Cancel

    Open app

    Search

    Criterion Properties

    5.0 (1 review)
    Closed 9:00 am - 5:00 pm

    Get a quote

    Response time

    4 hours

    Response rate

    100%

    Services - Criterion Properties

    Property management

    Criterion Properties Photos

    You might also consider

    Recommended Reviews - Criterion Properties

    Your trust is our priority, so businesses can't pay to alter or remove their reviews. Learn more about reviews.
    Yelp app icon
    Browse more easily on the app
    Review Feed Illustration

    8 months ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    Ask the Community - Criterion Properties

    Costello Property Management

    Costello Property Management

    (9 reviews)

    I've been living at costello apartments in eagle butte, SD for almost 8 years now, its not the best…read morebut its home for me and my little family. The maintenance is very poor, ive been the one fixing my own issues, Two years ago we got a new manager Leslie Oakie and besides from not having a diploma, she's crooked. Treats tenants like they are scum, very unprofessional and have a few people that witnessed her embezzling. Me for instance, I haven't worked since march 2023 and shes been charging me $1003 a month in rent, now shes claiming i owe over 80,000 in back rent, which is RIDICULOUS. How is that legit to be charging someone that much in rent WITHOUT A JOB. Ive been compliant and done the things i had to, its her that lies, never brings the appropriate paperwork and accusing me of having this large rent bill. Now shes trying to force me to leave by monday. I have no where to go, my son just turned 9 two days ago and hes in middle school. Can somebody anybody please point me in the right direction? Or have any quick advice?

    If you are thinking about moving into a Costello Apartment, DON"T! You will regret it. They are…read moreHORRIBLE!! Worst property manager ever is CARLA LLOYD!! Rude, unprofessional, hostile, prejudice, and a liar! They don't give her any reprimands or infractions (like tenants get) even though there is audio and video of it. If I could of given a minus rating I would have! Save yourself the aggravation and find somewhere else. I regret moving into a Costello Property.

    Alpine Property Management

    Alpine Property Management

    (6 reviews)

    Just a bizarre experience. Met for a few walk throughs, decided on a property I liked and then got…read morecompletely ghosted by everyone despite multiple attempts to reach out. I was in a time crunch so wasting my time was certainly not appreciated. I did end up finding a brand new, nicer place with more space for a way better price but they certainly didn't aide in anyway to an already complicated situation.

    Scam Company, Avoid they will try to make you pay to renovate a property you rented…read more June 2022 had rented a property via apartments.com, half way through the lease the landlord switch from apartments.com over to Alpine Property. Alpine after taking management of the property did not conduct an inspection (as noted by multiple employees saying there is none). There were multiple maintenance requests put in that went unfulfilled or fell on myself (tenant) to handle. There was a severe leak in the bathroom that continued for months as plumbers were called in, with no solution found. Eventually I had to suggest looking at the possibility of a roof leak (most water came in after warm days after a snow) to which finally his was taken care of. Upon move in there was no handle on the fridge that stayed that way until leaving. The house was noted from the landlord as not in perfect condition, and had various flaws; commenting this was "the charm of the place". Before moving out I called the Alpine office stating that I was moving and if I needed to do anything further, as well as if they had any other properties available. I was told no. This was 3 months prior to move out. As move out closed in I contacted them again for their checklist and I was then informed I did not tell them I was moving out, I let them know I did, and who I talked to. I was told that that person didn't know better and it's my fault. I also told them about the various issues with the place upon move in and how the owner can confirm this, to which she did. When receiving the deposit disposition they disregarded all of the information on prior damages and blamed me for them, eventually some items were removed but many were left on even though the owner states they were like that. I also hired a professional cleaning service for the move out to which this was apparently not good enough for Alpine (it was spotless) and they comment it was $150 to wipe behind oven and microwave. I was also charged prorated rent for their employee not telling me proper move out notification procedure.

    Criterion Properties - propertymgmt - Updated May 2026

    Loading...
    Loading...
    Loading...