Really really great. This is a bold statement from me, a NJ native. They accommodated two large events for us over three days. Delicious bagels. Tasty spreads. Phenomenal service. Very fair prices. Only thing keeping it from 5 stars is it's not in NJ. I'm glad I live 30 min away from the New Milford location, otherwise I'd be there every morning. read more

I do a "3-rule" which means if I have 3-BAD experiences in a row, I'm done! I've probably extended every extension I could here but I'm now officially done. Something changed, and dramatically! SLOW, SLOW and SLOWER... and that's when there's no other customers. I always go in off peak hours, always. Making things worse is the fact my last 2-orders weren't even correct! They're so easy and simple it's downright shocking they can be screwed up or wrong. Used to be my 'go-to.' Now I GO AWAY! read more

The bagels are always fresh, the coffee is just what I'm looking for. Whether you eat in or take out you will be satisfied. The employees are always joyful and helpful. There is a very good selection of other types of sandwiches and other breakfast items. Al read more

Sooo I'm new to the New Milford location! What a nice surprise... and they even have vegan sausage available. The bagel was cooked that morning you could tell how fresh it was! Soft deliciousness. I called in a to go order and picked up it promptly. read more

Bagelman - Vegan Sausage, Egg & Cheese on an everything bagel with a hash brown & hot sauce - Delis Near Me - New Milford, Connecticut

I love this place I get their breakfast chorizo burrito and it tastes so good I usually get a smoothie from them too I can honestly say this place is amazing read more

Not sure why my $6 "garden vegetable cream cheese" only had carrots in it but my bagels were big and tasty.

Sandwiches were great. Chicken salad tasted very fresh and my daughter enjoyed her grilled cheese. Lots of options besides bagels and bagel sandwiches which was helpful with kids. read more

delicious bagels! had a huge order but the customer service was wonderful and everything was prepared within minutes. will definitely be back! read more

It's not Tal, but Bagelman is not too shoddy! Bagels here are softer and more airy than what you might find at a top notch NYC bagelry, the crust not as chewy and well developed -- but I don't think we've found better in the New Milford area. Our family loves the saltier-than-average seasoning on the everything bagels, the fresh cream cheese, grilled cheese and breakfast sandwiches. I love the mellow, not-overly-acidic iced coffee. The staff are almost all high school-aged kids and most are very sweet and on top of their game. A few times, we've encountered kids who only very reluctantly came to the register to take orders, and who clearly did not want to be there -- but that's not the norm. Eating outside at one of the outdoor patio tables with our pup on a sunny autumn day is truly one of life's simple pleasures. read more

Foods great, service is good, but they keep forgetting stuff like bagels and added on hashbrowns on my bacon egg and cheeses. It's pretty frustrating considering they charge so much for a little bit of potato and you don't even get it half the time read more

they have good bagels, but they are an absolute mess in terms of customer service and order.

New location for an awesome deli. I regularly visited the Danbury location and was happy to see this one open while working in the area. Always a good sandwich - fresh, friendly and tons of variety. Bagels are amazing (of course) but the lunch options are great. Welcome to New Milford Bagelman! read more

Bagelman - New Bagelman location! - Delis Near Me - New Milford, Connecticut

My online order was completely wrong. Got billed for cream cheese and never received it. Asked for utensils never got them...but they were quick to charge me the extra money for my request to cut the bagels in half. Staff should double check orders and make sure they are prepared correctly. It's not my job to check your work. Still waiting for refund on cream cheese. read more

This Mother's Day I decided to avoid the busy overcrowded restaurants for brunch and decided to have it catered. I was happy to see on the menu choices for pre planned meals to choose from I had 11 guests and ordered the #3 choice which included scrambled eggs, sausages, bacon, bagels and rolls. I added pastries , home fries and a box of coffee. I was pleasantly surprised they provided 3 different types of cream cheeses , jelly and butter. Also proved cream and milk with sugar, plenty of plates, napkin's, coffee cups, utensils to eat with and to serve. The home fries were seasoned and flavorful to perfection! Everything I ordered was fresh, delicious and plentiful for all of us to have doubles, which we did and still had leftovers. The service was excellent! When I arrived, they immediately acknowledged us and accommodated me with additional items that I decided last minute even with a line of people waiting to order The person that prepped the meal, who I think was the owner/manager greeted us and helped carry everything to my car Overall a great experience and super pleased with the food. Definitely considering to make this a yearly tradition. Not to mention how fresh the bagels were. I'm just sad I didn't take a picture of my setup to share read more

Just ordered a late lunch Rueben on rye with onion rings. Have gotten breakfast bagels there several times and haven't been disappointed. I wasn't disappointed with this lunch either. Pastrami was very flavorful, with perfect amount of sauerkraut, and thousand island dressing. Was also very pleased that the onion rings are battered and not breaded. Will definitely order lunch again. read more

If you like bagelman in Brookfield, you'll love this one. It's better. The food seems more fresh, somehow. The service is great, I honestly hope this never leaves New Milford. I've been wanting Bagelman to open up here and my dream finally came true. Keep doing what you're doing Bagelman. Also, ambiance is chill vibes read more

First time here at this location. I know it changed from bagel Barn to this. Idiots didn't listen when I said "no peppers or onions." And it isn't like they place them on top so I could pick them off. They're chopped up and mixed in. Learn to listen carefully. It's a shame- the people seem nice. They Just seem stupid. I've been here to pick up food myself, and ordered online. They need to try harder. And just keep to bagels. Ordering food-they don't seem to understand your order. Hard of hearing? . read more

Don't ask me if I'm waiting for food when THIRTY MINUTES AGO you asked me for the name of the order and then proceed not to give it to me.

The bagels were fresh and delicious will order again the people were very nice. The place was very clean and all the food was fresh and prepared well. Again very fresh and delicious, will buy again, read more

First time and never again. Paid 9$ for 1/2 dozen of bagels to go . Rip off . Could not say a word because I had a guest with me . Just bagels. read more

Came back, this time earlier at 11:15. They were fast, clean, and staff was friendly. Very happy I came back!

The bagels are good. It took a longish time for my order to be ready even though it was pretty basic.

These bagels are amazing! As a former New Yorker, I can honestly say that these are the best in the area! And the owner is unbelievably gracious. He went out of the way to ensure that we had our order Thanksgiving morning even though there was a delivery mix-up from Seamless. (My sister, who was in from NYC for Thanksgiving, also gave the bagels (and the muffins) rave reviews. read more