Cancel

    Open app

    Search

    Forgotten Treasures

    4.0 (1 review)
    Closed 10:00 am - 2:00 pm

    Forgotten Treasures Photos

    You might also consider

    Recommended Reviews - Forgotten Treasures

    Your trust is our priority, so businesses can't pay to alter or remove their reviews. Learn more about reviews.
    Yelp app icon
    Browse more easily on the app
    Review Feed Illustration

    2 years ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    Ask the Community - Forgotten Treasures

    You might also consider

    Verify this business for free

    People searched for Thrift Stores 982 times last month within 15 miles of this business.

    Verify this business

    Goodwill Store and Donation Center

    Goodwill Store and Donation Center

    3.0
    (8 reviews)
    3.4 mi
    $

    It was a rainy day here in Oconomowoc, and we were looking for something to do. We noticed this…read moreGoodwill Store and decided to check it out. We like supporting Goodwill, as purchases and donations there fund job training for persons with disabilities and disadvantages. We're also trying, though not always successfully, to be more minimalist and to buy more used for environmental reasons. The store is large, organized, well-lit, and most of the prices are quite good. There are many fitting rooms, and clean restrooms. My husband and I each had some "finds" in this store. For my husband, his best purchase was a Kelty self-inflating sleeping pad. We're doing some camping, and his current pad had developed a leak in the valve casing which he hasn't been able to fix yet. The pad at Goodwill was marked $12.99 but, because it was a "yellow tag", it was marked down 50% to $6.50. He also picked up two name-brand (LL Bean; Nike) hoodies ($9.99 each) and exercise pants ($6.99). All are in great condition. As for me, my best finds were in the hiking shoes category. I found two pairs of name-brand (Keen, Clarks) shoes in great condition, and at great prices ($14.99 and $6.99, respectively). I also picked up a hiking shirt ($2.99, yellow tag) and some office supplies. Check-out was a breeze, with a very friendly cashier. He told us about special promotions. (May, 2023). If you join their points program, you earn 1 point for every dollar spent. 100 points gets you a $5 off coupon. There are mark-down days for Veterans on Tuesdays and Seniors 60+ on Wednesdays. There are also discounts on one's birthday. We also noted many staff on the floor -- putting out new items and arranging shelves. Great job, Goodwill!

    This was the worst Goodwill I've ever been to. They have a special Senior day at the Waukesha…read moreGoodwill - but not at this one! Plus, I dropped off some really nice things and I got a gruff guy that came out of the door and grabbed my bag and didn't even get a thank you- forget the receipt question! I get a bad feeling from this place. Merchandise on the racks is so overpriced. It's disgusting

    Photos
    Here is the Squishmallo kitty I got

    See all

    Here is the Squishmallo kitty I got
    281 Sheridan Springs

    281 Sheridan Springs

    3.4
    (19 reviews)
    35.9 mi

    New FRED G. IS SCAM ARTIST, SCUMBAG. He charged me to pick…read moreup and clear out my home BUT DIDN'T FINISH THE JOB HE PROMISED. Fred left about 1/3 of the furniture and told me they could come back another day but I'd have to PAY for his FUEL round trip...AGAIN. (Cost of Gas was NOT mentioned in Freds phoney sales pitch) Fred also claimed I would receive an itemized list, AND BE PAID WHEN MY ITEMS SELL. THIS DID NOT HAPPEN. Fred never got me legitimate receipts for tax purposes. NEVER heard from FRED G. again on any consignment items. Fred didn't return texts or calls. Fred G. steals from vulnerable clients. I've read customer reviews... same experiences and complaints about Fred G. and his SCAM resale shop.

    Read other reviews... And Fred's ridiculous responses, that only back up complaints that many have…read more I've got a review below. In short My family estate was 920 Geneva st. in Lake Geneva... We let Fred's team into our home because he promised: Photographic inventory of the items we trusted him to take without us there..... we got nothing. He ignored emails from my sister and myself for months. He promised monthly checks as well.... after months of no responses from Fred, my sister asked me to go in to his shop. I did. Fred bumbled around came up with a bunch of bizarre excuses. Including saying my sister said to only work with her... she is the one who sent me there to confront him as to what stuff he took, and why he hadn't paid or communicated in months. He tried to bizarrely blame her. Anyways. Read other reviews and his attempted brags in his responses about how many clients he's had... which just support all the other reviewers stating how he ripped them off during tough family times. He's also been trying to get a review I left removed... Yelp admin... if you ever need receipts for any of these facts Fred tries to get taken down, feel free to contact me.

    Photos
    Looking for unique home furnishings and decor..this is the place!!
    Looking for unique home furnishings and decor..this is the place!!
    Designer dining set..table,chairs,buffet,mirror
    Designer dining set..table,chairs,buffet,mirror
    Why yes, we did buy a giant tiki idol for $250

    See all

    Why yes, we did buy a giant tiki idol for $250

    Forgotten Treasures - thrift_stores - Updated August 2026

    Loading...
    Loading...
    Loading...