My husband is hard to fit. They have a great collection of quality shoes from work to play in all…read moresizes. The service was amazing and we walked out with 3 pairs of the shoes that he needed. Worth the trip.

The store has an extremely large selection of shoes and the staff is incredibly knowledgeable…read more Tony helped me find the perfect size and style of waterproof sneaker that I was looking for and insured that my feet were comfortable, despite having plantar fasciitis and wide feet.

Great shoe store and Lindsay was incredibly patient and helpful. I ended up with just what I…read morewanted. Thank you Lindsay!

My favorite shoe store by far! Anna is an amazing…read moresaleswoman. I've never had anyone offer to bring me "all the available white sneakers in my size" until today.

I have the most awful feet! Pegasus has the an amazing selection of footwear!!! And the sales…read moreassociates are so knowledgable and helpful! Annie was so incredible and showed me fall shoes that would fit my feet best. I can't wait until I am able to put my new Taos' mary janes on!!!

Good selection of stylish and comfy shoes. Friendly and knowledgeable staff. Especially Annie. She…read morewas so kind, patient and helpful. Always stop here when we're in town!

This is the best thrift shop in the entire catskill/Hudson Valley area. They have the greatest…read moreselection of every kind of goods you can imagine. They have artwork and antiques that are beyond belief. There is nothing that even looks used. About half of the clothing is absolutely brand new/unused and the remainder looks brand new. Someone told me that they cull thru the donations and only keep the absolute best of the best. This is a new location which is larger than the old one and located in the center of Margaretville in a beautiful old building which is the cornerstone of the Village. They have frequent "Bag Sales" where you can fill a bag for a fixed price and also regular "2 for 1 sales". Many NYC visitors make sure they come to the Margaretville Thrift shop because of the quality and low prices.

Too expensive with unfriendly staff . Do not recommend. Low quality items with exorbitant pricesread more

You missed a sale from me yesterday. I almost had another purchase on a pair of sandals, but…read moredecided to check out the remainder of the sandal market at other stores instead, and then when you combine that with no employees in your store (or making an appearance near the center registers), I decided I'd leave things alone and try elsewhere. Sorry. I mean, you're men's sandal selection was tiny. Those that I did decide were okay were pricey, and those that were cheaper were a little too cheap and of such poor quality and make/brand that I didn't want to research further. (If I don't recognize a brand name, it's doubtful I'll ever try them on, and with this one name near the sandals I found for 49.99, I didn't want to research it further.)

i would love to say amazing things, however it was a preverbal ghost town. it looked like a scene…read moreright out of a zombie apocalypse movie. im praying it was only a reault of covid, that it seemed so frozen....

This has got to be the worst run mall. Several stores not open during business hours. The parking…read morelot is absolutely a disgrace with debris and potholes. Limited low quality restaurants.

This is a tough review to write because as a mall, this one is rather small and there's not a lot…read moregoing on; but there is not a lot of population in this area to financially support a huge shopping mecca that you'd maybe find in Albany, Syracuse, Kingston, or even Binghamton. So you have to set your expectations correctly. Within 20 miles or more, there's really nothing else like a mall. Some of the stores are going to be a bit weird, or will go out of business after a few months, or whatever. As it is, this mall served its purpose; something for us to do for an hour or so to kill some time when it was raining. There was a book store that was not bad, and a foreign market which had some unique foods. If I lived in the area, I'm sure I'd be dropping the kids off here to run around and hang out for a while.

I just treated myself to these garden clogs, they are perfect! I love that they came from Windham,…read moreNY! I grew up in the Catskills and l love to support local businesses. I hope to visit their shop in the future!

I took my goddaughter here today for her very first thrift store experience. We were both thrilled!…read more She is now hooked on thrift store shopping. It is clean, well displayed, good variety, great prices and friendly staff.

The elderly woman with purple hair who works on the weekends isn't just mean, she's downright…read morehostile. They have a large glass front area with doors and a door around the side. I saw her opening the side door so politely asked if I should go in through the side or front and she exasperatedly said "the side is the ONLY way you can come in" - um ok sorry I do not magically know your community center thrift store layout. After that she did not speak, only glared at me as I uncomfortably took a minute to look around. I passed her as I was leaving and she full on heavily sighed at me for zero reason. Pretty sure this is a volunteer job so if she hates humans so much maybe she should just spend her retirement reading self help books trying to find some shred of happiness as she's clearly a miserable person to treat potential customers so terribly. Two stars only b/c I bought several items a few years ago from an incredibly nice woman. Bring her back! Either way, I will not return.

Sign says they are open 10 to 4 on a Sunday August 6 2017. It's 1pm and they are closed with no…read moreexplanation. I can see why the locals say this place has changed management and names multiple times. Horrible business practice.

If I could give less than 1 Star I would. I went there today to get my daughter school sneakers. It…read morewas all dark and locked up with a sign on the door that had a little clock on it (for when you would go to lunch or something) it said they would be back at noon,problem was it was almost 1! Decided to go get lunch thinking maybe the sign meant 1:pm I went back and the sign was still there. VERY disappointing so I ended up having to go to Middletown! On the plus side the shoe store we went to was not only open but very friendly service,great selection and I was more than happy to spend my money there! That's where we will go from now on.