I called Atlanta Speed Shop to see if they could do the machine work on my '73 MGB engine and I spoke to Julius, the owner, who seemed polite and knowledgeable, and said he had experience with MGBs. I asked if they could also assemble the pistons and bearings into the block, and Julius said they certainly could, and estimated the assembly labor to be around $400. Perfect.
I dropped off the engine and cylinder head along with all the parts that I had purchased myself. Their workspace was bright, clean, and looked organized. Julius gave me a rough estimate of the cost, saying the total would be around $2,000 (including the fee to service the head and assemble the short-block). He estimated the job would take at least a few weeks. We both understood that the price and timing could change based on what they might find as they went. I authorized whatever additional work was needed.
After 9 weeks the block and head were ready and the bill was $3,400. It took a little longer than I wanted and cost a bit more than I was hoping, but as long as the job was done right I was happy - until I got home and got the block un-bagged and was shocked to find a huge gouge in the surface of the deck. I called Julius to ask what happened and he said the tech that did the resurfacing dropped the block and caused a gouge that was too deep to be milled off, and that he had "forgotten to tell me about it". Julius admitted that if the gouge were any nearer to the cylinder it would have rendered the block unusable, but he was "pretty sure it wouldn't be a problem".
I pointed out that he had not forgotten to add the $150 resurfacing charge to the bill though, and Julius stated that even though the resurfacing had damaged the block, "they did resurface the block" but he eventually agreed to refund me the $150 for the botched resurfacing and then he begrudgingly offered me an additional $50 off "for my trouble" and he'd mail me a check for the $200. After a few weeks with no check from them, I wrote it off to a lesson learned. By that time I had re-assembled the rest of the engine and got it into the vehicle and it was running perfectly. After a few trips around the neighborhood to ensure there were no leaks or issues, I took it out to put a few miles on it and begin the break-in procedure. The engine was running perfectly, idling smoothly, no leaks, oil pressure and temperature readings were good - for almost 8 miles.
Then the engine blew out a core plug, resulting in an instant and total loss of all coolant. By the time I got out of the travel lanes and safely to the side of the road, the damage had been done. The core plug(s) had been installed improperly and one had failed, and the instant coolant loss and subsequent temperature spike had blown the head gasket and damaged the head.
When I called Julius to demand an answer, and to remind him that I had not even received the $200 refund, Julius said that he had "forgotten" about sending the check and said, "The core plugs in an MBG are tricky, which is why we didn't charge you to install them" (???).
His idea of a warranty (and customer service) was another promise to send me the $200 refund, and that he'd "throw in a set of core plugs" that he had laying around (retail value $2.99). So after 9 weeks and $3,400 (and another $2,000 in parts) I'm back where I started. I have a damaged block, a blown head gasket, a damaged head, and I need to pull the engine back out to re-do the improperly installed core plugs.
When I finally received the refund check (and the core plugs) Julius basically admitted that they blew it because he included a handwritten note that read "by cashing this $200 check I was agreeing to not communicate with anyone about this". I mailed the check back to him.
I can't say that Atlanta Speed Shop is the worst machine shop in the world, but I can say that they're the worst machine shop I've ever dealt with. Your mileage may vary, but after a $3,400 rebuild by Atlanta Speed Shop, my mileage was about 8 miles.
-and just like Mickey's review below, when I posted a review on facebook they deleted it and blocked me. read more