Hands down, BEST pinxtos bar we experienced in all of San Sebastian! Unlike the majority of the bars in the area, Borda Berri makes absolutely everything on their menu to order - and this helps them stand out from the rest. Both mine and my wife's favorite stop(s) of our entire two week trip to Portugal and Spain. We were in San Sebastian for 4 days (3 nights), and visited Borda Berri THREE times. The food quality and taste here was literally as good as a Michelin starred ~300+ euro dinner, for a TENTH of the price! (although obviously the Michelin experience offered some other intangibles and superior service)
We tried & recommend all of the following (in order of my preference):
Carrillera de Ternera of Vino Tinto (3.50 euros) - A whole veal cheek, slowly braised in red wine and served with two types of sauces. The meat literally falls apart (in a good way) before you can put it on your fork, and the depth of flavor is incredible. This remains one of my favorite bites I've ever had, anywhere, and the price is unbeatable.
Risotto de "Puntalete" con Queso Idiazabal (3 euros) - I don't think risotto is a typical Spanish dish (especially a risotto with such a sharp cheese flavor), but this dish is absolutely incredible. I assume the reason we didn't see risotto on any other menu in town is because other establishments know this dish would be impossible to compare to.
"Kebab" de Costilla de Cerdo (4 euros) - This is not a kebab in the traditional American sense. It's actually a giant pork rib. Very tender (although not quite as much as the veal cheek), and the outer coating of the rib tastes like candy.
Entrecote con Berenjena (4 euros) - This is basically a filet mignon. Very simple, and not quite as much flavor as the veal cheek dish, but the quality of this cut of meat is incredible and cooked a perfect medium-rare (recommend, especially given the price)
Ravioli de Langostinos y Bacon (4 euros) - This is the one dish that we weren't completely WOWED by... The dish is a single, good sized ravioli, with a distinguished Asian flavor profile (which was a surprise to us). The flavor was good, but we weren't able to identify any good sized chunks of langostine or bacon inside - the filling is more of a blend/puree. Given the price of this dish compared to the others mentioned above, we only tried this one time and didn't repeat as we did with all of the others. Think of this more as an above average asian style dumpling than an Italian ravioli - definitely something to try, but wasn't our favorite.
Service & atmosphere: Friendly enough, but mostly business. Keep in mind that they are extremely busy, and since they cook all dishes to order, they are sometimes a little chaotic. It is truly incredible that the bartenders usually just shout back all of the orders to the kitchen, and we didn't experience any missing or forgotten dishes for ourselves or the other patrons. Once you fight your way to the front and make eye contact with a bartender/server, be prepared to order or expect them to quickly move on to someone who is ready (kind of like the Soup Nazi - but definitely friendlier and a little more forgiving). I think I was on good terms with the bartender with my readiness, because by our second and third visit here, she always winked at me whenever we put in a new order or asked for "la cuenta" (the check).
Atmosphere: A crowded and hectic, but SOOO worth fighting for a spot. Don't expect to find a seat here unless you get lucky - there are only 4 stools in the whole place from what we can tell (all of which were spread out, so even if you got one you definitely won't get a second next to it).
Tip: No English menu available -- come prepared! read more