We happened to go on an evening that was super packed with a group event or something with kids sports, so it was a bit loud. However, they really are a neighborhood gem. We love the people and love the food. I love to move around the city and try different restaurants, but we also choose Cappy's when we want something close by or we feel like a great pizza. Yum read more

I picked up a takeout Pizza tonight for my Mom to surprise her. it was busy in there ..what a cute little place...I was greeted and my Pizza just came out hot and fresh ...I ordered it crispy and they did not disappoint..ordered a Cheese Pizza and and they were very generous with the cheese...will come back! read more

See all

Best pizza in Tampa. One of the few places you can get Chicago style. Now take credit cards with a small convenience fee. Parking can be tricky but worth it. read more

See all

Worst pizza I've ever had! The sauce tasted like nothing but tomatoes and the crust was dry and disgusting. We also ordered pepperoni, and it had none. Also thought deep dish pizza would be filled to the top, but this was half full! read more

Hands down my favorite go to pizza place, the NY style cheese pizza and bread is great!

Walked in at 7:18pm on a Sunday. Their hours state they close at 8 and the kitchen closes at 7:30. We actually knew exactly what we wanted to order but with 3 other tables in there, 2 with their pizzas already she said "we're out of everything until next week" and then walked away. Used to love this place. Never again... read more

YESSSS! BEST PIZZA EVER!!! divine perfection... my favorite pizza ever!!! 10/10. get the chicago style pizza and the cheese bread THEY FINALLY TAKE CREDIT CARDS!!! (according to facebook...). they only took cash for the longest time ever which was inconvenient but now they have made a great change it's so cute and awesome inside. i usually order for pickup by calling which is very easy and quick! they have a parking lot which is relatively small but i've never had a problem with parking. read more

Cappy's Pizzeria - inside - Pizza Near Me - Tampa, Florida

See all

We returned to Cappy's after a long hiatus. My son was interested in trying Chicago deep dish pizza, and Cappy's is the only place that offers it in south Tampa. I called ahead and ordered the pizza for a Tuesday night at 8PM. We arrived on time, and the parking lot was nearly empty. My food was packaged to go and piping hot. The thin crust pizza had been cut but the Chicago style pizza was not, which was preferable. I thought the thin crust pizza was fine, but the Chicago style pizza was quite good. I thought the crust was a little sweeter than I preferred, but I did love how buttery it was, and the sauce was so nice and tangy. Cappy's now takes credit card! There's a convenience fee, but that's becoming increasingly common, and I was just so delighted to not have to have cash on hand. read more

What a great pizza place! Awesome pizza. Cold AC. Very cool vibe. Nicole was great! We will be back.

I have heard so many people RAVE about this place and was so excited to try but was left so disappointed. I ordered a large cheese with caramelized onion, a small deep dish with pepperoni and 2 sides of ranch. They are cash only which they informed us over the phone but did not inform us of the price. The large cheese with caramelized onions was given to us with raw onions, would not of ordered raw onions on a pizza and was really disappointed at the taste. I'm not a fan of raw onions as is. The deep dish with pepperoni came with approximately 4 thin slices of pepperoni. To be paying almost $3 for a topping and get so few pepperoni slices that it wasn't till the 2nd slice that I got any at all is absurd. Two ranches were not included. No receipt was offered so I can't even see if we were charged. Total was $36. read more

Cappy's Pizzeria - Large cheese with RAW onions (ordered caramelized) - Pizza Near Me - Tampa, Florida

See all

Decent but not a Chicago deep dish. More of a thick crust. Burnt the edge though. Sauce is right. Taste is good. So not bad. read more

Cappy's Pizzeria - Large Thick, not deep dish. Sausage mushroom 1/2 green pepper - Pizza Near Me - Tampa, Florida

See all

This used to be such a good pizza joint. I just tried calling them right after opening time (5pm) and got hung up on seven times and got about forty busy signals over 20 minutes. So, we decided that I'd keep trying by phone and another member of our group would drive the fifteen minutes to place an order in person. When they got there the place was closed because of the July 4th weekend. So, closed 3-5 July. No way of knowing that. It wasn't on their website, wasn't on a phone message, nothing. And, what level of service does a pizza joint sink to to not be open on a Friday, Saturday or Sunday over a holiday weekend. Apparently business is so strong they feel they can shut down anytime they like. With no notice except a paper stuck in a window. Why business is so strong you got me. The place is a dump with little seating. Used to be their pizza was excellent. It's still very good, especially the crust. But, we'll never go back. read more

The ONLY reason I gave this place four stars (nothing to do with the food) is the parking and cash only. What a pain!!! The pizza is good! For deep dish, this is our go to place! It's cute inside. Can't comment on service, since we only get it to go! read more

I'm the only one in my family that likes deep dish pizza. This is the only deep dish I'll eat in Tampa. I grabbed this as carry out last weekend. This is the small deep dish Cappy's (their deluxe). It never disappoints. Tip- if you go on a Friday night, go slightly before they open. I was there at 4:40. It was ready in 25 mins just like they said. Note- if you've never been, it's a small place with not a lot of parking. And they only take cash. read more

See all

First time going but will definitely be back amazing salad to start and wine on tap. Followed by some killer pizza! Family joint but could also be fun with a group of friends or date night read more

Despite mixed reviews, I decided to give Cappy's a chance, and I'm glad I did! The pizza was delicious, perfectly balanced with cheese, veggies, and meat. The staff were incredibly friendly and welcoming. read more

Cappy's Pizzeria - The Cappy Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Tampa, Florida

See all

Good takeout with great salads. Excellent service but a tad pricey. If you are particular about parking, I would suggest opting for delivery. read more

Takeaways: IMO the best pizza in Tampa (might be biased since I prefer Chicago-style pizza), GET THE CHICAGO STYLE, friendly staff, super fun and retro atmosphere! Food: I'm probably going to lose a lot of credibility for saying this, but I've been to Chicago and I honestly think that Cappy's deep dish holds its own against some of the big names. The deep dish is AMAZING! I've never had anything other than the deep dish so I can't speak to the rest of the menu, but why would you get anything else here?? Service: The service is great! The people are very friendly and wonderful! Nothing special to say here. Ambiance: The ambiance is super fun! The restaurant is located in a cozy little old fashioned home with retro memorabilia littered all over the place! Perfect for families and friends! read more

Great pizza. Love it. Tastes good. Delicious. Great pizza. Great pizza. Need 85 words here so sorry for being repetitive.

No idea why people like this place. It has so much potential if they tried a bit. Get better cheese, better toppings, add some butter to the crust. For the place to be cash only, no Uber eats, it best be good, real good. Make some changes cappys and stop it with the crappy. read more

Food- Chicago Deep Pizza, Veggie (Not Olive Fan). I'm a huge pizza fan and by far this was delicious! You can tell the mushroom, green peppers and onions were sooooo freessshhhh! And the cheese --- its just chesse heaven! Service- Excellent, they didn't have cherry coke (which was kinda sad but life went on). I had water and the water was delicious! Florida water can taste weird at times but this place had good water! Overall, get this pizza worth it! 10/10 read more

Cappy's Pizzeria - Chicago Deep Dish Medium Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Tampa, Florida

My top pizza spot in South Tampa! I love this place! Super chill atmosphere, self-serve beer cooler and outstanding pizza. Hubby introduced me to Cappy's close to 10 years ago and it's been one of our staples ever since. They are cash only! So come prepared. Their parking lot is small but we've never had an issue finding a spot. You must order the Greek salad! They have the best Greek salad outside of a Greek restaurant. They only use the freshest ingredients in their salads. They also make their own delicious homemade Greek dressing! The potato salad is so good, hubby's absolute favorite. I love their Chicago style deep dish pizza. We usually keep it simple and order our deep dish with pepperoni. They use the large sandwich style pepperoni slices in their deep dish which I think is the best kind of pepperoni. The sauce on top is on the chunky side but perfectly tangy and sweet at the same time. The crust on their deep dish has a great crunch, it's buttery and truly amazing. Their deep dish is just as good leftover as well, whether eaten cold or reheated. Their New York style is slightly thicker than a traditional New York style. My fav toppings include: pepperoni, chicken and bacon. Always the right amount of sauce and cheese. You won't regret visiting Cappy's in South Tampa! read more

See all

Cappys was delicious! We had a party of 7 and got 3 pizzas and 2 salads. All were really good! We had both the deep dish and NY style and they were both impressive. The only negative in my opinion is that it was Pepsi and not coke drinks. Also it's cash only so be prepared. read more

Favorite pizza in town. Always consistent. Love the meat lovers well done. Remember- They only take cash!

Cappy's is the best Chicago style pizza in the Tampa Bay Area! Please expect to call 30-50 times to put an order in during high call volume periods. They are not answering and putting customers on hold as I experienced last Friday. It's just ringing busy. Once you do get through they have a great setup for pick up outside the restaurant and pie is hot and fresh. They use premium toppings and I have had a very consistent pie every time. Crust is sweet and crunchy with a mound of cheese followed by toppings and a chunky, sweet tomato sauce on top that brings it all together. The sauce has a great flavor and is definitely spiced appropriately with some garlic and oregano notes. If you are feeling like a salad their Greek salad is a family favorite and the dressing is so good they will sell you a bottle. read more

We love Cappy's! The owners and staff are always so friendly and polite. The food is amazing and never disappoints. Our go to is the Chicago deep dish and their amazing Greek salad. read more

Can't call to order pizza! Phone line is dead, doesn't answer, tried calling over 10 times.

If they tell you it's going to take an hour for pickup, you show up at an 1:15 and they still don't have a pie in the oven for you when you get there, that's BS. Guy standing next to me waiting was told 1/2 hour and it's been almost two and no pizza. If you can't set reasonable expectations and meet them, STOP TAKING ORDERS! read more

who sends food out like this? certainly not worth the pick up, cash, no parking requirements. read more

Cappy's Pizzeria - my calzone was burnt and had 3 pieces of pepperoni. breadsticks burnt too. - Pizza Near Me - Tampa, Florida

Had Cappy's pizza for the first time this past Saturday. The Gasparilla Kids parade event made it a little tough to get to the restaurant itself, but that is no fault of Cappy's (and hopefully the potential permanent lane closure on Bay to Bay will not happen anytime soon - or Cappy's is sure to suffer!). Normally I think it cool for cash-only restaurant, to exist in this modern day, but that would be a in a big city with a bustling population...not Tampa - where delivery and UberEats make all the more sense, especially on a day like Gasparilla. Nevertheless, my friend happened to be carrying enough cash and we were able to order a large New York style half cheese, half spinach pizza and order of garlic bread for under $20. Based on other reviews, you can also order a pie Chicago style, which is pretty cool given so few options offered at other pizza spots. The pizza we had was good - my friend enjoyed her half, and I enjoyed mine. We ended up placing our order for take-out, which worked just fine for our plans that evening. I got the feeling that the woman working behind the counter was expecting my friend to tip after receiving her change - but I half hope that I am wrong. In most take-out circumstances I compel my fellow diners to tip - but not in a cash only setting, where you don't offer the option of delivery and you don't allow people the choice in payment method. In this case, the service is all about the business, not the customer (IMHO). Given the obvious implications surrounding "cash only" transactions, I hope that a dine-in experience would elicit top-notch customer service (in which case a tip would indeed be appropriate). I've already told my family about how comparable Cappy's pizza was to true NY-style, so I am sure I'll dine in at some point to enjoy the full "NY pizza experience" :) read more

Cappy's Pizzeria - Large New York style half cheese /half spinach pizza! - Pizza Near Me - Tampa, Florida

See all

I've heard a few good things about Cappy's. It's a really small location they only take cash or check! They only take cash or check. It's pretty close to our apartment so we are excited for the proximity. Craving some dough pizza sauce and cheese we were stoked to give this one a go. There's enough parking for pick up it was an easy process 30 bucks for a small and a large pizza. We got a veggie large which was very yummy cooked pretty well too. The small cheese was fire. I loved it. Felt like an artesianal take on pizza. We didn't get the deep dish again we got the traditional hand tossed New York style. We also got the homemade ranch which was nice. Homemade is always better. Usually made with more love. We will definitely be back I'd be down to try a couple of the different flavors. Also the staff is super sweet literally a family, so friendly. read more

See all

We got take out and the staff was so friendly and welcoming! We got the Caesar salad and the Cappys deep dish pizza! It was all so so good! I would definitely recommend :) read more

I came here once a few months ago with my family, and it was great! Service was fast and friendly, and everyone enjoyed their food. I am vegan, so I was very pleased with their vegan cheese option. I can't wait to go back sometime soon! read more

One word, wow, 1st time here, they are very good. We ordered 1 of each, way too much, everything is great! The place is authentic old, super cool, and the service is outstanding. This is one place I highly recommend, go visit, sit down and take it all in. It's a fun place with good people and food done right, very delicious. read more

Cappy's Pizzeria - Dinner! - Pizza Near Me - Tampa, Florida

Can't go wrong with Cappy's. Friendly staff, relaxed ambience, AMAZING deep dish pizza.

Love this place! Pizza is consistent and amazing. Definitely my favorite place for pizza in the Tampa area. Just be aware that it is cash only! read more

the pizza and above all the sauce was delicious and the staff were very friendly, Remembering my days in Italy during summer read more

Cappy's Pizzeria - Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Tampa, Florida

Great food, super nice service staff, cute location and interior. Had a great dinner, look forward to returning again read more

Cappy's Pizzeria - Chicago Style Deep Dish - Pizza Near Me - Tampa, Florida

See all

So, this place was recommended by a good friend who has lived in the area his whole life. Was nearby and called him, "Hey, I'm a fish out of water here! Where can I go for a good beer and even better pizza?" He remembered I'm from Chicago and says, "How about some deep dish pizza? Make you feel at home?" Wow, yes says I. "Cappy's, go to Cappy's. You won't be sorry. So I follow his advice And I am surely not sorry! Beer? They have an amazingly eclectic collection of interesting and international beers. Dark, light, even Welles Banana Bread Beer! Cannot go wrong and won't go dry! Atmosphere is very casual - it's in an old house, how much more casual can you get?? Lots of old posters, maps, license plates, ephemera on the walls. Place says "party" in an old-school language. Loved it. The pizza? Amazing. Great. Fantastic. I can't afford any more adjectives - it's unbelievable. Best deep dish I've had in Florida. Well made, fully cooked, nice ingredients, crust with flavor. Sweet Home Tampa!! Waitress was so cheerful too. And I loved the "sign in" book at the door - that's the list you put your name on it yourself and they'll call you when the table is ready. Look for Sparky McGurk - that's me! I will return and next time, I'm skipping lunch so that I can enjoy more of their food!! read more

Cappy's Pizzeria - Food prep area - Pizza Near Me - Tampa, Florida

See all

It hurts me to say that I recently discovered my favorite Tampa pizzeria who provides deep dish akin to my love Charlotte's Chicago cut... does not believe in mask wearing. Upon further investigation and chatter amongst cronies of mine, we all agreed their pizza is delicious, however we noticed all patrons were mask wearing, whilst employees were not clad with proper protective equipment. Such a pity, we love local businesses, especially one as institutional as Cappy's. But the fact remains, as a physician I swore an oath to protect people from disease, and as much as I so wish to support this locale eatery, I cannot compromise my ethics and support those who as a whole cannot wear masks to protect people. I have worked with asthmatic, claustrophobic, dermatologically challenged doctors in my residency, and their health issues did not prevent them from wearing masks in surgery. Let's try and consider the needs of the public. With kindness and admiration for your pizza, Dr. Crane MD read more