Very good food, decent prices, and good service.
The location is on top of a hill overlooking the gardens to the surrounding mountains and down to the town of Todos Santos. Great views - especially prior to sunset with the great colors in the evening sky. And unlike places with ocean views at sunset, when the sun goes down you see the lights of the town (vs just a dark ocean). You drive up the typical dirt road, park it the dirt parking lot, walk up the path up a slight hill to get to the restaurant. So dont wear your evening finest ;).
Having read glowing reviews when they first opened last year and getting a "you must absolutely go" from our VRBO host, we skipped one of our favorite places on this trip and hit Il Giardino. Our timing was right because we just beat the rush that required others to wait for a table.
The specialty is Italian, so I would stick with that. The menu is small, but large enough to please anyone. They also have a few daily specials listed on a chalkboard - including a cocktail of the day.
We ordered a couple of cocktails - I got the special cocktail of the day, a Matcha Martini. It was quite good. We ordered a bottle of wine for our dinner - figuring we would drink half and take the rest back with us. Salad and entrees followed. Again, all very good.
During Covid I think they take mostly solid precautions but could improve - more in the Covid summary below.
So why 4 stars vs 5 - basically 3 reasons:
- service was haphazard - for example, we had to ask for water 3 times before getting it. There seem to be confusion regarding who was doing what.
- tables were not spread out much for Covid. It is a small place, so they have limited options, but it was interesting having a table basically right behind me.
- after all the glowing reviews, I guess I expected a little more. So while I enjoyed our experience there, it didn't live up to the buildup.
Will we return? Definitely. The food and view make it worthwhile. It is my favorite Italian in the Todos area? Not quite, that would be Romantica. But it is near the top of the list.
COVID-19 OUTDOOR DINING SUMMARY
All dining here is completely outdoors - basically a roof over our heads and wide open on 3.5 sides. They check temperature at the hostess stand as well as request that you use hand sanitizer. They also have a wet pad area to step on before coming in. All staff wears masks and you must wear a mask when entering.
That said, the tables are a little close together for Covid times, they need to improve that. Also, everyone (and I mean everyone) removed their masks, often before they even sat down. And finally, those waiting for a table sort of gather at the hostess stand (which is across the path from one of the tables) or along the path from the parking area.
COVID-19 Safety Precautions
- Staff all wearing masks and gloves
- All dining is outside
- Customer temperature check before being seated
- Customers requested to wear masks to enter and requested to when ordering (though few did)
- Hand sanitizer use required when entering
- Wet mat to step on before entering main dining area
- Take-away service available
In summary, very nice Italian food with a great view. Would we return? Definitely yes, but might wait until I get the Covid vaccine.
PS, I am pretty sure John O (12/29 review) was there the night we were there - I believe he was sitting at the table behind me. read more