Cancel

    Open app

    Search

    Casey's

    3.5 (2 reviews)
    Open Open 24 hours

    Casey's Photos

    You might also consider

    Recommended Reviews - Casey's

    Your trust is our priority, so businesses can't pay to alter or remove their reviews. Learn more about reviews.
    Yelp app icon
    Browse more easily on the app
    Review Feed Illustration
    Photo of T T.
    0
    1
    0

    10 months ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    4 years ago

    Always out of everything! Out of all the Casey's stores in the Vigo county area this one needs the most improvement.

    Business owner information

    Photo of Casey G.

    Casey G.

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    Ask the Community - Casey's

    You might also consider

    Verify this business for free

    People searched for Pizza 506 times last month within 15 miles of this business.

    Verify this business

    Scout's Pizzaria - The menu QR from the Verve

    Scout's Pizzaria

    3.9(37 reviews)
    2.4 mi

    Scout's was recommended to us, so we took their word for it!…read more The service was sub-par, but I think it was a college student who did not have any experience in the food industry. I think with some more training and work on confidence, this could be improved. As a recommendation, I think having a photo of the apps would be helpful -- our table ordered the hay fries and were surprised that they were just a pizza cut differently. We would have ordered something else had we known. There is also a weird vibe at the restaurant -- I think the acoustics need some engineering because it felt a little off with how quiet it was. The soda also seemed off -- I think the syrup ratio was incorrect. The Dr. Pepper tasted like cherry cough syrup. It's also odd that all drinks come in super tiny cups -- water and sodas alike. Bringing pitchers of water to table would help. The pizza is okay -- not quite on par with Italian-style pizza though (I'm a lucky gal who has been to Napoli which is peak italian pizza). There are some bugs to work out -- I hope they can keep moving forward and implement some changes!

    Food was excellent! We got the haysticks appetizer which is essentially a pepperoni pizza cut into…read moresquares. The menu is all "personal" size pizzas. I couldn't tell if they were 12" or 14". I asked the server before ordering if the pizza were personal size or meant to be shared and she said they can feed 1-2 people. I completely agree with that assessment; had I not eaten so much of the appetizer I would have eaten all of the pizza. I'm a big guy with a big appetite, so I could see one pizza easily feeding two people and both of them being happy about it. Service was awesome, but one caveat. We were eating at noon on a Saturday and there wasn't anyone else there so we got as much attention as we wanted. It also meant our food came out really fast (on their menu they warn that the pizzas may take 30 minutes to come out and ours came out in about 10 minutes. Ambience was nothing special, probably because no one was there. I bet the vibe is pretty awesome when it's busier. We were able to park on the street outside, and I could see parking being an issue if the parking ramp close to the place isn't open. Would go here again and would recommend if ur in Terre Haute and looking for good non pizza chain pizza. My partner mentioned that her pizza was a bit "drippy," meaning she thought there was a bit more olive oil than it needed.

    Photos
    Scout's Pizzaria - Farmhouse Pizza

    Farmhouse Pizza

    Scout's Pizzaria - Outdoor Seating for Scout's and the Verve

    Outdoor Seating for Scout's and the Verve

    Scout's Pizzaria - Kitchen and the Woodfire oven

    See all

    Kitchen and the Woodfire oven

    Piloni's - Lasagna

    Piloni's

    4.4(279 reviews)
    4.4 mi
    $$

    Excellent! We have loved every item we've ordered. The lemon martini is one of my favs. The…read morecalamari is fresh and comes with homemade sauce. The shrimp, fettuccine, chicken parmesan and others items, never disappointed. We have also tried about 4 different desserts and each one was fabulous. They make their own noodles and the Parmesan cheese is shaved and mixed just right. This is family owned and the service is friendly. This is a must try if you are visiting your live here.

    I had been hearing about this restaurant since I first started working in Terre Haute so I finally…read moredecided to try it. It was good. I am writing about a delivery, so I can't comment on the restaurant itself. I took a star off because they did not provide any utensils or napkins in the delivery bag which made for a delayed meal since I had to go searching for a fork. The garden salad was very good. So crisp and fresh. The tomatoes were yummy, and I liked the surprise of celery amoungst the greens. The greens were mixed and not just iceberg which elevated the salad quite a bit. I always say I judge an Italian restaurant by their sauce, and this one was ok. Very sweet. Not thick. It wanted for something. I ordered the half portion of angel hair pasta, and it was still a very generous amount. I added a meatball which tasted more like an Italian sausage in a ball with a bit of spice and a chewier consistency. I wasn't mad at it, but it wasn't the seasoned ground beef crumble I expected. All in all, the meal was good, just lacking in some of things I expected from a place everyone seemed to like about it. I would probably go back and maybe try some of the other dishes next time I am in Terre Haute, if only to see if maybe it was just that order.

    Photos
    Piloni's - Intimate dining space.

    Intimate dining space.

    Piloni's
    Piloni's - Entrance to Piloni's

    See all

    Entrance to Piloni's

    Casey's - pizza - Updated August 2026

    Loading...
    Loading...
    Loading...