Cancel

    Open app

    Search

    Fat Sally's Cakes

    5.0 (4 reviews)

    Fat Sally's Cakes Photos

    You might also consider

    Recommended Reviews - Fat Sally's Cakes

    Your trust is our priority, so businesses can't pay to alter or remove their reviews. Learn more about reviews.
    Yelp app icon
    Browse more easily on the app
    Review Feed Illustration

    1 year ago

    The cake and cookies were amazing! My 80 year old mother really enjoyed her birthday cake!

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    7 years ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    7 years ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    7 years ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    Ask the Community - Fat Sally's Cakes

    Verify this business for free

    Get access to customer & competitor insights.

    Verify this business

    Persnikkitys Sweet Confections

    Persnikkitys Sweet Confections

    4.4
    (23 reviews)
    4.9 km

    We got boba and one of each available cupcake to sample for my friend's wedding this fall…read more The tapioca pearls in the boba were the worst I've ever had. I saw them sitting out on the counter and didn't know that was an issue till I looked it up later. They are apparently not supposed to sit out at all. No wonder they tasted so weird. The matcha powder was not good quality either. We tried the chocolate, german chocolate, lemon, birthday cake, strawberry, and black forest cupcakes. The cupcakes were very underwhelming for a professional bakery. Some of the cake was clearly from a box and very dry. The buttercream wasn't very good and wasn't consistent across cakes. Some were grainy and others had a waxy texture. Some, if not all, of the filling was definitely out of a jar or store bought, especially the cherry filling in the black forest. The filling was also very minimal. The communication was also very concerning and scared us away from considering them for an event as important as a wedding. We attempted to email and submitted an info request but got no response at all. We had to call on two seperate occasions to get someone on the phone and when we did the person clearly did not know enough about the bakery itself to help get us information. Would not recommend at all.

    Amazing Food !!! Great cafe Great friendly service and the food was Amazing !!…read more Philly cheese steak and Chicken almond salad were absolutely perfection!! Clean tables and restaurant area !! Service with a smile !!

    Photos
    Samoa cupcake and chocolate chip pecan cookie
    Samoa cupcake and chocolate chip pecan cookie
    Assorted cupcakes
    Assorted cupcakes
    Lemon Bar $4, Red Velvet Cookie $3, Cannoli $3 - All were delicious!

    See all

    Lemon Bar $4, Red Velvet Cookie $3, Cannoli $3 - All were delicious!
    PersNIKKIty's Cafe

    PersNIKKIty's Cafe

    4.4
    (490 reviews)
    1.1 km
    $$

    This place was great! So great, we went twice in one day…read more We came right at openings for breakfast and the clean, bright space and fun menu made us optimistic. I had the Holla Tots -- tater tots with ham, bacon, egg, and hollandaise. Delicious! I also ordered a Mangonada Mimosa which was so fun. We ended up coming back for lunch where I shared the turkey club and a BLT. It was packed at lunch but somehow still easy to find a spot to sit. This place has food and drink options to suit a lot of tastes, great staff, and plenty of seating in a cute space. The attention to detail is clear from the fun food and drink names to the decor (especially the bathroom) and the 3 or 4 kinds of ketchup. I wish they had one near me!

    "Persnikkity's Food Offers a Lot: Hits the Hungry Spot"…read more Walking into Persnikkity in Show Low (which I have done many times from their old location to their new one), you immediately feel like you've stumbled onto something the town's been keeping to itself. The place has that lived-in charm where locals know each other's orders, and the staff treats you like you're part of the club from minute one. I've made the Asian chicken wrap and twisted beef Philly my reliable go-tos--they nail that balance of fresh and hearty that keeps pulling me back. The morning totchos are a brilliant mess of everything breakfast should be, the chicken and waffle hits that sweet-savory note without trying too hard, and even their bagel with salmon comes out like they actually care about it. The vanilla matcha bubble tea deserves its own mention because it tastes like someone put thought into it rather than just dumping powder into a cup. Service here makes the food taste even better--attentive without hovering, friendly without being fake. The vibe is casual enough that you can show up in whatever you're wearing, but the food quality makes it clear they're taking things seriously where it counts. It's the kind of spot where you find yourself coming back not just for one signature dish, but because the whole experience just works.​​​​​​​​​​​​​​​​

    Photos
    The service counter with menu items, coffee and drink station to the left.
    The service counter with menu items, coffee and drink station to the left.
    Mac and cheese was the best we have had off a kids menu
    Mac and cheese was the best we have had off a kids menu
    Interior view

    See all

    Interior view
    Twisted Sugar Show Low

    Twisted Sugar Show Low

    3.4
    (5 reviews)
    5.8 km

    Delicious cookies worth stopping for! My sister had wanted to pop in and with most dessert shops I…read moreusually over look. Not always my thing. I was WRONG. These cookies are unique. My favorite was the Swizzle. I squirted the lime that came with it onto the cookie and it was deliciously tangy, my favorite cookie so far of any place. All the cookies are SOFT. We ordered a classic chocolate chip, sprinkle, & fruity pebbles. All were so wonderfully perfect. I loved the frosting, especially on the sprinkle one. Looking forward to coming back for a box when we visit Pinetop again!

    "The ultimate destination for those who crave extraordinary treats!" as claimed by Twisted Sugar…read more You'll never be disappointed when your sweet tooth is craving for something sweet. Twisted Sugar's cookies are not just soft and chewy but also bursting with flavors. I heard about Twisted Sugar from a colleague and decided to give it a try. They have so many different cookie flavors to choose from. They offer fancy gourmet cookies, tasty mixed sodas, and delicious ice cream twisters. When I went there, I picked up a box of assorted cookie flavors: Mint Madness, Cookies and Cream, Twisted, Swizzle, Crinkle, and Salted Caramel. They even have a special "cookie of the month." The staff at the counter were really helpful in recommending their best sellers, and they also have gluten-free options. The shop is cutely decorated and has a cool vibe. There's a fun twist when you buy. They have a basketball ring where you get three tries to shoot the ball. Each successful shot earns you a free cookie or drink. There were some high school kids trying their luck, and one boy was really lucky that day. Twisted Sugar started in Utah and has expanded to different states. They also have other six locations here in Arizona. They also offer franchise opportunities. It was a nice treat, and I enjoyed every bite of their delicious cookies. I'll surely be back to try their twisted sodas and ice cream.

    Photos
    Cub Lake Rd
    Cub Lake Rd
    Twisted Sugar Show Low
    Twisted Sugar Show Low

    See all

    Fat Sally's Cakes - customcakes - Updated August 2026

    Loading...
    Loading...
    Loading...