This little store packs a punch! The service is outstanding and their selection is amazing for the…read moresize of the store. I always buy my liquor here. They also give discounts for cash and buying beer and wine warm vs. chilled. Go there. You won't be disappointed!

GREAT little store! Staff is as helpful or out-of-the-way as you need them to be. They have…read morepacked a pretty impressive selection into that small space, and I have always found what I need! Definitely check out the "sales" table just to the right when you walk in the door - some great bargains can sometimes be found there! Prices are always spot-on.

Worth my 40 minute drive just for their beer selection!!! Holy walk-in cooler Batman! Now it's…read morenot as sweet as your bigger city liquor stores but for the area this place is top notch! Some VERY VERY cool microbrews that I haven't seen in a long time including some new ones that I bought far too many of! My new favorite is the Orange Ginerbeer (alcoholic). SO YUM!! They also carry Deep Eddy vodkas which I haven't seen anywhere. The proprietors are incredibly friendly and helpful and make it a great experience while you're there. Completely worth your time if you're within an hour driving distance...just make sure you bring enough $$ because you'll end up spending more than you think!!

Only place I shop in the area for adult beverages! Great selection & service. Absolutely love the…read moretasting table selections.

Owned by Kroger; a very small, scaled down version of Kroger. Even carry a lot of Kroger brand…read moreproducts; ads are the same. But as I said, it's a SCALED DOWN version. Very small town. I would think, with 2 large resorts in the area they could grow this place. Anyhoo, they had what we needed. Priced comprable.

If you are coming in and enjoying the resorts, this might be the only place you'll find vegetables…read morebecause the resort restaurants, as well as restaurants in the towns, are not big fans of vegetables. This store is owned by Kroger so expect to find a slightly scaled down Kroger. I did try a donut out and it tastes like every other grocery store donut. Nothing bad but nothing to write home about. Come here if you need something from the grocery. No hard liquor is sold as the store doesn't have a pharmacy. You'll need to go to CVS, the nearby Big Red, or the winery/distillery, all of which are pretty close to this store.

This place is amazing. Seems small but they have a Lot of specialty liquors and beers. No food of…read morecourse. Rob is always helpful and fun to talk to. Inside is small but not too crowded. Worth checking out !

Santa Claus, Indiana. Home of Holiday World, Splashin' Safari, Lake Rudolph, a sleighful of…read moreChristmas-themed stores and... one of the best liquor stores in the state?! It's more likely than you'd think! Old Tyme Liquors is fairly small but packs a remarkable variety within its walls, and no matter what your vice is, you won't be hurting for options. The craft beer coolers deserve particular attention, because they house some rarities that are downright shocking to find in this region. My favorite find was Lazy Magnolia's Southern Pecan Ale. This terrific brown ale from Kiln, MS tends to be rarer than hen's teeth in Kentuckiana, and I've only caught it on draft a couple times. To see it casually hanging out in one of Old Tyme's coolers was a real treat. Other notable names on deck here include Lil Beaver (Bloomington, IL), Voodoo Brewing Co. (Meadville, PA), Rochester Mills (Rochester, MI), Fair State Co-op (Minneapolis, MN) and of course, plenty of standout breweries from across Indiana. Seriously, this place is a slice of heaven if you're looking for craft beer from far-flung parts of the country. And for everything else, they keep the prices reasonable and the shelves stocked. Damn, it feels good to be a Hoosier.