My garden club had our Christmas luncheon here and it was amazing. Everyone loved the food and decor! I had salmon and it was great, as always. The desserts were all FABULOUS! The pistachio cranberry bread was inspirational--a couple of people said they were going to try to make it. The melted chocolate truffle was amazing, as always. My very favorite was the white chocolate mousse--the dot of raspberry sauce was delightful. The mousse was light and airy but also rich and decadent--and my last bite had a white chocolate chip. That was the perfect ending to a perfect lunch. And the coffee, as always, was SOOOOO yummy. Thanks JC Wyatt for accommodating our special Christmas luncheon celebration! read more

JC Wyatt House - Dessert trio is always the highlight for me! - New American Near Me - St. Joseph, Missouri

See all

I have to start this review with an apology to St. Joseph, Missouri. I love the city, it is interesting, and we absolutely love the city. Our only critique is the lack of fine dining. Luckily, that is where the JC Wyatt House comes in. Not only is the food top rate, but the entire experience is amazing. At the JC Wyatt House, you have dinner in an intimate, small dining room inside a Victorian Mansion. Here is how it works. They are only open on Thursday and Friday, 1130am to 1230pm, for lunch and Wednesday thru Saturday, 530pm to 7pm for dinner. Reservations are required and you will choose your main entree for all of your party when you make your reservation. We went for our wedding anniversary and were not disappointed. We arrived a few minutes before our 6pm reservation and were seated. At exactly 6pm, our server, Chris, started with our choice of hors d'oeuvres. Either a potato and fresh vegetable soup, or shrimp cocktail. My wife had the shrimp, and I had the soup. Both were outstanding. For dinner, I had the lamb, and my wife had the filet mignon. Both came with potatoes, carrots and a roll. Again, both meals were outstanding. We finished with a dessert trio that was amazing. Besides the fantastic meal, the service was first class, and the ambiance was really special. This is a must visit for an amazing meal. Call today and get your reservations. read more

See all

Most of the shrimp cocktail was good, there was one piece a little stale. The lamb and salmon were overcooked. My date ordered her lamb "medium rare" so it was quite a surprise that is was "medium well done" instead, she didn't eat most of it. Salmon should be much more lightly cooked than what they served. The sides were good. Desserts were good. Nice interesting ambiance in a renovated older house. Bring your own beer or wine if you want that. If I come back would probably order the steak instead and tell them medium rare, please don't overcook it. Service was generally good, they are friendly. You can be comfortable here in a suit/dress or more casual, but don't recommend sloppy attire. If they get their kitchen execution together it could be a really nice place. read more

If there were a six star rating, this dining experience would deserve it! On a quick trip to St. Joe to visit their unique museums, my son stumbled upon the JC Wyatt house through a restaurant search. I'm so glad he did. I was unsure of what to expect. You will need to have a reservation. You are required to select your entre ahead of time. Bring in your own wine as no alcohol is served there. An unusual restaurant choice turned into a wonderful dining experience. We were treated like we were their most valued patrons. The food was outstanding! The house is fascinating. And I honestly can't think of a single bad thing. Thank you for one of my best dining experiences ever! Visit St. Joseph MO and do not miss this lovely restaurant . JC Wyatt House you were quite a treat!! read more

See all

We had the ultimate dining experience. Excellent, delicious food and outstanding service. We were rewarded with a very personalized dinner. The decor and stories behind the decor will keep every guest entertained. Simply amazing place. read more

My favorite place to eat!!! The owners' friendliness adds to the ambiance!! The food is to die for!!! This place is so comfortable and delish!!! read more

Amazing service & food!! Ambiance is in a very welcome historic home. Reservation only so make sure to call ahead!

Dinner at JC Wyatt house is an absolute, must do, incredible experience. The setting for dinner is an impeccable, lovingly restored Victorian mansion. Expect to be regaled by the proprietor and his partner of stories from his 20 plus years in New York City as a restauranteur that was popular with Hollywood clientele, commissioned paintings by his partner, a collection of handcrafted doll house furniture, the history of JC Wyatt, an incredibly curated collection of seasonal decorations, etc. I equated the experience to "dinner and a show". The grand finale to dinner is a hand crafted dessert trio.....need I say more? read more

Absolutely delightful dinner , service and surroundings. This is truly a beautiful dining experience. They made it very special for my mom on her birthday! read more

See all

My favorite place to eat in St. Joseph, MO! This little restaurant is in an old, but very nicely refurbished house. They have a limited but very good menu, the food is always delicious, the atmosphere is great, the service is always good, and each meal comes with a trio of desserts! Yes, three desserts! read more

This is a lovely Victorian house, which has been converted to a restaurant. The food was nice. I think we had salmon. Neither of the menu choices were very inventive. But well done with what they did. Just not interesting enough. Very basic food. read more

Had dinner last night was wonderful. It's bring your own wine! Guys were super nice and everyone one in our party of 7 enjoyed themselves. read more

Oh so good! Planned a going away lunch for a good friend and coworker. We had a group of 9 who I had some difficulty wrangling a pre order out of, but once the order was submitted via e-mail to Jim, I received a confirmation later that evening and we were set for lunch two days out. Everyone was awed at the interior of the home. A real labor of love to have such a complete Victorian atmosphere and keep it so neat and clean. Dust and neglect is a big turnoff in any restaurant experience, but I challenge you to find any here! Our lunches consisted of various salads; Roasted Salmon, Shrimp Salad on Croissant, Chicken Salad with Spinach and Feta Quiché, and the Mandarin Chicken Entree salad were big winners. I had the Beef and Blue cheese entree salad. Amazing! Dried cherries, glazed walnuts, mixed greens and perfectly cooked beef slices complemented with blue cheese, Magnifiqué! Everyone gushed about their lunches and were soon attracted to the marvelous aroma of their house coffee. Hands down, the best, balanced coffee I have ever had in a restaurant. But the pièce de résistance was the dessert trio! The dark chocolate pudding, the light lemon cupcake, and cheesecake mousse... too much. The most decadent lunch we as a group have ever experienced, and all for around $15.00 each. The biggest challenge is getting your group to decide in advance for an outing like this, but once you have "trained" them, there is no delay on getting people on board for next time. read more

JC Wyatt House - From the front sidewalk looking northwest. - New American Near Me - St. Joseph, Missouri

JC Wyatt House is my go to when I have someone out of town visiting and I want to enjoy a lovely meal and atmosphere! Jim is the best host you could ask for and he is gracious to share the history of his wonderfully renovated home! Great meal and relaxing dining! Plan ahead though, seating is limited! read more

This was an awesome stop! For sure have a meal here. Food was fantastic and honestly, I could have licked my dessert plate. Great value and such an interesting home. We talked with Jim the owner. Super nice. Recommend highly! read more

Beautiful historic house. Chef and his partner are simply amazing people, friendly outgoing and so informative. Food was perfect from start to finish. If you want an upscale date night or high quality business event, this is the place read more

This dining experience is a must in St. Joe! They were waiting by the door when we pulled up, and were treated as family. Jim and Jeff were very hospitable and we loved taking to them! They told us stories of St. Joe and the community and it is very apparent they care and enjoy what they do. The food was awesome! I cut my steak with a butter knife and dessert was to die for! Will definitely be back for more stories and great food!!! read more

Found this looking for a unique place to celebrate my sister's 65th Birthday. It was everything we possibly could have hoped for! As indicated on the webpage, we made our reservation two days in advance and pre-ordered our meals. From the moment we arrived, we felt like honored guests as the host Jim took our coats to hang up for us and escorted us into a charming room at the front. There was a larger party in the room in the back, but we had our area to ourselves for our lunch. Service was impeccable, and the food delightful. We had the salmon, the apple cider chicken, and the quiche with chicken salad. All so delicious! The dessert trio was yummy from the baked chocolate mousse to the mint Chocolate cheesecake and the filled cupcake. More than I could finish. We enjoyed visiting with Jim also. He was very personable, and while I fill that if we had wanted just a quiet service, that would have been fine, he was very happy to fill us in on the history of the beautiful historic mansion he has personally restored. As we are all history buffs, we enjoyed this aspect of the experience immensely. We are already looking for reasons to return to experience the evening meal in this previously unsuspected gem! read more

See all

Once again this fine dining experience was among the most memorable of evenings we have ever had together. The ambiance, the personal attention and then the amazing, delicate, and savory foods. My medium+ steak was deliciously cooked end to end to perfection. My husband had his steak medium rare and his was also cooked to perfection throughout. Mom had the pork tenderloin medallions and dad had the salmon, and all meals were melt in your mouth heaven. Although we shared each of the choices in the first course, (omg, the cheese soufflé, mushroom ravioli, and crab cake) no one offered to share their entrees other than a tiny bite. Then came the finale, the trio of desserts and coffee! If you are looking for the experience of having an award winning personal chef, with the best table side customer serving experience, and the best meal of your life, with no more than a few other customers dining at the same time, plan an evening in St Joseph at JC Wyatt. Thank you! I will book again when I fly back in from Orlando! read more

Spectacular food in a charming setting. The JC Wyatt House is a lovingly restored Victorian home. The food is outstanding, the service friendly, truly an outstanding dining experience. read more

My first visit to this hidden gem. We made reservations for 8. I was a little skeptical after learning this was in a old home in St. Joseph. However, from the moment we stepped inside we were transported. The owner was so pleasant and hospitable! We felt like we were eating dinner at an old friends home. The antiques, the stories and the history made the experience even better. The food.....oh, the food! The three courses were amazing! Each one better than the last. The starters were a meal all their own. Incredible! Our filets were cooked perfectly and were so tender that we used butter knives to cut them. Some of our party had rack of lamb or salmon and each of them endlessly commented in how delicious it was. The desserts were delectible and just the right amount after two large courses. We will most definitely be coming back. Make reservations far in advance if you want to go around holidays. This place books up fast and has limited seating. read more

We had a FABULOUS family Girls Night Out last summer with 3 generations. Dinner and hospitality were 5-star! The owners' labor of love is evident from salads & crab cakes, salmon & filets through the tasty dessert trio read more

JC Wyatt House - Turn of the century home/restaurant has been lovingly restored for fine dining - New American Near Me - St. Joseph, Missouri

See all

This place is incredible. It is the Only place in St. Joseph to dine. I highly recommend it! Not only is the food impeccable but the service is fantastic. read more

Love this place! Attention to detail in comfort and food menu! Atmosphere is cozy in an elegant way! Soft music in the background allows for conversation without competition. I've had the salmon and the filet.... both just as wonderful! And to top it off.... 3 small bite desserts! Not kidding! The warm melt in your mouth chocolate is my fave. Always look forward to going back. Oh and the coffee.... read more

We had a wonderful dinner, impeccable service and great atmosphere in this classic restoration. Area is being upgraded with other restorations, so will be a a hard place to into at some point as more discover. read more

This was my lady's and my first time visiting St Joe for a getaway weekend. Decides to look up some too restaurants and fun places to try for cuisine and came across this place. Was able to make reservations and confirm menu selections easily with no hassle (be sure to do so in advance per instructions). Right off the bat the decor and the ambience of the house can be felt..and it is very pleasant. Beautiful garden along with its artistic colors and decorations welcome the guests with rolling appetites. Jim, the owner of the restaurant AND house, greeted us at the door before we even got to the front door. Immediately entering I felt like I was in 1800s setting, with the backdrop exhuming antique history and classy decor. Every detail from the color of the walls to the table decorations was very pleasing to the eye. The food was absolutely amazing; the chef (Jeff) moved from New York and you can definitely taste the exquisite and high quality flavors in their food. The service was excellent and we will definitely be going back. Great place to try for those of you curious! - Pauline and Joe read more

JC Wyatt House - New American Near Me - St. Joseph, Missouri

Quite literally the best dining I've ever encountered. The level of gastronomic artistry, paired with silver service that redefines "fine dining", is on par with the bigwigs of any world class city. The fact that, dollar for dollar, this is also the most affordable eatery in St Joseph, is almost sacrilege. read more

I would give this place 2 stars and my wife 4, so 3 is the average of our opinions. The house is interesting to look at. The food is pretty blah and pricey. For our first course I got a tomato and mozzarella salad. It was very nice. My wife couldn't decide and ordered a sampler of all three options-- the salad, gazpacho with crab meat, and sage ricotta cheese ravioli. She like the ravioli the best but liked all three. I ordered the lamb chops. They were severely overcooked and not seasoned. The mashed potatoes were bland. The mixed vegetables were nice. My wife got the pork tenderloin with a cherry sauce. She liked it and the potatoes and vegetables too. The dessert trio consisted of a chocolate truffle dish, a key lime cupcake, and a small cheesecake. The chocolate was overwhelmingly chocolate which my wife liked and I didn't. The cupcake was overly dry and filling bland. The cheesecake was no better than the little frozen cheesecake cube you can buy in Sam's Club. My wife said the coffee was very good. At $89, I found the entire experience subpar and would resist returning. read more

JC Wyatt House - New American Near Me - St. Joseph, Missouri

Went to the JC Wyatt house last night and had the stuffed flounder. It was absolutely excellent and along with the white pizza I could not have had a better meal anywhere. Of course the service was wonderful and I always feel like we are the only people in the restaurant and Jeff and Jim are old friends read more

JC Wyatt house is amazing. We had the Chicken Marsala and it was wonderful. The service was impeccable and everything fine dining should be. We felt the price was amazing for all they provided and would have been willing to pay more. The desert trio, which is included with the meal, was delicious. We were so full we could not finish it all. The home this is in is beautiful. They have really kept to the original Victorian Era. We can't wait to go back. read more

Very good and fun place. Food is excellent in a historic district. Fresh good food served by efficient help. Unique dining experience and a great place to take visitors. read more

My husband and I had lunched here today and were greatly impressed by the value, quality, and service. The food was delicious and so worth what we paid for it. The dessert trio that came with lunch was amazing. Beautiful atmosphere in a nicely-decorated Victorian mansion. Certainly worth a visit! read more

Absolutely the best place to eat in town. Great food, atmosphere, and overall dining experience! Highly recommend their soups and desserts.

Totally unique fine-dining experience. Food is fresh, healthy, and delicious. Highly recommend the salmon and sweet potatoes. Reservations are necessary so plan in advance. Nothing like it in northwest Missouri. read more

This place has wonderful food & service. It's small but great as a fancy restaurant especially for a romantic setting or special occasion. Yum yum yum!! read more

I called because I wanted to treat a friend to dinner and do not live in St Joseph. They do not do gift cards, but were extremely accommodating and were still able to help me out. My friend said she had an amazing time there and the food was great! Everyone I spoke with on the phone was extremely friendly and helpful. read more