in to pick up your order of pizza and wings + $1.25 cup of garlic sauce. They read your order to you to confirm (including the garlic sauce). But then they don't actually PUT the sauce you paid extra for in the bag, thus negating to whole point of confirming the order. Super Uncool. -----IOU Invoice------ $1.25 + .08 tax total: $1.33 payer: Mamma's payee: Me read more

We have been going to Mamma's for over 25 years. This a great family-owned small business right off I-83 in Loganville. We enjoy their specialty pizzas and stromboli. Their enlarged restaurant is huge compared to the little pizza it place it was back in the 90's. I like the stuffed shells and manicotti. The bread is all home made daily. Great family; we always have fast, friendly service and remember it's BYOB. read more

We usually get carry out and it's always spectacular. There are occasions where the pizza is over or under done, but this may be expected for a local place. We've been happy and continue to go back. Veggie pizza and special cheese steak are amazing. read more

Welcomed immediately. Very friendly and welcoming. Really good prices. Large portions. Delicious selections. We have traveled through Italy numerous times and Mamma's Pizza absolutely brought back memories of eating out in Calabrian towns. It is cozy and open at the same time, definitely the look and feel of Italy. I honestly believe a dinner here would be like eating in Sicily. read more

We love Mamma's! Everything from their pizza, apps, and subs are 10/10. Chick-o-philly is one of our absolute favorites on their menu. Quick service and friendly staff. We have never done dine-in but never had issues with to-go. read more

Hunter was seriously the nicest person I've ever met. The pizza was great, but the service is why I'll keep coming back. Thank you for such a great experience, Hunter! read more

Great subs, fantastic service. Clean, we will be back again. Going to work our way through the menu. The homemade bread is the best

So, the food here is very good. The bread for their subs and hot sandwiches (I had the Chick-o-Philly sandwich) is fantastic. The sandwiches and the pizza are very good also. My wife had the spaghetti with meat sauce and she always loves it. So, why the 3 rating? Well sorry to say the service wasn't good. It took us over an hour to get served. I will come back and hope that the kitchen cooks get faster and they train the servers better. Now they could have been short staffed and you never know. But the food is very good! So overall, I gave a 3. Update: So a quick update, the good news is the Manager came out and acknowledged the issue and gave everyone in the group (it was a group of 11, 10% off the bill). This is even better reason to come for the food and hopefully the service will be corrected! read more

I'm from Illinois so I love pizza, especially deep dish. My fiancé, well she just thinks deep dishes are pies (she's correct, a beautiful saucy, cheesy pie) , so we ordered a thin crust We ordered a standard medium meat lovers pizza, I would consider it to be 6 medium-to-large slices, absolutely delicious. The crust was cooked perfect, a little soft towards the middle, but nice and crunchy on the outside. The meat, tasty and not over-cooked, especially the sausage, lip smacking good. Not overly saucy, just the right amount for a thin pizza, with a great amount of cheese. The service, great, the kid was probably in high school or slightly older, attentive, nice and got our order MOVIN' baby. I think it was done in 10-15 minutes tops, I lost track because it's BYOB, so we ran to Rutter's to get some alcohol. 10/10 would dine here again and don't be stingy, tip your service industry workers. read more

Really good crispy fry'!! not that soggy stuff . Pizza is great. And the staff is great hard workers ! I love this place honestly

Great pizza. I usually call in and pick up and the pizza is ready as promised. Subs are good as well.

Food is very bland i try my best not to go. The pizza is mediocre and the cheesesteak meat taste horrible i hope the place improves because i live close by. read more

Nice place, good food, good atmosphere, friendly service, good prices. Have been back multiple times. read more

Terrific spot for subs, etc!! We've lived in So. York Co. for 20+ years, and I'm sorry to say this is my first visit. The food was great, service stellar and environment was clean. The bread and rolls were homemade and the best around!! I'm looking forward to my next visit to try the "real" dinners... I've heard they are quite good. Also note that they offer BYOB, which I truly like. read more

Good pizza, NY style crust, with a decent amount of ingredients. We had a pepperoni, and a veggie deluxe. The pepperoni was a little better, Also ordered something they call chicken sliders, which were like giant Totino's pizza rolls, and they're pretty good. read more

One of the best restaurants I have been to. Pizza is great, wings are cooked to perfection and the service is great. Love this place

I'm not sure how exactly this happened but we ordered subs and used a credit card in the evening and the early next day, everything was compromised on my Credit Card right after that, so obviously I wouldn't use a credit card here. No reply from management read more

The pizza is amazing, but the prices are a little hefty. I still like coming here for the quality and the location.

Pretty good pizza! We (2 adults) had the all meat as a medium pizza and could not finish; the slices are huge!! Had the wings with old bay for an appetizer and they were pretty good. I am not sure why this location is only a 3 star. The service was great and attentive. We were seated right away, waited on within a decent time, got our drinks, appetizer and pizza all within a good amount of time. The pizza was very good for being right up the street for us. Uses pure mozzarella and not a 3 cheese combination as some other pizza places do. They also have a variety of subs Italian dishes, Pepsi products, and a dessert menu, but we did not have room for dessert. It was a great Sunday dinner out. Will likely be back. Don't see a reason not to go back for a great evening of pizza and Italian yumminess! read more

See all

We order here often and usually get takeout. The pizza is usually very good and I also enjoy the boats/subs. Service here is also usually very good as well. We've ordered the tiramisu and it was quite good. We also like the kids menu, as sometimes my daughter does not want pizza. She likes to order meatballs from here. Only thing I ordered before that I was really disappointed in was the chicken piccata. It was basically like eating poached chicken in a water sauce-because the sauce had zero flavor. read more

The service was lousy and not polite at all .The pizza was very greasy.And there was very little sauce I was very dissatisfied . They need to remember to be polite to the customer.I would only give them one star.And I will not be going back not will I recommend them. read more

Mamma's is my first choice when we order dinner. The food is delicious, and service is consistently excellent. Their sub rolls are fantastic, and dinner portions always serve me two meals. You won't want to miss this place!!! read more

Their food is always delicious. We've ordered their subs and pizzas, fries and other items. We have always been pleased with the quality and taste. In addition, they are prompt and if you download their app, you can even get specials or coupons and they have a rewards program for dinners, lunches, pizzas, subs and deserts. read more

Pizza is probably the best in the area south of York proper. I would give it a 3 out of 5 and the wife loves this pizza with a 4 out of 5. So if you need a pie give it a whirl. read more

I ordered the stuffed shells dinner for 11.99 recently. When I got it home there were 3 small shells in a large container with a lot of sauce. I thought it was a mistake so I called and asked how many are included in the dinner. They said 3. It came with a small salad and bread but even so for the price I thought there should be at least 5 or 6. There is no meat in them so why so expensive? The sauce had no flavor and was very bland. Needless to say I won't be ordering that again!! I used to like Mama's but it has gone downhill. I'll stick with Paseano's in Loganville! read more

Food was good, but overshadowed by disappointing service. Long long wait after seating. Many beverages were unavailable. Never received refills, had to ask repeatedly for dip for wings. Server was perhaps preparing food as well? Might explain the absence. Really felt ignored. White pizza, Stromboli, wings, were all delicious, Caesar salad was just lettuce and parmigiana with dressing on the side. read more

"Never again " after waiting 30 mins the waitress came out and brought the pizzaand said" the cook forgot rest of the order , that it will take another 15 minutes.well any orders were still messed up. After complaining to the waitress she said there's nothing she can do about it. Oh by the way the pizza was burnt. Very poor attitude on the waitresses Part, when she brought the bill she had the gall to ask if we wanted any change back. That's why I left her a penny. Very unprofessional on June 14th 2016. I will never walk in that place again or recommend it to anybody read more

ISo today on March 13th at 3:00 pm I went to Mamma's Pizza for some pizza obviously. I just recently moved to Loganville so for my first visit it sucked. I waited about 20 minutes before I was seated and the staff was short. I finally got seated and it took about another 15 minutes for a waitress to attend me. I then ordered a medium cheese pizza and a sub, I watched the waitress talk to other workers and not put my order in yet because it was in her hand!!! About after 30 minutes the waitress came out with the pizza and I asked where my sub was and she then told me that the cook messed it up and it would be right out. After I had already ate as much pizza I could my sub came out 15 minutes later by this time im just angry. She didn't even seem to care and the place was just empty I wonder why. The sub was sloppy and the mayonnaise was all over the place. I decided to eat half and try it and the meat looked RAW!!! I just paid my order and left which the balance was $30.25 which isn't too bad but the food wasn't so good for that much money. I don't think I would ever eat there again especially if the staff is not serious. read more

First restaurant I tried moving into Loganville unfortunately a disappointing experience. Service was slow and understaffed I ordered the sausage Parmesan sub and got pizza fixings on a sub roll who in the world serves sausage bologna that's the only way I can describe it my husband cheesesteak was mediocre at best he didn't even finish half of it I cannot recommend this establishment at all. read more

After hearing from a few people that this place had good pizza it was time to pack the little judges up and try it. After two small boli's, a personal cheese pizza and a large white pizza with tomato's and spinach the results are in. We love it! We also had two apps. I know a lot of food, but we have plenty for the next few days. Not to mention the price was reasonable. Can't wait to go back and try some of the pasta dish's. read more