Cancel

    Open app

    Search

    Fergie's Pizza

    4.0 (2 reviews)
    ModeratePizza
    Closed 4:00 pm - 9:00 PM

    Fergie's Pizza Photos

    You might also consider

    Recommended Reviews - Fergie's Pizza

    Your trust is our priority, so businesses can't pay to alter or remove their reviews. Learn more about reviews.
    Yelp app icon
    Browse more easily on the app
    Review Feed Illustration

    9 years ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    10 years ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    Verify this business for free

    Get access to customer & competitor insights.

    Verify this business

    Me Too Pizza - A modified pizza made by Me Too Pizza

    Me Too Pizza

    3.2(5 reviews)
    43.5 mi

    For some reason (only known to the people of Williston/Culberston) they have a compulsion to jumble…read morethe sequence of making of a pizza. I don't know what school of thought you may come from (when it comes to Pizzas), but I usually am a Base, Mariana, Cheese, toppings, then herbs person. This place is one of the few eateries in Culberston, that also means they can do as they please. I had experienced 2 pizzas at Me Too Pizza before begrudgingly ordering a third. They were prepared in the following manner. 1: Base 2: Something resembling Tomato Sauce 3: Toppings 4: Cheese (not sure what type). That means, the toppings were buried, under-cooked, mushy, and would fall off the base burning your lips/chin. I decided that if was going to pay for another pizza from this place, it was going to be made how I expected it to be made. As you can expect, Telling someone their product is not how you want it is not something that they want to hear. When I mentioned how I expected it to be made, and also how they were making such pizza faux pas (that lead to a burnt chin aspect) the girl serving me at the business replied "but that's how we make them". It was at that moment that I realized I had bitten off more than I could chew, even before it entered the oven. When I returned to pick it up my modified pizza, the owner just dropped the box of said pizza on the counter returning back to the kitchen without sating a word. Then when I opened the box it to look at my order, he aggressively rushed out exclaiming "Is there a problem with it?!!!!!" Before leaving Culberston, I shared my story with another local, and they mentioned the owner takes exceptions to being told how to prepare his own product. If you want your pizza made your way or modify the preparation, it can be done, it will just take some effort. But if you are a fan of backwards pizzas, then you will be happy. By the way, I posted a photo on here showing the results, and with extra garlic, was the best pizza I had in Montana.

    Good pizza. Alas, no beer. It's not like you have lots of choices in Culbertson, Montana. So I was…read morereally pleasantly surprised.

    Sherman Inn Restaurant - Dining room serving breakfast, lunch and dinner Monday through Friday

    Sherman Inn Restaurant

    3.1(9 reviews)
    68.2 mi

    You know how some restaurants seem to have a handful of older, bad reviews that don't match up with…read moretheir current reputation? That's what I found when I looked up this place. The only negative reviews I could find were from over seven years ago, and they're completely out of sync with the experience I had. I first visited for breakfast, and it was incredible. I'm a bit of a bacon connoisseur, and the bacon here was easily the best I've had in a long time. It was perfectly crispy and flavorful without being greasy. I was so impressed that I came back for dinner. I had the ribeye special, and it was amazing. The steak was cooked perfectly to my order, a beautiful medium rare, and every bite was tender and delicious. It came with a baked potato that was fluffy on the inside, and loaded with all the fixings. The service was top-notch as well, with the staff being attentive and friendly throughout the entire meal. This restaurant is clearly doing something right and has been for a while. Don't let those old reviews fool you--the Sherman Inn Restaurant is a must-try.

    Ate here 4 times during a stay at the hotel. They've got a pretty audacious selection of specials…read moreconsidering they can't seem to keep most things in stock. Food I ate was great though. Really good fried chicken. Their side broccoli is dreadful but this is America let's be real no one cares about that. Reasonable prices and huge servings.

    Photos
    Sherman Inn Restaurant
    Sherman Inn Restaurant
    Sherman Inn Restaurant - Try your luck in our lounge! Full menu available during restaurant hours, pizza available after restaurant closes.

    See all

    Try your luck in our lounge! Full menu available during restaurant hours, pizza available after restaurant closes.

    Fergie's Pizza - pizza - Updated May 2026

    Loading...
    Loading...
    Loading...