The Appraiser did not do a good job at all on my client's Appraisal. Shorted me, $135,000 on a New…read moreBuild Home. He came out to Appraiser a Dirt Lot, using a Plan, Design Addendums and Cost to Build Budget Form required by the Lender. This was a New Construction Home in Sussex County, and he unfortunately disregarded information provided to him prior to the Appraisal that he would need to complete his Appraisal, and then formally documented in the report "He had no idea the cost to build the home." This information was provided to him via email and paper trail to prove its conveyance. Not to mention it took him weeks to complete this VA Appraisal. He stated he could not use certain comps based on certain reasons documented in his report, and decided to take 3 and nearly Average the Price Per Sq.Ft. to get our average. How is it even possible that a New Construction Home today, cost "LESS" this year to build than last year? He valued this home at $47 Less Per Sq.Ft. this year than 1 Year ago, when the Builders built their last two homes and other builders are currently building as well. We also noticed, and figured out, that the Appraiser who took the Appraisal order was NOT the person who did the Site Visit, and was not the person who completed the Appraisal. David Hoffer of Hashem and Hoffer is the Appraiser who took the Appraisal Order from UWM, but we are certain Mendel Hoffer (son) came out to the site. He stated to the Builders "So how do you want me to do this?" (Showing he was unfamiliar with the VAOTC Appraisal Process. I have submitted a Complaint to DCA in New Jersey to address my concerns. I have also reviewed the two public Disciplinary Actions against this Appraiser from 2013 and 2021. Very interesting facts to read, and in fact I had this same Appraiser last year, and the very same thing that was an issue on his 2021 Disciplinary Action happened to my other Military Client in 2024. I am sharing both Appraisals with the Appraisal Board in NJ and DCA to address both concerns with this Appraiser. After reading these other reviews, it's quite concerning to see new training has resulted in the same actions again. Both of my issues are with Military (VA) Loans. Hopefully the state of New Jersey Appraisal Board will look in these Appraisals and address same with these two Appraisers. We did achieve $39,000 from the Veteran Affairs, and since this particular Buyer is putting $100,000 Down on a VA Loan, the deal can now work, HOWEVER, this is an unfair and inaccurate Appraisal Completed. We would have done a 2nd ROV with the VA and taken it up to Supervisory, but the Lender confirmed we will still have a Post Build Appraisal, so we will address that later should need be. But wow! These Appraisers need more training, ethics, and accuracy.