Probably my favorite place in Tally to get ice cream! Whether my wife and I want scoops, Blizzard-like treats, or sundaes, we normally find ourselves coming to Bruster's! Their ice cream is delicious. I would suggest trying the Oreo or Mint Chip flavors. Bruster's packs a ton of add-ins (Oreos, chocolate chips, etc) into their ice cream and it makes it even better! I also suggest the Blizzard-like treat called Blasts. The Brownie Fudge sundae is the star of the show though. The brownie is hot, soft, and delicious! They also pack a ton of ice cream (your choice), hot fudge, and whipped cream on top. So good! Warning: the sundae is huge! Bring a big appetite or someone to share If you want something sweet, Bruster's is always my suggestion. They have a wide variety of ice cream treats and they are all delicious! read more

Bruster's Real Ice Cream - Oreo Blast - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Tallahassee, Florida

Hidden gem! My sweet tooth was calling me and I happened upon the establishment. It was pretty close to my hotel so I was sold. My friend ordered 2 scoops of cookies and cream on a waffle cone. I ordered 2 scoops of chocolate with specialty dark chocolate on a waffle cone. The young lady assisting us behind the counter highly recommended it. When I tell you we sat in silence until we nearly inhaled our ice cream. It was so delicious. The richness in the flavors was definitely memorable. The portion sizes of the scoops were consistent and worth the value (around $11 for both). I would return whenever I'm in town. read more

Great little strip mall ice cream shop! We celebrated the last day of school with a kids cup of birthday cake ice cream with rainbow sprinkles and a turtle sundae. Both were great! The young man running the shop was friendly and helpful. You'll find a couple tables inside and a few more in the covered outside area. Not much atmosphere, but some damned good ice cream!!! read more

See all

We were staying nearby at a hotel and popped in one night . The two young girls working were super friendly and helpful. I really enjoyed the turtle ice cream in a cone but the paper stuck to the cone and I couldn't get it off. (Pet peeve!!) My boyfriend enjoyed his Butter Pecan ice cream. Good so for yummy ice cream. read more

See all

Third time in three weeks we come here for a milkshake in the early afternoon and they have ran out of milk. Finding a new milkshake place. They have supply issues. read more

This location is okay. I had two scoops of the chocolate chip cookie dough with the waffle cone and there is definitely a difference in quality of ice cream here versus the other locations. read more

My wife and i pass this place every day. It was sort of a rotten day so we stopped in for ice cream. I ended up getting a hot fudge brownie and she got a banana split. The prices were fairly high for ice cream. The portion was decent though. I was however disappointed in the presentation and amount of fudge. I didn't see the fudge at all until i started eating into the brownie. It looked like whip cream vanilla ice cream and brownie at first. When i finally reached the hot fudge it was realistically just a few bites and for what i paid i felt ripped off. My wife's banana split looked real good though and she really enjoyed it. I found it interesting they sell these half off on Thursdays if you bring your own banana. We also weren't able to use the restroom (said they didn't have public restrooms). This was frustrating since we're getting food and drinks. You may want to keep that last one in mind. read more

See all

Favorite ice cream shop in town! They have the best hot fudge sundae. I love the cookie dough and the Oreo ice cream. Most places do not add in much cookie dough, and this place fills the ice cream with it! The Oreo ice cream is so creamy with lots of crushed Oreos. Excellent customer service. Brianne is usually there when we go and she's also super friendly and helpful! Download the Bruster's App and take advantage of the rewards program-- you get $3 off your first order with the app too. read more

Bruster's Real Ice Cream - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Tallahassee, Florida

See all

We have NEVER had a bad experience at BRUSTERS. They give samples and have Awesome ice cream and staff!!

I see all of these great reviews so maybe it's me. Maybe I have the weird taste buds. Ice cream is my all time favorite dessert! Like I could eat it when it s 20 degrees outside....but I could easily bypass Bruster's and get some from the grocery store. I'm not certain what it is that's never "wow'd me." The best way I can describe my feelings is that nothing stands out from it. It is "good"....well "yes", but store bought ice cream is "good"....or even "great." If I'm going to pay $4-$7 for ice cream at an ice cream shop, I except to have some really good, like I gotta have it ice cream. Bruster's, to me, is along the lines of Baskin-Robbins or Marble Slab. I love ice cream to be creamy and bursting with flavor. I also appreciate a creative menu and I just didn't get that with Brusters's. They even charged me $1 extra for a waffle bowl. Let me name a few places that: (Store bought) Blue Bell, Talenti, Halo top, So Delicious Cashew Milk flavors.... (Ice cream shops) Coldstone, Rita's, Ye Old Fashion, Shake Shack, Pinkberry and Nuberri (yes I know its yogurt). To be honest, if some put a scoop of strawberry from Brusters and a scoop of strawberry from...lets say Edy's or Breyers, I probably wouldn't know the different...even though I would say all three are "good." On another note, the store was clean and the cashier was friendly. She was the only person working there and there was a line of about 7 customers but she worked as quickly as she could and apologized for the wait. There is limited seating; but both indoor and outdoor available and there is no drive-thru. read more

See all

I can't resist a waffle cone and although I have to workout really hard to have one Brusters does it well and makes it worth the work out. Lol read more

After a long movie, I was craving ice cream. I quickly looked to see which parlor was closest to me and chose Bruster's. I was very pleased with the quality of ice cream they serve in this particular Brusters. It was creamy and buttery. I got cookie dough and tried the double chocolate chunky flavor. Soooo good! I have finally found my favorite ice cream parlor in Tally. I usually felt like I had to go to the store and get Ben&Jerry's but that started feeling super sugary. This ice cream felt like old fashioned creamy milky ice cream. read more

Bruster's Real Ice Cream - Hungry for sweeeets! - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Tallahassee, Florida

See all

My favorite ice cream in Tallahassee! This location has indoor and outdoor seating but no drive-thru like the other one, and it's hours are a bit more limited. Plenty of parking. Dog owners: They give you a free pup cup--small vanilla scoop and milk bone--for your pup with a purchase. read more

It was so good! I definitely recommend people trying this amazing spot. The ice cream was so amazing and creamy and there was so many flavors to choose from! read more

We were kind of skeptical after reviewing some of the reviews but it's been a hot, muggy day here and decided to give it a try anyway. Not shown was my husbands four scoop butter pecan waffle cone because he had most of it gone before we took photos and said it was great - my grandson had the hot fudge sundae which was larger than we expected for the price and I had mistakenly ordered birthday cake instead of cake batter but it was really good! For $16 bucks total we think the price was pretty good compared to what we pay in Lake City at our ice cream chain. (NNM) will definitely be back! read more

Bruster's Real Ice Cream - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Tallahassee, Florida

See all

I took a walk this afternoon to explore the area and couldn't pass up the opportunity to have some ice cream here. Ice cream is one of my favorite things. My husband learned early in our relationship he could distract me, change my mood and/or score points with trips for ice cream. We go out for it a lot. All ice cream is pretty good but you can't beat homemade. Bruster's ice cream has a very smooth creamy consistency and awesome full-bodied flavor. My choice today (after some sampling) was a sugar cone with strawberry cheesecake ice cream. I opted for the "small" and it turned out to be a very generous portion that satisfied even my big-time ice cream cravings. After watching another patron's ice cream slide sideways, I took the suggested bowl with my order. Turns out I didn't need it but I am a pretty big ice cream pro. Non pros might want to consider the bowl - just in case. read more

Bruster's Real Ice Cream - BYOB Thursdays! - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Tallahassee, Florida

Ice cream is good but the employee handling the ice cream wasn't wearing a mask so that was a little unsettling lol. read more

Bruster's Real Ice Cream - Sign - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Tallahassee, Florida

Half price banana split on Thursday if you bring your own banana. Three huge scewps of ice cream with a bunch of fruit for $3.50. Amazing deal for the quality of ice cream. read more

This is become my favorite ice cream place in town and I love it. Not a big desert guy but this is good stuff!

Good ice cream place with a great selection. They always seem to have some really creative flavors. My last trip I had a waffle cone with caramel cashew ice cream. Think butter pecan, but with cashews, and I mean tons of them. I had the regular which included 3 scoops, and that is huge, but oh so good. I'll get a small next time. Nice fun place that we are sure to visit many times in the future. read more

Normally a hands down 5 star experience. No questions asked. The creamiest, dreamiest ice cream in all the land. The best Oreo I've ever come across. Sigh. I went in here last night and got a regular waffle cone (3 scoops), and boy was the bar set high. I opted for oreo (obviously), cookie dough, and chocolate - chocolate chunk. While the ice cream was still pretty tasty, it was MELTED! Did they lose power during Hermine and keep the ice cream frozen just enough to keep serving a week later? So disappointed. It was the consistency of soft serve after its been in a hot car for 10 mins. A drippy mess with 3 flavors all melted together is what I ended up with. What a sad, sad day. I'd give it a few weeks before going here to make sure you aren't served the same slop that I got this weekend. read more

Just staying in town tonight and this place got some pretty good reviews so we decided to try it out. Very glad we did. Got here just in time too, the line behind us had 15 people in it, yes i counted! I guess this place isn't the best kept secret in town. I'm a fan. I got a cone and it was HUGE! Tones of ice cream. Make sure you're hungry, that's all i can say. read more

What can I say about Brusters Ice cream in Tallahassee ,fl it's simply the best ice cream in town in fact I will say The best Iv ever had in the USA.Great people great ice cream on the parkway. read more

Bruster's Real Ice Cream - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Tallahassee, Florida

Great fresh homemade ice cream. They always have great flavors. We've tried many flavors you can't go wrong!!!!

Delicious handmade ice cream and waffle cones. They make their ice cream fresh daily as well as their cones. I got a regular waffle cone with double chocolate chunk ice cream and my husband got the birthday cake milkshake. They were both delicious! read more

The ice cream is high quality (better than Ben and Jerry's and Cold Stone). In addition, the prices are much lower than the aforementioned. This translates into darn good ice cream for a great value! :) The owner of this particular store seems passionate about taking care of her customers and providing a great product!!!! If you are a resident of Tallahassee, stop by and have a scoop or two. If you are a traveler who finds yourself in Tallahassee seeking good ice cream then Bruster's is worth seeking out! read more

Bruster's Real Ice Cream - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Tallahassee, Florida

We came in on a cold night. It had just rained. We were immediately greeted by a friendly cashier. She offered to explain the menu to us and offered up free samples right away. When she saw our dog, she also offered up a doggy bowl for him. I had the chocolate I've cream in a waffle cone. It was really good. Their ice cream is smooth and tasty. It want overly sweet and it really hit the spot. I'd definitely come back. It was a really good experience, which is hard to come by in Tallahassee. read more

This place has the best ice cream!!! Nice tables out front to take a break from running errands and enjoying a treat:)

Pretty good ice cream, but seems overpriced. Staff are friendly and location is good; only outdoor seating, but that's just fine for Tallahassee conditions! If you're looking to spend $5 on ice cream, this is your place. read more

My wife and I get ice cream here at least once a week. Great ice cream flavors and the waffle cone is delicious

Honestly, I'm highly impressed as to how someone could botch a chocolate milkshake. The "chocolate" was vanilla ice cream somewhat blended with chocolate syrup. Not to mention I paid $6.00 for it. So much for "Real Ice Cream". What a shame. read more

Really unique, tasty variety of flavors! Their ice cream is so creamy and delicious, never too hard or icy. They're not super cheap for ice cream cones, but they have big servings and are always really satisfying. They also give doggy sundaes for free if you bring your dog! read more

Really good ice cream and nice ambiance. Moreover, they offer Italian ice, which a lot of other local places don't. Only downside is it's a little pricey for what you get, not terribly large portions relative to how much you pay. But given the up side, we'll be returning in the near future. read more

The ice cream is good, but Derek is great! Amazing customer service, he can practically read your order by looking deep into your eyes. Will come again! read more

Without question my favorite local business! Not only is the ice cream homemade and there are plenty of choices, the employees are very nice. Even better, the servings are HUGE (one scoop from Brusters is enough for most). If you're in town or live here and have family visiting, this is the place to be to satisfy your sweet tooth! read more

Great ice cream flavor, tons of menu items, quick staff and large portions. This was a much better deal then those pay by the ounce yogurt shops. read more