My husband ordered a plain bacon burger with nothing else on it (not even cheese...he is allergic) and he said it was "pretty good." We have a winner! You see, if the burger tastes good without all of the "stuff" piled on top, you can tell they know how to properly season and cook a burger. I had the Italian Hoagie with a side of cole slaw and everything was tasty without being too salty. Our service was good (a plus for a busy Saturday night) and we were pleasantly surprised when the food actually came out right (most places screw up the plain bacon burger somehow...). It was a bit loud (lots of hard surfaces for sound to bounce off) but what do you expect? It's a sports bar. This was a nice find that is close to our home. We'll be back! read more

Been here a few times Nice hometown feel to the place Food has been great Heads up..Kitchen closes at 9 Service has been very good Found my spot read more

Great Cape Coral local tavern with a Taco Tuesday Grouper special with fries for only $11.99. Various sports banners throughout with a large dining room and small bar offering domestic and a few craft beers on tap. The server, Rachel, was energetic with a great personality. She poured us High5 Hazy beer which was cold and refreshing. The well seasoned grouper strips were fluffy and nestled inside six toasted soft tacos. The hallway leading to the gender assigned bathrooms had beer company placards affixed to the walls. The men's bathroom was clean and continued the beer theme and loved it. read more

See all

I consider this our local tavern, as it is the closest to where we live. It seems to have a very popular local following. Lots of TV screens, very busy on game days. Our first visit was over a year ago when we first moved to NW Cape and tried to find new places to eat. We were pretty happy with the food, but it took over 30 minutes waiting between appetizer and entree, and water glass was never filled. We said never again. Don't get me wrong, the servers were friendly, but they seemed to forget to check on us! But we did give it a second chance, as we did like the food. We learned though, order all your food together, hope they come out fast. And more importantly, adjust our expectation as far as service goes, especially on very busy day or during peak times. That strategy seemed to work, we have been back every few months. What can I say, I really like their Ruben sandwich and the chicken wings! read more

See all

We love Burnt Store Tavern. Sometimes the food may come out a little different, but they always go out of their way to make it right. Contrary to a review left on April 24th, about Morgan is wrong. She is not like that. She is a hard worker and she always has a smile. There are times she gets so busy and she may not look happy but that's only because she is so focused on her tables, but she's always a hard worker and very pleasant. Please don't listen to that review on the 24th because it's not correct. It's like Cheers in this place and everyone who works there are always pleasant and hard working. read more

I got the Rueben & fries. The sandwich was loaded with corned beef & very tasty. Great fries too. My husband got the fried chicken, mashed potatoes & broccoli. He said everything was great as well. One issue is some of the tables are really crammed in tight. There was no way anyone could sit at the table behind my husband and the place was packed. They did have outdoor seating. Also, there was some type of meat auction to raise money for something. Made it a very, very noisy. Try to avoid eating there when there is an auction (unless you want the meat). Otherwise, the food was delicious & worth the trip. read more

Went for the usually good fried chicken. When we got it told our server Morgan b that it was over cooked and very dry. (maybe oil too hot?).She said "that's the way it comes" and walked away. She never brought the water we asked for and did not come back to check on us or ask if we wanted another cocktail. We pulled the chicken off the bone and removed the skin (we're not offered a "to go" box, so we wrapped in napkins to take home to our dogs.We were never asked if we wanted anything else and had to flag her down across the room to get our check. We are typically VERY generous tippers, and we did leave her a small tip considering maybe she was having a bad day or personal problems, but she needs some training or an attitude change if she wants to make some money. We consider this a very poor reflection on a restaurant that we frequent and usually enjoy!- and she charged us $4.99 for a side that should have been $1.99 since we ordered entrees but said she would not correct the bill/ big part of reason we deducted that amount from what would have been a $5,00 additional tip! read more

The place is smaller than the pictures make it seem. the hamburger bun was super flat for some reason not sure why. the sweet potato fries lacked salt. the place is kind of smaller than i expected. But it seems like it attracted a happy local crowd. We sat on the outside terrace. There are smokers that go outside so be careful if you bring any kiddos. The hostess and server were nice though! read more

Burnt Store Tavern - cheeseburger and sweet potato fries - Sports Bars Near Me - Cape Coral, Florida

My husband got sick on their shrimp cocktail. The server said the kitchen didn't think it was the shrimp.?!? We won't be back. I noticed they have also had health dept. Voilations. It is very sad they do not care about their customers. read more

Best fried shrimp anywhere! Generous portions, friendly and fast service. We stopped in here a year ago, and hoped we'd enjoy it as much this time - absolutely! read more

Over the past week we had two occasions to visit Burnt Store Tavern in Cape Coral FL. with a group of eight people & had the good fortune of having Mikayla as our server. The food & drinks were good , prices right but service with Mikayla was outstanding! read more

Loved it. They even have Guinness! Had the fish and it was really good. service slightly slow but not bad and the waitress was very nice. Went in on a whim and was not disappointed. read more

Thought I would try a new place. So I ended up having a couple of beers and a sloppy joe with sweet potato fries. I felt like a kid again, except for the beers. Hahahaha. Service was good and a really nice peaceful atmosphere. Will come back again read more

This place welcomes everyone who comes in. Friendly staff and good food. I have never had a bad meal here. Always have fun things to do! read more

WOW! Totally unexpected! It's LOCAL...Feels LOCAL...Just what the Doctor ordered. Food? Wow! Reuben? Huge! Taste? Perfect! Size? Huge! As it should be. There were no less than five other menu items I want to try. Like fries with that? PERFECT FRIES! Want to hang out where the locals are? Burnt Store Tavern is it. EXCELLENT prices and Service and food delivery were good...not fancy...just good. Like a local would be served. If you get that. The ambiance is...yep...LOCAL. Nothing fancy, a little too brightly lite maybe, but TV's, neon signs and black walls, a big bar and, if I didn't mention...LOCALS like us. We walked in and immediately knew someone. Check out Burnt Store Tavern. And of all my reviews I've never asked a place to add something. BST makes pizza. Please add Stromboli! You'll be the only place selling it west of Skyline. Brian read more

See all

What a great place to eat and see the locals. This place has its regulars and is community orientated. The one and only thing I would change about it is, I wish it was a BILLS BAR. But hey, I can work around that! Prices are fair and I've never had a bad meal. read more

Nice place. Pleasant staff. Food was good but a little salty. My husband had same experience.

Went to watch the Super Bowl, food & drink were good but between the half time show and 1 loud racist patron made for long halftime... I know the establishment can't help the sucky halftime show but nobody seemed to be concerned about the guy yelling inappropriate things... management/owner should have stepped up. read more

Burnt Store Tavern - Cape Coral, FL (Would give 6 stars if Google allowed it for "Beer Colder Than a witch's Tit") Walked into Burnt Store Tavern expecting the usual Florida strip-mall vibes and left wondering if I'd accidentally stumbled into a Michelin-starred speakeasy disguised as a neighborhood bar. Our server Casey deserves her own statue outside. Picture this: four hangry adults, zero patience, menus longer than a CVS receipt. Casey swoops in like a superhero whose cape is made of napkins and unlimited refills. She memorized our chaotic order faster than I can remember my own Wi-Fi password. No "I'll check with the kitchen," no up-selling dessert before apps--just pure, unfiltered competence wrapped in a smile that could melt butter. 10/10, would let her babysit my kids, dog, and tax documents. The kitchen? Pure Sorcery. My grouper sandwich arrived so perfectly cooked I half-expected it to wink at me. Flaky, juicy, zero "fishy" crimes committed. The burgers were medium-well masterpieces--juicier than gossip at a PTA meeting. And the wings? Crispy outside, tender inside, sauced so expertly I considered proposing to the chef mid-bite. Beer? Served at a temperature that should be illegal in Florida. I'm convinced they keep hops in the witness-protection program inside a glacier. If you leave Burnt Store Tavern anything less than stuffed, happy, and plotting your return trip, you're doing life wrong. Tell Casey we sent you--she'll probably remember our order from 2025 anyway. P.S. Bathroom was clean, parking was easy, and zero alligators tried to eat me. Florida five stars! read more

Great place for a drink but as far as food, eh it's at two. Been there a couple times cause other people wanted to go and every time the food I've gotten has been so salty that has been unbearable for me. read more

Food was ok The customer service was awful. Not worth putting up with There are better places to enjoy a meal read more

First time here and last time. Had the Wednesday Special Prime Rib, it was grey in color, extremely chewy, bland and barely warm, near impossible to even cut with their steak knife. Mashed potatoes tasted instant and cheap. I told waitress this was first and probably last time here and she did not care either way. Side of corn was also bland and cold Sent entire meal back. I should have know since our mushroom appetizers were cold in the middle but almost burnt on the outside. Oh well, $70 down the drain. read more

We went for dinner with 2 kids the other day! They were very accommodating with the children! Server was great and food was delicious!

The food at this location is certainly better than what I would have associated with a 'tavern'. The French dip and chicken fried steak are both excellent. It is also a good place to watch the game. read more

Great sports bar as long as you're with the home team. Great burger, cold beer, and eclectic menu.

Had fried shrimp and a Reuben sandwich. Both were very tasty. Waitress was very efficient.

Waited 13 minutes at the table, no service. Should not have to wait that long to be greeted by a server. So we left read more

Was excited to hopefully find a nice local place for lunch, but unfortunately it wasn't what we hoped for. Staff were decent and friendly but we waited 40 minutes for food on a Sunday afternoon and it wasn't very busy. Food was ok, nothing special. read more

Food is good and servers are pleasant but last two times we were there it took 45 minutes to a hour to get our food if it wasn't for that I might have given them four stars they need to figure out how to speed up the kitchen read more

Service was great, food was your typical fried spots bar food. Had plenty of tvs and a decent selection of beers.

If you live in the area or in town visiting our beautiful paradise, Burnt Store Tavern is a must try!! We are regulars here because it's like our very own "Cheers" where everyone knows your name.. Fantastic people, fun atmosphere and great food! The bartenders and wait staff are very accommodating and friendly!! The owners are great people as well and hands on! They have daily meal specials under $10!! Just one of our favorites is the grilled Grouper taco Tuesday special.. read more

Burnt Store Tavern - Grilled Grouper Taco Tuesday special!! - Sports Bars Near Me - Cape Coral, Florida

Food was pretty bad for being " bar food". Tenders - overcooked Fish & chips - overcooked ( maybe oil too hot) Meatball sub - it was ok Hopefully it was just us / or some needed improvements to help This place going forward Prices seem on par with other places. Service was good. read more

See all

Great food great staff common quiet everything on the menu very good served hot and fresh. The staff are all great friendly people lunch specials are very good too. read more

Great food and awesome service! Staff is always kind and attentive. Some of the best wings and nachos in town. I've you're in for a real treat, get yourself a Philly cheesesteak or the special of the day. Sports bar type ambiance with a bunch of tvs perfect for game night. read more

Only had a chocolate martini but it was wonderful! Loved the Minnesota Vikings decor and friendly service!

Excellent home town food, service is great and always very fast. Great daily specials, but don't mist the Mushroom and Swiss burgers. Tater tots and onion rings are excellent too! read more

Terrible customer service! I'd love to give one star but not an option! mediocre at best for the food. read more

Just not a comfortable place to dine. I won't be going back. People working there don't seem happy about it, and it is a downer for a good dining experience. read more

I have been here before and it was pretty good, that's why we came back today. I ordered fried chicken which i thought was amazing last time, today, not so much. Seemed to not have the breading in several areas and one piece might have been under cooked. One girl in our group ordered a grilled cheese, it another grilled cheese came out real quick, i was happy because that was for a toddler, 20 minutes for our food and then no grilled cheese for the other girl, all food was good but the chicken, service was very slow, no apology or acknowledgement. I like the have Vikings and twins stuff in walls but i cannot repeat biz with a 2 star. I'd pass if i was trying to decide based on reviews. read more

Went to Burnt Store Tavern on 10/11/24. Many challenges with intermittent power outages. Servers were great. Food was excellent. Patrons took all the challenges in stride. Would highly recommend. Owners checked in with patrons. read more