We've been in town a handful of times, and have been told that WTSP has great food, but to be…read morehonest, it's hard to read from the exterior. Sure, it looks welcoming and friendly enough, but there is no way of knowing just how OUTRAGEOUSLY good the flipping food is. After one visit, WTSP is immediately on our favorite places list, and we cannot wait to come back. The burgers are out of control good, regardless if you get the smash patty or the more traditional hand patty. The bread is homemade in the best way possible, and the attention to details - the absolutely perfect fries as example - shine through. This food is made by a kitchen that cares. And same for the pizza. I was nervous because I saw everyone ordering REALLY delicious looking Detroit style pizza, but we went with a round, hand tossed, pepperoni number. And man alive, I am glad we did. It was up there with some of the best pizza I've had in Michigan, which if you know Michigan, is saying a LOT. Long story short, this place rules. Yes, it's a little rough around the edges, but do yourself a favor and pop in for a local beer and a burger, and take home a pizza to have for dinner the next day. You'll thank me for it.

Excellent service! Excellent pizza!! True Detroit Style! I cannot say enough of how amazing the…read moretaste of this pizza is!the antipasto is HUGE! We'll def be back! It's literally just north of the water tower!

I ordered just a small pizza and a beer. Pizza finally came out and it was burnt…read more took a bite and I could not eat it. I ate the cheese off the top with the pepperoni. I had to go find her to get a bill. then she asked me if I wanted to take it home. I laughed at her and told her it was un Edible. And she just walked away! So when I paid my bill, I paid just for my food and a drink. I told her if she wants to take that nasty pizza off my bill she can have her tip that way. I will never ever go back there

Some of the food is ok, only the perch is what I would consider "good." Just had their pizza for…read morethe second time, both times were inedible. Unless you like spaghettios, the cheapest of "mozzella," and really tasteless meat. The crust, also not chewy and not as good as a hand tossed pizza should be, weirdly, my "Parmesan crust," tasted like it had sugar sprinkled in it. Could be the sauce was so sugary that it just seemed like it. I added garlic, pizza sauce and hot pepper flakes I like at home, and still threw it out. Not had a decent burger there either (they make the bartenders cook them frequently, and they're still paid less than their cooks are). I know it's a "local pub," but I wouldn't expect anything to be very good. One more note: literally the weirdest tasting dirty martini ever. Waiting to see if something was "off," but hoping it was just some nasty bitters or a spoiled olive, I ordered my fave vodka, so it wasn't that.

We had the hot honey pizza and it was amazing! We love this place. The bartender/server Janie was…read moreso friendly and adorable.

A group of us were in town for a bachelorette party & stopped here Saturday early afternoon. It's…read moresuper cute inside & was clean as well! I ordered 2 different drinks, the strawberry basil smash & the stormy night martini, both were delicious! A friend & I split the bbq chicken pizza & it was so good! I would definitely order it again. Our server was nice, but the service was pretty slow even though they didn't appear very busy. It took a long time to get drinks. I do feel a lot of their stuff is a bit overpriced, but the flavors were all good. Ultimately it was a good experience & I would come back.

Nice large menu. Good variety of food delicious food. Friendly staff. Good ambiance. Love their…read morepizza.

The surf and turf was great. I always enjoy the salad and bread. No wait as I was able to make a…read morereservation.

It's been a few years since last review. I take cheating on mushrooms seriously lol. This time the…read morepizza was perfect! And I got my double Mushroom! Thank you Mrs Zirelli!!!

Fantastic Olive Burger, with all the fixings, heavy all, delicious, friendly staff super cool,…read moresmall town appeal down home atmosphere, highly recommend~when you're passing through!

Best ice cream. And quite good pizza and salad. This place is a gem if you go to Lakeport State…read morePark.

Come for the ice cream, stay for the cheese bread! Like all pizza inspired dishes in the area, it's…read moreDetroit style, and man alive is it ever cheesy and good. The store is super small, and covid precautions are absolutely not in effect, but they won't look at you too weird if you wear a mask. Just make sure you come with an appetite and low blood sugar.

The BEST pizza in the world! I grew up on this pizza and drive 16 hours home-one of the best…read morethings i look forward to. Always get a side of nacho cheese sauce for dipping.

I drove 20+ minutes each way (+ additional delay due to road work) to get Ernesto's pizza for my…read moremom who loves BLT pizza. So pleasantly surprised when they asked if I wanted the lettuce, tomato & mayo in a separate box? Made all the difference! Mom was super happy with it! Note: as of July 2022, curbside pickup only!

The Meatball Sliders were absolutely out of this world!!…read more The Pizza is absolutely delicious as always.

The service staff is always very nice, and the food is always excellent. Very very good. I've not…read morehad anything that I didn't like yet. Highly recommend.

Great food and great service!!!! Really a cute place inside full of character for sure. A hidden…read moregem!

The Forester Inn restaurant is one of the best places to go. Service is great, the atmosphere is…read moregreat, and the prices are good. We have tried many of the dinners offered, and the salad bar is fresh. Good thing they have parking across the street from them as they get busy a lot. The waitress is attentive even when she is super busy. I recommend you give it a try.