Bagelman

The sandwiches at Jojo's deli are epic. I had a double meat double cheese ham turkey, and roast…read morebeef with lettuce, tomato mayonnaise, onion, and I made two meals out of it. Wonderfully fresh meats cut right in front of you nothing but good things to say about JoJo.

Fabulous food generous hełpings Best place around for really hungry people to go toread more

Spinach, Hummus & Feta Wrap

Drunken Irishman: The sandwich is as amazing as the name!

See all

Grilled Chicken Fajita Panini - Delicious!

Primo Deli

4.1(71 reviews)

2.9 mi

Okay, going 1-more star to 5! Upped their game even more! This place makes the best sandwiches, the…read morelargest panino and ample sized take-out portions! Best of all, very fairly priced! They're making money on volume here as I never go in when there's not people coming or going. Amazing selection to choose from if you're ordering from their hot bar - so much! My 'only' recommendation/comment here would be to have more 'fresh' coffee on-hand. Maybe something a little stronger like Cafe Bustelo, and providing stirrers or spoons wouldn't hurt either. Thank you to the sisters! You two are GREAT!

Narrow interior but goes far back, small space but they made the most of the space. This is…read moreprobably exactly what you expect from the outside. There's a counter you stand at with a hot bar and a cold bar and you order there - then pay at the register where there is an assortment of desserts. Very friendly English speaking service. Meat that's well seasoned and falls off the bone. Flavorful rice and beans. My husband finished his - I'm gonna get two meals out of mine. They have a a couple coolers full of drinks. I want to go back for a chocolate cake slice.

Rice beans pork ribs and plantains

Marinated carrots and radishes. Very very

See all

Steak Burrito bowl

L&M Deli & Sandwich Shop

4.4(14 reviews)

This is the best deli in town! They are always efficient and kind and the sandwiches are amazing!read more

Have ordered breakfast and lunch here a few times before. Quality is pretty good and sandwiches are…read moretasty. We've had some times where the breakfast sandwiches are better than others. Prices are reasonable as well. Service is fairly quick to turnaround sandwiches as well.

Bacon egg and cheese

Sausage egg and cheese

See all

Sausage egg and cheese

C&C Delicatessen

3.8(8 reviews)

Order from here regularly. They are very good and the service is great. Everyone is kind and…read morehelpful. They have a hot bar which has awesome picks. The sandwiches are great and a lot bigger than you'd expect. The pricing is the best I've seen which is partially why we go get so much. Definitely try it

Your workers need to learn English for one, my husband keeps ordering even though you continue to…read moreget my order wrong.. do you even know what a Reuben is?? it does not have dressing, lettuce or tomato. If someone places a specific order do it, not half arse whatever you understand in English. I will throw out anything from this deli. Learn English and get orders right. 0 stars.. horrible food. Negligent employees.

Chicken wings

See all

New Milford Deli & Catering

3.7(3 reviews)

I started working in the area and wanted to find a good sandwich spot. Co-worked mentioned to me…read moreabout this place and gave it try. So far, I've had the Stallion and Cubano sandwiches... amazing! Great tasting and great value for the money. Not to mention, inside is presentable (very clean) with some seating and friendly staff. Meant to attach a photo of my sandwich but ate it too quickly :).

I was trying to explain to them that when I order a specific sandwich they don't make it the way I…read moreorder it. It's happened every time. I specifically asked for grilled roast beef on a garlic roll with Swiss cheese and mayo... she wrote down what I wanted and then when I explained the issue the man in charge came over and said that I need to be more specific and say I don't want the one that's on the menu (which is a completely different sandwich it has sun-dried tomatoes brown gravy and onions) So I said she wrote down what I wanted and the kitchen made whatever they wanted. No apology no nothing he said it was my fault!!!??, ridiculous, DO Better !!

Menu cover: business address, hours and phone number

From menu: paninis

See all

From menu: salads selection

Midway Market

3.5(24 reviews)

4.6 mi

A good friend of mine grew up across the street and has talked for years with nostalgia and respect…read morefor the authentic and simplicity of Midway. I was passing the other day and got a few sandwiches for us to share - really looking to experience with him what he remembers fondly. Ownership and staff were fantastic. I loved hearing the regulars have very funny (and unedited) banter with them. The store is a semi-well appointed convenient store. Not fully stocked. Lots of random things (the most whiffle balls in one location I have ever seen), and some holes in the inventory. Deli counter straight forward with lots of options. It feels completely authentic. Kind of a throwback in time. I was very happy to have visited. Every so often I'll come through when in the area. Will not be a destination. Take aways - great people. Really really good rolls and bread for the area. Wry reasonably priced.

Part of me to was kind of surprised there was actually a deli. I'm not sure why, I had no reason to…read moredoubt it. The card board rock and random wiffle ball display was much more surprising. But by and large, it was a regular conscience store, with deli. There was even a small section of seating inside. The selection was pretty much what you'd expect, chips and soft drinks. Not a bad place for a pick me up, but parking can be exciting because you're backing into traffic if you go too far

See all

Roxbury Market & Deli

4.2(20 reviews)

6.1 mi

Friendly folks in a small but interesting market offering a mix of dry goods, grocery items and…read moreunique ice cream flavors. Worth stopping for especially if you'd like to trade stories with the "denizens"! Glad we ran across it. I'd rate it a 5 for the serendipitous nature of the place and, perhaps a 4 simply because of the limited selection of some items (understandable).

Nice premade sandwiches for a quick pick up trip. Neat clean place fully stocked. Great selection…read moreof drinks and snacks.

See all

Route 7 Deli & Catering

3.4(5 reviews)

Hands down the best deli around, we needed this deli in new Milford , the food is so fresh and so…read moregood and the people are as friendly as it can be , I highly recommend, you will not regret. Thank you deli and catering for making the best sandwiches ever and the hot food is fenomenal as well I love this place .

The absolute best deli food I have ever had! I love they they offer gluten free options and healthy…read moremeals. Every sandwich and meal is delicious and made with care. The people who work there are so kind. I highly recommend going, you will be happy you did.

Brickhouse Pizza & Restaurant

4.2(103 reviews)

2.4 mi

Had to throw some additional LOVE to this place, AGAIN! I had something today I haven't had in…read moreyears. Real 'Hot' Italian sausage! Usually you don't get a choice so when I ordered my sandwich and I was asked, "Spicy or Regular?" I was immediately shocked as you never get a choice. But hearing "Hot" got me excited as even when you're told someone has it, it NEVER is. This WAS! Hot, spicy and absolutely delicious! The G.O.A.T. sausage parm! The temp was super hot too. Got it home and had to wait several minutes for it to cool down. NO prob there!

Decent food, nothing to rave about. Their fried calamari was okay just average. Honestly if one…read moreword were to describe this place I'd say average. I would go here again tho it is solid nothing bad.

Chicken marsala

See all

Bagelman - delis - Updated October 2026

Browse Nearby

BEST of New Milford, Connecticut Restaurants near Bagelman

BEST of New Milford, Connecticut Parking near Bagelman

BEST of New Milford, Connecticut Coffee near Bagelman

BEST of New Milford, Connecticut Desserts near Bagelman

BEST of New Milford, Connecticut Sandwiches near Bagelman

BEST of New Milford, Connecticut Breakfast near Bagelman

BEST of New Milford, Connecticut Things to Do near Bagelman

BEST of New Milford, Connecticut Lunch near Bagelman

BEST of New Milford, Connecticut Shopping near Bagelman

BEST of New Milford, Connecticut Thrift Stores near Bagelman

Best of New Milford

Things to do in New Milford

Browse Brands

Brands by name

Browse Articles

Articles by date

People who viewed Bagelman also viewed

Bagel Delight

3.9

(120 reviews)

The bagels are just great, lots of choices and every choice is a good one. The owner is a lovely…read morewoman who gives back to the community constantly. Her pricing is never constant though, just a quirk, let it go, even if its high, next time it will be low and its never expensive. My go to is an egg everything breakfast sandwich and it always rocks. Don't plan on eating that in the car though, the everything will get everywhere. Best bagels around.

I stopped going here, not because of the bagels which are big and fluffy but because of two…read morethings... the prices are not posted and vary each time and the owner is oblivious to the long line of people trying to pay for their order and has more than the polite three second conversation with a patron. If you go there, prepare to stand and wait while she holds court with her regulars.

A.M. Bagel

4.6

(140 reviews)

Amazing place very very good. been coming here for a while and always a great experience .I highly…read morerecommend to anyone.

I arrived just before 7am on the morning of Christmas Eve and there was a line already formed that…read morecould have easily been 50-70 feet long. I waited for half hour for the line to move, before I made it inside. They still had plenty of Xmas themed bagels. I got a dozen. The staff were super nice, attentive, and worked really fast to get people in and out as soon as possible. The place itself is nice big bright and inviting. I got a half dozen of their green and red plain bagels, a Jalapeno cheddar bagel with plain cream cheese and bacon (they put lots on yum and it was crispy), and another plain holiday bagel with their Christmas bark cream cheese. These were some of the best bagels I've ever had thus far in my life. The dozen remained warm for an hour after I picked them up. They were so soft all day, from morning, well into the evening. I can't wait to go back and I'm super happy I waited in that line. My family was extremely happy to try them as well. Nice Xmas Eve morning delight.

DeRocco's Wiches Bagels and Brew

(90 reviews)

DeRocco's has made the move from its longtime neighborhood home in Naugatuck to a beautiful new…read morelocation in Middlebury, and I couldn't be happier for them. The new space is bright, welcoming, and much more accessible to people who may have never discovered this hidden gem before. While I wondered if something would be lost leaving that small neighborhood setting behind, it didn't take long to realize the opposite. The owners, the staff, and the loyal customers have all brought the same warmth and sense of family with them. It still feels like home. I'll admit, though, I was crushed when I learned that Taylor Ham didn't make the move to the new menu. If you read my older reviews, that's actually what brought me through their doors in the first place. It genuinely broke my heart. But loyalty goes both ways. I love this place, so instead of dwelling on what isn't there, I'm making my way through the menu looking for a new favorite. Today I tried the Jalapeño Whopper--bacon, grilled jalapeños, and cream cheese on an everything bagel. It was really good. I discovered that warm cream cheese just isn't my thing, but that's 100% on me, not the sandwich. I also ordered the Gootz: sausage, egg, provolone, sautéed mushrooms, and cherry peppers on a garlic bagel. Outstanding. I'd order that again without hesitation. I'm going to keep working my way through the menu in hopes of finding something that fills the Taylor Ham-sized hole in my heart. And even if I never do, I'll happily keep coming back for their outstanding bagels, incredible spreads, great food, and the feeling you get every time you walk through the door. And while their coffee service is a little different with the pots behind the counter, it's still fantastic. Some places serve breakfast. DeRocco's feels like home.

Consistent and always a great breakfast sandwich! Staff is fast and they have always been on point…read morewith my order. The space is large with a ton of seating. Check their Facebook page before you drive a distance to make sure they haven't sold out and are open!

Nardelli's Grinder Shoppe

4.0

(207 reviews)

Nardelli's is the best deli place in the area. Their sandwiches are delicious, and their desserts…read moreare wonderful. I would order from them more often, but I get out of work too late. Nardelli's is my go-to place for excellent sandwiches!

"Italian Combo Wrap ... everything on it" Keeps me coming back! Whenever I'm in Southbury, I always…read morestop by for take out to avoid cooking supper.

Main Street Deli

(6 reviews)

It's good I only come here once every other week (because this is also where I fill my car). The…read moresandwiches are a good value, especially the breakfast ones. I treat myself to one (or a lunch sandwich) when I fuel up. There's the usual gas station notions, potions and papers, which is sometimes convenient when I don't feel like making a special stop for one item. A good selection of coffees and other necessities. Always friendly people behind the counter.

I cannot believe it took me so long to write a review for these guys. This is an amazing deli and…read moreyou would never guess it because it is inside a gas station. The owners are wonderful people, the deli meats are sliced when you order, the rolls are amazing. The place is packed at lunch time for a very good reason, it is the best deli in town!

The Local Gourmet - Southbury

(82 reviews)

The easiest grab and go lunch spot. The staff is super kind. Always a welcoming, positive attitude…read more All of the food is prepared and on display along fridges that line the walls -- sandwiches, wraps, salads, pre-made meals, and more. They also have smoothies, and other drinks you could order. Today, I tried the strawberry acai smoothie, Vermont chicken club wrap, and the Mexican street corn pasta. All delicious. Another one of my go tos is their chicken salad ciabatta.

The Local Gourmet catered brunch at Post University's Women's History Month event on Friday. The…read morefood was fantastic and everyone raved about it. It was easy to work with the Local Gourmet; Christy and Ashley had great suggestions and made the brunch a success.

Oliver’s Deli & Pizza

4.1

(17 reviews)

Got take away - delicious pie! Service was very friendly in a cozy location. I'm from out of town…read morebut I'd happily return and if I lived here this would probably be my "go to" for NYC style pies...

Certain items are surprisingly wonderful but in my experience, a bit inconsistent. I never know…read morewhen they're open and certain items get better and then it's different the next time. It's a difficult spot but greatly appreciated! Try the Cuban.

Nicks Deli & Catering

5.0

(6 reviews)

Great food and good prices. The service is excellent. I always have a great experience here.read more

Good food, diverse menu, friendly people, decent prices. It's great to find a deli that works like…read morethey all used to work. I stop by often and I recommend the place highly.

Little Town Deli

3.9

(8 reviews)

Needed a quick bite before a large event. Ordered the breakfast burrito with sausage. They were…read morebusy but the wait wasn't too long. The burrito was filled loved how the egg wasn't scrambled up into tiny pieces, it was more like a sheet. Very cheesy. Enjoyed seeing the regulars come in and out.

I was so enamoured with how cute this deli is! It's in a somewhat non-descript strip mall off the…read moreGreen (and perhaps the only tenant), but inside is adorable and small-town! The shop offers sandwiches to order, and every non-alcoholic drink you may want - Coke, Pepsi, hot chocolate, and of course coffee. The coffee is Omar Coffee, if brand matters to you. The BEC sandwich on a croissant is eggy with a wonderful buttery flavor. The cheese and bacon quantities are reasonable (what can I say, I care about the cheese!). They also have baked goods - cookies, brownies, yum! The decor is all local - posters from old Bethlehem fairs, paintings from local artists, and a classic wall of business cards! If you need a local service, I bet you'll find it there. There is also a restroom available.

Daily Bagel