We just ate at Brooklyn Joes for the first time today. My husband had the calzone and I had the eggplant panini. They both were fantastic! While waiting Tim brought us a slice of cheese pizza to try. It was a true slice of heaven, thin crispy crust with just the right amount of cheese. Finally we found some great Italian food. We will be back to try more of their delicious selections. Special shoutout to Tim, he was attentive and an overall great person. See you soon! read more

Fast, friendly, fair for dine in or take out. My fav pizza in PG/PC (not that I've tried all). I like the slightly greasy (sorry) and thin crust. Quick slices to go for lunch. Lots or worker bees stop there. read more

I am very picky about NY style pizza.. Brooklyn Joe's pizza was amazing!! Stopped in for a quick slice, can't wait to try more.

My second time here and they greeted me like family when I came in I ended up having mild chicken wings. Pasta soup and their Brooklyn pizza with hot honey. The honey wasn't really that hot but the pizza was delicious. I've had the pizza here before and that's why I came back. Very good. Fresh ingredients would come back again. Check out the pictures they'll make your mouth drool. read more

Brooklyn Joe's - Brooklyn pizza - Pizza Near Me - Punta Gorda, Florida

See all

Brooklyn Joes is amazing. The pizza is always perfect with great flavor and texture. The Philly cheese steak is fantastic and the sausage and cheese pizza is one of the best around. The staff is friendly and the place has a great local vibe. Always a solid choice for great food. read more

Brooklyn Joe's - Pizza Near Me - Punta Gorda, Florida

Once again BJoes didn't disappoint, great great pizza. Looking for the best pizza, here is the place! read more

Brooklyn Joe's - Roasted red pepper and sausage! - Pizza Near Me - Punta Gorda, Florida

Having had the opportunity to order meals through the past few years, consistency is a key factor that Justin and his team have achieved. They prepare consistently great meals, whether you order a pizza or a delicious dinner. The new menu, in my opinion is a home run. The chicken parmigiana and piccata were both excellent and pizzas superb. This is a great local restaurant that serves delicious meals. If you haven't tried them, give them the opportunity to make a meal for you. As an added bonus their deserts won't disappoint either. Food: 5/5 | Service: 5/5 | Atmosphere: 5/ read more

The food and service are perfect. Never had a meal I didn't like. The restaurant is always clean. Everyone greets you with a warm smile. read more

Amazing! The mozzarella is the best I have ever tasted in pizza. They have Brooklyn soda there which is much better than any coke or root beer I ever tasted. It happed to be a bust Tuesday afternoon but everyone was so nice and helpful. Did I say the pizza was too notch? GF crust is awesome. read more

Brooklyn Joe's - What's left of mozzarella caprese gluten free! Mmmm - Pizza Near Me - Punta Gorda, Florida

When visiting Punta Gorda in the off season, you have to be aware that many restaurants are either closed or close early. I googled Brooklyn Joe's and it said they were closing in one minute. I called to confirm, but the owner said what do you want, I am going to be here for another hour anyway. We headed down and our pizza was coming out the oven. Great service from Ian and the pizza was the best I have had in a while. Authentic New York style. The sauce was especially tasty. Thanks again, we will be back. read more

Brooklyn Joe's - Pizza Near Me - Punta Gorda, Florida

We loved Broklyn Joe's - we get pizza and cheese steaks. Quick carry out service, friendly staff.

Authentic Brooklyn style pizza. Very friendly staff and nice dinning area. Try and hot honey and pepperoni pizza and the margarita pizza. 7/3/2025 read more

Brooklyn Joe's - Pizza Near Me - Punta Gorda, Florida

It's o.k. but we won't return. Lasagna looks like it came pre-made and pre packaged. My husband liked the meatball sub. Pizza was o.k. but nothing to brag about. read more

First time here and was not disappointed. Having lived in north Jersey surrounded by good pizza I was happily surprised and delighted by the Hawaiian pizza. Fresh and crisp. Will return 100% read more

Brooklyn Joe's - Hawaiian Grandma Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Punta Gorda, Florida

Okay. I know it's annoying for northerners to come to Florida and compare pizza, I get it. But the last time I was in Florida I had a bite of pizza that was so nasty that I immediately spit it out. It scarred me, actually lol. I decided to try this place as I live directly behind it and people rave about it. My expectations were low, but let me tell ya. Absolutely frikan delish. My dad hasn't shut up about it either lol. Highly recommend read more

Incredible pizza. Top notch and perfect. The crust is thin and soft sauce is not too sweet or sour, pepperoni was juicy and crispy and the cheese is impeccable. The only downside is the size coming from NYC this pizza is small but worth it. The environment is friendly and the service is quick and good. The guy who makes the pizza is friendly and talkative. read more

Our pizza was cold when we received it. Not even SLIGHTLY warm. The spinach (chicken Alfredo spinach) was raw. The flavor was awful. Never again! read more

Food was good, but way over priced. Service was terrible, we received our pizza and the Alfredo for grandchild came out after we boxed up the pizza. No offer of discount, boxed up the Alfredo because she didn't want to eat alone. Table never got cleaned, had to ask several times for refills and to go boxes. The worst part of it: 3 waitress and only 5 other tables had customers. read more

First time at Brooklyn Joes, The Pizza was Delish, will definitely come back again, I even had a take out box. Employees are Awesome. Thank again. read more

Awesome Pizza and Stromboli! Very good flavor and crust texture on the pizza. Took the Stromboli home for later...Service was great! Highly recommend it read more

Guy recommended to this place by a friend of mine from New York. Long Island stepped into the place. Great service. The pizza was delicious. Highly recommend. read more

Great pizza, good ingredients, friendly staff, quick service, and online ordering. Can't go wrong with that.

Best pizza! Always get our pizza at Brooklyn Joe's!! Always dependable service! Love them! Our go-to pizza!

Had good food and great service! I had a small pizza and my wife had the chicken parm. Both were served quickly and good portions. read more

The best the works pizza, and tiramisu I ever ate! The server Ian was great and Justin was exceptional! A woman server pitched in to help as they were busy! Delicious! read more

Ordered Italian club and was very disappointed. Dry roll that crumbled as it was held. Maybe 5 slices of meat, if that, on a large. If Joe really is from Brooklyn, he should be embarrassed. People don't order hoagies, subs, heros to eat a loaf of bread, especially whatever Joe's is using. Joe, ya need to call Amoroso's Bakery and change up those rolls if you're gonna be advertising an east coast style sandwich and serving it to transplants. read more

Brooklyn Joe's - Dry, dry bread with very little meat. - Pizza Near Me - Punta Gorda, Florida

A legit pizzeria in Florida is hard to come by. this checks all the boxes. Great pizza. Great service. Super clean. Try the pepperoni/feta/honey slice. read more

The place has the best pizza around. All the fixing are fresh and you can add what you love.Lunch specials are large include salad meal and dessert at a very reasonable price. read more

Chef Nick here. Well I got to tell you I've had a lot of people tell me you got to try Brooklyn Joe's. Finally, I get up to punta Gorda to try them. I'll tell you it's just a name Brooklyn because they certainly couldn't serve this pizza in Brooklyn. It was so thin and I picked up the slice. It fell over. That was the first strike. The second strike was they were using this inferior grande cheese. A blended cheese left oil over the pizza. Not whole milk. Mozzarella like I'm used to up north salsa's okay, but very disappointed and if $5 is a slice that's a disgrace. They weren't worth more than a dollar. Obviously I was still hungry after two paper thin slices. So I ordered a Philly cheese steak. What another disgrace. It was tasty. However, it had chopped peppers who the hell is ever told anybody in Florida that a Philly cheese steak has sliced peppers on it. It doesn't fried onions and cheese. That's it. No other bullshit goes on a cheese steak. You want to add mushrooms? That's up to you but never ever ever peppers. That's not a Philly cheese steak. That's probably a jersey cheesecake. They do anything in that state. Me was very scarce. I could have put all the meat on half of sandwich. You need it. Have very little meat in it roll was so so but that's Florida. $15 for sandwich. It should have been $2.99. I don't think I'll go back. I was so disappointed because that Brooklyn Joe's now of course I've been to Brooklyn many times but this by no way or means. Is this food like in Brooklyn? Forget about it. Don't even think of going there. Don't waste your time or your money. Not a table next to me to have salad look like plenty of salad. The salt look good but I went there for the pizza and the cheese steak. I asked about their meatballs. You make your own meatballs. He said no, we don't. That was another strike. You got to be kidding me. Brooklyn Joe's buys frozen meatballs and cooks them. What kind of Italian pizza parlor buys meatballs? They're so easy to make. No pride whatsoever and absolute disgrace one and done for that place. read more

Loved the pizza. The staff was and is always friendly. Pizza is always a person choice, always a hot topic on reviews. Try them, reminds of a good Jersey Pizza. read more

We were given half of a Joe's calzone by a neighbor who was leaving town and OMG it was delicious. So, one night when we were debating dinner we ordered a meat lover's pizza from Joe's with the same result. Great food and fast service (we carried out). We'll have to try other menu items but would be happy with more Joe's calzone and pizza. read more

This is our go to Neighborhood Italian place. We love the food. Everything we order is hot, fresh and delicious. Friendly staff. Quick drink refills. Bottled beer and wine. They are doing curbside service during Covid lockdown. Highly recommend. read more

Brooklyn Joe's - a pizza on a pan - Pizza Near Me - Punta Gorda, Florida

See all

Excellent variations of all sorts of red and white sauce pizzas!! I ordered and picked up here for a work lunch event. Everyone raved about the flavors and wanted to know where it's located. read more

Pizza was excellent! They improved from last visit! The ingredients were perfect. Will buy again.

Best pizza in Punta Gorda and Port Charlotte, Fl! and energetic service! Looking forward to trying their other dishes next time. Will definitely return. read more

I wrote a review on Yelp for this place however it disappeared, but is still under my reviews. Strange. I gave it four stars on that one but I ate inside the restaurant. I have only gotten take out since. You have to go there and order and then wait for it or you will get a cold pie. My only issue is that the specialty pizzas don't have what I like and by the time I add olives , mushrooms and banana peppers to the Genovese, it gets pricey for what you get. The pizza is good and it's just down the street from me. I wish them every success. Not on the level of Pioneers , but still good. I didn't care to eat inside because of the dirty dish basket that they keep the dishes and table scraps on sit in the dining area. Sorry , but that's gross. read more

Brooklyn Joe's - Pizza Genovese - Pizza Near Me - Punta Gorda, Florida

See all

Welcome to town Brooklyn Joe's! My husband and I stopped in Brooklyn Joe's for the very first time today hoping to try a slice of pizza. We had heard great things and were intrigued by the new spot in PGI. However, we found that they stop serving slices at 3:00pm. It was 2:45pm and we could have had a slice of the remaining selections, but the toppings weren't to our liking, so we decided to get a small calzone to-go. That's when the rain came and that to-go calzone turned into, we'll just hang out here and eat it. WOW! So glad we didn't get a slice because our selection was incredible. We split a small calzone with pepperoni and mushrooms and it was fantastic. Perfect size for sharing. The calzone was overflowing with yummy mozzarella and ricotta, absolutely delicious. You could tell the ingredients were of good quality. The side of sauce that came with the calzone was some of the best I've ever had! We had a wonderful waitress (I'm sad to say I failed to get her name, I know she was discovered at the gym next door) that accommodated our change from to-go to eat-in with ease, even though she was already waiting on several tables. She was a breath of fresh air, talking with the customers and going above and beyond her basic duties. There were only two small things of note, and I imagine they are still getting the hang of how things will work since they're new, but there were two tubs of dirty dishes on a cart near the front counter, not really what I want to see when I walk-in or while I'm eating. Now those tubs were taken away while we were there, but I think I would find an alternate spot even if it is less convenient. The other thing is my personal problem because I really, really dislike cigarette smoke. A couple of employees took a break and I noticed they went out right beside the main entrance to smoke. I felt bad for the customers getting a whiff of it as they came inside even though one of the smokers was super polite and held the door open for them. Maybe there should be a table out back for employees to take their breaks. Over all Brooklyn Joe's was great, and we look forward to trying many more items on the surprisingly extensive menu. read more

See all

Great pizza and pasta spot. Locally owned and committed to Punta Gorda. Highly recommended!Meat Lovers Works Pizza read more

The food is exceptional and the people are wonderful. I have had pizza, Stromboli and spaghetti. Never disappoints. Look, I get it, they a a modest but comfortable dining area. I always pick up and eat at my home 5 minutes away. I'm not trying to over sell the place but, try it. You won't be disappointed. read more

Being from New England finding good pizza is difficult. Had lunch here, we ordered slices which were good and in my opinion sold for a very cheap price. Crust was thin and crispy, my wife commented this is her favorite since we moved here a little over a year ago. We will got back again to try as freshly made pizza vs. slices as slices are always a little less tasty than a freshly cooked pizza. We had both the cheese and meatball slices. Meatball slices we loaded with meatball vs getting a taste every second or third bite. The meatball were very good. read more