Well-designed beer garden in which to spend a warm, sunny day, complete with big table umbrellas so that you're not sitting entirely in the sun. Plus an indoor sports bar, an indoor eating area if you can't get a seat outside or if it's too cold, another indoor bar at which they have live music on weekend evenings, and a good-sized live music venue that isn't used much any more but in its day hosted bands whose names you'd know, before most people knew them.
The food they serve is pretty much all designed to go well with alcohol (no surprise here). They offer pub standards like schnitzel and steak, along with burgers and other grilled sangas, fish and chips, other seafood and random salads and sides. Their blackboard specials tend to be delicious. The grilled scampi recently added to the menu during an apparent push to upscale their offerings is to die for, though not inexpensive. They also have some creative pizza options worth a go, although the crust itself is pretty average. Like most establishments in the area, you'd be hard-pressed to find a bargain on food here, although the Monday night 2-for-1 on selected traditional pub menu items gets you closer to a deal.
On a nice day, you might find some surfboards or paddle boards propped against the wall at the entrance, their rightful owners just on the other side of the alcohol service boundary. How much more "beach" can you get, than that? Last summer, there was a tiki bar set up where they served tropical cocktails, near the outdoor dining area.
NSW laws apply, so there's no smoking in food service areas, even outdoors, and the beer garden features numerous signs to remind you of that so that ignorance of the rule isn't an excuse. However, the bar area at the far southern end of the beer garden does have a clearly marked smoking area, so if you have to "duck out", it's not far. (But still far enough away that those of us who'd rather not join in, get clean air.)
Pro tips, other than the obvious Monday 2-for-1 meal deal:
(1) If the bar you're in doesn't offer a particular beer on tap, check the other bars in the hotel, as they feature different ones.
(2) If you're a visitor coming from the city for dinner and drinks/music later, the 373 bus runs all night (no stupid Nightride milk run route hassles here!), and the pub is open until 6am on the weekends in the sports bar, and usually until 1am-3am depending on crowds in the beach bar that features live music on the weekends. It drops off right at the entrance to the hotel, and picks up on the other side of the street, north a bit. Follow Plan B from the start and take the bus to and from, so that you don't require a designated driver. The bus only runs every hour in the wee hours of the morning, so check the schedule before you go in so that you can pick a reasonable time to end your evening.
(3) They have other random deals from time to time. Right now, there's a pizza and Coopers deal for $25, for example.
(4) I'm not sure if this is well-advertised, but you can get food for takeaway if you don't have time to enjoy the atmosphere.
Between local regulars and travellers with interesting stories to tell, there are plenty of people to just hang out and enjoy a beer with, if you're in the area by yourself. If you're female, don't pay too much attention to the pre-2014 reviews. The Bay used to be a pretty rough place, but it's gentrified considerably in the past couple years. I've gone there dozens of times by myself and never had a problem. Before I moved to Coogee, I would regularly weekend here, getting a pub room for a night so that I could have dinner, stay up late listening to music and then enjoy breakfast back in the brasserie in the morning. Patrons tend to be polite. Blokes will probably try to chat you up, but if you're not interested, they move along quickly enough. Fair warning: You can get into conversations interesting enough that by the time they're all done shouting you and you them, it's well after midnight on a work night.
Yes, the Coogee Bay is old school enough that it offers accom. The pub rooms aren't flash, and you have to climb stairs to get to them, but every one has its own ensuite, which is something you can't say about most pub rooms I've stayed in. (There is also deluxe accom, which is more like a typical 4* ... I'd put the pub rooms at 2.5 or so, although as a lover of vintage I'm tempted to give an extra .5 for the (presumably non-working?) motel side tables with built in radios (from the 60's? ... the CBH used to look like a drive-up roadside beach motel with a bar in its pre-beer garden days) in some of the rooms -- parents, show your kids (or grandkids) what roadside motel rooms USED to look like, as these haven't changed all that much! ;-) read more